Showing posts with label Weimar. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Weimar. Show all posts

02 June 2026

Lutetia Hotel, French culture German WW2

The Lutetia hotel was one of Paris’ landmarks, a monument to the city’s cultural memory where art, history and luxury met. In Dec 1910 Lutetia was opened by Marguerite and Aristide Boucicaut, visionary founders of Le Bon Marché. They created a hotel to welcome the department store’s wealthy clientele and reflect the cosmopolitan Left Bank. The result was unlike any other in Paris: a fusion of Art Nouveau exuberance and nascent Art Deco restraint, its grand façade with sculptural reliefs.

front entrance and facade
 
Lutetia always attracted the elite, wealthy visitors, artists, intellectuals and writers who helped define C20th culture. James Joyce corrected proofs of Ulysses inside, Picasso, Matisse and André Gide were regulars and Josephine Baker gave jazz rhythm to its salons. A unique blend of high society and arty avant-garde!

Author Jane Rogoyska focused on this fashionable grand hotel from 1933-45 in Hotel Exile. She wrote of the hotel’s war events before, in and after the German occupation of France. She wrote of the destruction of German & Austrian culture, once the Nazis seized power in 1933.

Germans forced into exile in France included many literary stars of Habsburg Vienna & Weimar Republic: Heinrich & Thomas Mann, Berthold Brecht, Walter Benjamin, Alfred Kerr, Hannah Arendt, Joseph Roth, Franz Werfel & Stefan Zweig and James Joyce. They escaped with their lives but mostly lost their livelihoods. In Paris they lived in solitude or in cheap hotels. They also faced the hostility of French bureaucracy against Germans.

In 1935, a millionaire genius of international communism Willi Münzenberg led the Lutetia Committee. Despite his leadership (supported by E.M Forster & Aldous Huxley), no German Popular Front emerged and alliance between communists & social democrats ended in Aug 1939 with the Nazi-Soviet pact. The leader of the French communists, Maurice Thorez welcomed Der Pakt as a stroke of genius on Stalin’s part that would avert another European war.

WW2 broke out later when many of the exiles had already managed to re-escape to U.S, UK or Switzerland and the German army occupied Paris. This hotel was soon controlled by Abwehr-German Military Intelligence Service (in 1940), a German organisation standing on the Nazi regime fringes. Arthur Koestler, a Hungarian Jewish communist, joined the Foreign Legion to escape the bureaucrats who interned him. But eventually some exiles, inspired by Heinrich Mann, risked fighting back by forming Lutetia Committee of Germany’s Popular Front against Fascism. They met in the elegant Lutetia salons.

Colonel Friedrich Rudolph decided to requisition the French staff, as well as the hotel. The concierge, cooks, waiters and chambermaids continued to serve their German “guests” with their normal respect, and Manager Marcel Chappaz ensured everyone’s comfort. Abwehr commanders stayed until the end. They regrouped in Berlin, where Col Rudolph was gaoled re a July plot to assassinate Hitler.

Meanwhile the political deportees were registered in reception, where the hotel staff were assisted by boy scouts. Many of their patients were the true heroes of France’s war, all that remained of that small minority who had found the courage to fight back after the military debacle of 1940. The survivors returned in a terrible state, here described in vivid detail. Some were wasted with lice or contagious with typhus or TB. Some Lutetia’s staff died following contact with the first postwar guests who they said nothing.

cocktails

Rogoyska’s thoroughly researched account, using secondary sources, is a little less convincing when she generalises about events beyond the hotel’s revolving doors. The Abwehr’s effectiveness in Occupied France was not notably hindered by the dominant role given to rival SS-SD. In any case, the hotel became a place of surveillance and control, not murders. In fact fear of being handed over to the Gestapo gave the Abwehr interrogators a very persuasive argument. Nor did the Gestapo’s brutality lead to an increase in volunteering for the French Resistance. All the Abwehr agents sent to England were either executed or used by MI5, and the deception sent to Rudolph’s Berlin mates was important re D-Day.

Rogoyska suggested that the care given to the deportees absolved the Lutetia from guilt over its wartime role. Or not. In 1955 Col. Rudolph paid a return visit to Paris, a place of happy memories, and cautiously entered the hotel where Manager Chappaz was on duty. He greeted the Colonel warmly and offered him lunch as a hotel guest.

After Liberation, it took on a humane role, serving as a reception centre for deportees and prisoners-of-war back in France. Families gathered searching for news about loved ones, and the name Lutetia started to reflect loss, reunion and remembrance. This era cemented its place in the nation’s collective memory, lending it rare gravity.

Postwar Lutetia re-earned its role as an ideal of Parisian life, remaining a favourite of visiting notables, artists and designers, and its brasserie became a fixture of St-Germain. But the faded interiors, once fresh and modern, had faded. In 2014, its owners closed the property.

What followed were ambitious restorations. Trusted to architect Jean-Michel Wilmotte, the 4-year project sought to restore Lutetia’s historic features while reinventing it for a new era of luxury. Frescoes hidden beneath layers of paint were uncovered and meticulously restored, marble floors were relaid, and spaces allowed more light. The number of rooms was reduced, creating larger, more comfortable suites with St-Germain views. Eucalyptus wood, Murano glass and Carrara marble glamourised the interiors.

view over Paris

When the hotel reopened in 2018, it became a legend reborn. The restored Bar Joséphine, with its shimmering frescoes and live jazz, once again became a magnet for Parisians and travellers alike. The brasserie reestablished the Lutetia as a culinary destination, balancing tradition with innovation. In keeping with contemporary hospitality trends, the creation of the Akasha Holistic Wellbeing Centre, with a long pool, hammam, sauna, spas & treatment rooms, brought serenity and modernity.

In Ap 2025, Lutetia joined the Mandarin Oriental Hotel Group. Now Mandarin Oriental Lutetia Paris retained its status as the Left Bank’s only officially designated Palace hotel, a recognition of its heritage and standards. And it gained from Mandarin’s global reach.

Lutetia is now a living history, a Parisian institution that witnessed C20th triumphs and traumas, and still embodying the Left Bank spirit. The hotel offers an immersion into Paris itself, so discover the city through its artistic and intellectual heritage: literary cafés, art galleries, Left Bank boutiques and museums. Thanks to Hotel Exile: Paris in the Shadow of War by Jane Rogoyska, 2026

music area



29 November 2025

Françoise Fren­k­el's vital WW2 memoirs

Françoise Fren­k­el (1889-1975) was born to Jewish parents in Piotr­ków Poland, near Lodz. After an introduction saying how she became fascinated with books as a child, she continued with her studies at the Sorbonne and did an apprenticeship with an anti­qu­arian bookseller. Not surprisingly, she soon developed a profess­ional passion for literature, especially French literature.

Francoise Frenkel, Rien où poser sa tête
Published 1945
Leboncoin

Germany In 1921 Françoise set up the first French-language bookshop in Berlin, La Maison du Livre, recognising the appetite for French culture in Berlin after WW1. Her business successfully appealed to classy people: diplomats, aut­hors, artists. In the heady years of the Weimar Republic (1918-33) and after, her bookshop became a cultural centre in the city.

She worked with her Russian-born husband Simon Raich­enstein until 1933. Ident­ity papers were denied him by French auth­orities who is­s­ued him with a deportation order. He was taken to Drancy detention camp near Paris and killed in Ausch­witz in July 1942.

Frenkel’s dream job lasted until 1939 but the end was seen with the descent into Naz­ism, racial gen­o­cide and the start of WW2. Nazi officers & Hitler Youths crept over the streets, destroying Jewish-run businesses, smashing windows and burning synagog­ues. Krist­allnacht Nov 1938 was the worst.

Françoise had to escape to France, just before war broke out. Only days after her depart­ure from Germany, Nazi Germany bomb­ed Paris, causing terrible destruction. Frenkel would have stayed in Paris but she was forced to keep mov­ing. In the meantime Mar­shal Philippe Petain’s regime remained in Vichy as the nominal gov­ern­ment of France, op­erating as a client state of Nazi Germ­any from Nov 1942 on.

Françoise and many other city residents sought refuge in the loveliest parts of France - first Avignon (Sth), then Nice (S.E). Frenkel her­self was constantly moved from safe house to safe house, from refugee hotel to messy refugee hotel. Nice was overrun with ref­ug­ees who were hiding in poor living cond­itions; families were split up. Françoise understood that she surv­ived only because some stran­g­ers risked their lives to protect her. She escaped many crises with Nazi police officers rounding up Jews for concentration camps, but informants were clearly everywhere.

Just as it was looking as if most non-Jews were either brutal them­selves or uncaring about Jews, her memoir became a tap dance bet­ween acknowledging human cruelty and being in awe of human kind­ness. In fact her most valuable insights were into the behaviour of French people specifically under Occupation in Vichy France.

Deportation of Foreign Jews from Paris 
to Drancy detention camp.

Frenkel conveyed a huge debt of gratitude in her work. I would not have. My grandfather searched Eastern Europe for his sister, from the last letter he received (1942) until his 1971 death. My father-in-law searched for his brother, sister-in-law and 6 nieces/nephews after his liberation from Ukraine; all had been exterm­in­ated except one child.

Switzerland  From Dec 1942 on Françoise attempted to reach neutral Switzerland, her bids for safety being des­perate. In her book, she detailed how in 1943 she finally smug­gled herself across the border from Haute-Savoie. Eventually her memoir Rien où poser sa tête/No Place to Lay One’s Head was written on the shores of Lake Lucerne in Switzerland and published in 1945 by Geneva-based publish­ers Jeheber.

What happened in Françoise Frenkel's subsequent life? She returned to live in Nice and died there in 1975. But not even a photo of the author exists. Very limited extra informat­ion came from a list of persons who were given per­mis­sion to cros­s­ the border into Switz­erland during WW2 and who obtained a resid­ence permit there. Those documents are now in State Archives of Gen­eva.

After the 1945 publication, the memoir was largely forgotten until recently when a copy was accidentally discovered in Nice. In the preface of the book’s newest publication, French novelist/Nobel Prize winner Patrick Modiano added to the story of refugees fleeing terror the world over.

Of course Frenkel’s book reminded me of Anne Frank’s Diary of a Young Girl, the girl who survived in hiding in Amsterdam until the family was deported to death camps in Poland in 1944. Miraculously her father Otto Frank survived and miraculously he found Anne’s diary. And Catherine Taylor  added another comparison - Irène Némirovsky’s unfin­ish­ed novel Suite Française, which was miraculously discovered by her daughter, decades after Némirovsky perished at Aus­chwitz-Birkenau. Like Rien où poser sa tête, these two books works were lucky to be published. But unlike Frenkel, Anne Frank became a well known sym­bol of the Holocaust.

Division of France between German Occupied Zone and Vichy Free Zone
highlighting Paris, Drancy, Nice (N) in France and Geneva (G) in Switzerland

Frenkel’s quest for refuge in war-torn Europe reminds us all of our contemp­orary debates reg­arding refugees. Like the author back in WW2, many unlucky citizens in the modern world need to flee starv­ation, war or ethnic oppression. No country wants them today, so fleeing is still an alien­ating, unforgiving journey of necessity. The story today is as tragic today as it was when my own husband was carried over the mountains between home (Czechoslovakia) and the DP camps in Austria after the war. Worse, probably.

 
No Place To Lay one's Head
by Francoise Frenkel
translated by Stephanie Smee, 2019
Amazon

Bookshop in Berlin (alternative title) by Francoise Frenkel
Booktopia

Penguin Random House's Vintage published a translation of Frenkel’s French book, Rien où poser sa tête in 2017 as A Bookshop in Berlin. Hopefully the orig­in­al style was capt­ured in English by Australian translator Steph­an­ie Smee. For a detailed review, read Brigette Manion in Asymptote.



03 June 2025

Miracles & Madness in German art Guardian


Nolde's Crucifix, 1912
was in Städtisches Museum in Halle

I’ve not read The Gallery of Miracles & Madness: Insanity, Art and Hit­l­er’s First Mass-Murder Programme by Charlie English, 2021 because I was more interested in the fate of Germany’s degenerate artists than in men­t­al patients in asylums. So here is Kathryn Hughes’ fine review.

In 1922 Heidelberg psychiatrist Hans Prinzhorn’s book Artistry of the Mentally Ill fired up the art world. Since the C19th, doctors in asylums pored ov­er the drawings, paintings and sculptures of their patients. Could doctors spot schizophrenia just by looking at how someone coloured in the sky? Could they discern neurosis in an patients who simply painted models with incomplete faces?

But using art diagnostically was not Prinzhorn’s issue. His interest in the patients’ art was aesthetic and philosophic eg when a delusional Ham­b­urg metalworker Franz Bühler produced The Choking Angel, an intense version of God’s messenger with a shining crown and a torturer’s face, Prinz­horn seriously compared the work to Albrecht Dürer’s!

Bühler, Angel, 1909
The Guardian

This was certainly not art to soothe the soul, but of course soul-soothing was not what mod­ern art was about. From the late C19th, Gustav Klimt, Vincent van Gogh, Edvard Munch and Egon Schiele focused on describing the agony of modern selfhood. Feel the ris­ing tide of madness in Munch’s horrified scream or Schiele’s warped bodies. And it was that madness, a heroic refusal to fall for the easy remedies of civilised soc­iety, that Prinzhorn’s asylum artists easily accessed. While sane art­ists scraped off layers of social condit­ioning and acad­emic train­ing before they could reach Freud’s hidden parts of themsel­ves, asylum in­mates had a shortcut to their unconscious. Rather than being patronised, these artists of the interior were to be revered and copied.

Paul Klee, teaching pictorial theory of form at Bauhaus, greeted the images in Prinzhorn’s book rapturously. In these oddly shattered shapes, with jagged outlines, perspective shifts and incomplete­ness, Klee saw an authent­ic response to all post-WW1 world crises. See his Prophetic Woman (1923), a prim­itive figure in­debted to Lamb of God, a dense geometric pen-ink drawing by an insane banker.

Angel of Suffocation by Franz Karl Bühler, 1909 on book cover of:
Artistry of the Mentally Ill: Psychology and Psychopathology of Configuration
Hans Prinzhorn, Amazon

Among the Surrealists, Prinzhorn’s book also succeeded. Max Ernst drew inspiration from August Natterer, an Upper Swabia engineer who believed he was a direct Napoleonic descendant. Natterer’s intensely detailed, densely coloured works, which came to him in a vision, provided in­spiration for Max Ernst’s 1931 Oedipus. Salvador Dalí borrowed from madmen but, to his credit, tried hard to go insane as a way of improving his own painting, never quite managing it.

Having failed 2 entrance exams to pre-WW1 Vienna’s Academy of Fine Arts, self-taught art­ist Adolf Hitler scraped a living by copying postcards of pleasant Munich views and selling them in bars. Until he ended up in a Bavarian prison, screaming at the admitting psychologist! A ps­ych­ologist had assessed Hitler as a mor­bid psychopath, with hysteria and an inclin­ation toward a mystical mind­set. Hitler was imprisoned for his part in the 1923 Beer Hall Putsch, in which he led 2,000 Nazi storm­troopers in a failed attempt to end the Weimar Republic. His fort­unes were about to change and within 10 years he was Chancellor of Germany, but his ideas about art did not change. In fact they hard­ened into a dogma that be­came a founding principle of the Third Reich’s German culture and pure Aryan race.

Hitler’s outrage at modern art focused on abstract, distorted and angry works. This worsened in WW1’s devastating aft­ermath in Germany, exaggerated colours, expressive brush strokes and gory subjects only ex­acerbated Germany’s societal divisions, and econom­ic and political cris­es. For Hitler, on the other hand, Healthy Art was an art that painted exactly what was in front of its nose, plus some ex­tra swagger. People should look like Ary­ans, with firm limbs and rosy cheeks, and land­scapes should resemble the tourist postcards he once churned out. So the Füh­rer introduced legislation to en­sure that painters followed his rules.

Any art that did not follow these rules was Degenerate, seen as a deliberate ploy by the Jewish-Bolsheviks to destroy Germany. To ensure this didn’t happen, Hitler ordered the confiscation of all trouble­some art from Ger­man galleries and museums in 1937. This collected treasure, includ­ing a number of pieces by the Prinzhorn artists Klee, Marc Chagall and Otto Dix, was put on display in the Degenerate Art Exhibit­ion that year. Lat­er iterations of the immensely popular show cont­rasted modern­ist art with art made by the Heidelberg patients, in order to show the conn­ect­ion between biological and artistic degeneracy.

Otto Dix. Storm Troops Advancing under Gas, 1924.
Kunstsammlung Nordhein-Westfalen, Dusseldorf.

By this time the patients were extremely vulnerable. Most profess­ional artists whose work featured in the Degenerate Art Exhib­ition had gone. Klee was in Switzerland, Chagall, Dalí and Ernst were in New York, while Oskar Schlemmer and Dix were in hiding. So there was no-one left to speak up for the asylum artists when, in autumn 1939, Hitler set out to exterminate them.

The rationale was eugenics. Psychiatric illnesses like schizophrenia were heritable, so it made sense to purge the un­for­tunates who “rep­res­ented life unworthy of life”. Actually cost-cutting was possibly the more immediate driver: long-term psychiatric care cost money and, as Ger­many prepared for war with Brit­ain, the money could be better spent on tanks. 30+ of Prinzhorn’s artists were among the 250,000 in­mates put into gas chambers early in the war. The lucky ones got away with forced st­er­ilisation.

Great Exhibition of German Art catalogue cover, 1937. 
ancient, classical, proud

Charlie English’s book was as beautiful as it was bleak. Thank you Kathryn Hughes

18 January 2025

Weimar Republic 1918-33: great culture & democracy

Pres Paul von Hindenburg
Wiki

The usual image of the Weimar Republic was one of political instability, economic crisis and cultural decadence. That always seemed ridiculous to me since this republic was Germany’s new system of democratic government after the Second Reich collapsed. The name was chosen because Berlin was still in the midst of revolution when the Imperial period ended in 1918. So the first Assembly for the new Republic was held in Jan 1919 in Weimar instead.

My best German era started when Weimar Republic politics became democratic, social freedoms arrived and vibrant artistic movements blossomed. The tricky cond­itions imposed by the Treaty of Versailles and economic instab­ility only made governmental support more urgent.

Intellectual and political democracy
The Weimar era was noted for these amazing successes:
1.Political power was rested in the Reichstag
2.Universal voting for ALL adults led to a genuine democracy
3.unemployment insurance was introduced
4.working weeks were reduced from 50 hours to 46.
5.free speech was guaranteed.
6.religious freedom was guaranteed
7.sciences were promoted in the universities and scientists supported at work

Arts The Bauhaus Academy opened in 1919 where expressionist artists overcame the rigid traditions of the main art academies. The new style which flourished in the German-speaking nations was characterised by distorted forms, sharp colour contrasts, dark shadows, weird angles and distorted id­ent­it­ies. Bauhaus was great for young architects when a new wave of designers foll­ow­ed Walter Grop­ius (1883-1969) instead of traditional or cl­ass­ical architects. It foll­owed a new post-war Western spirit when cultural modernity would be Germany’s reparations to the world. What happened when the learned Weimar Rep­ublic suff­er­ed high inflation?

A woman exchanges vegetables for baskets of money during the hyperinflation of 1923 
Law & Liberty

In Berlin post-WW1, Christian Schad became an model of New Objectivity,  painting cool, sharp portraits of his social milieu. He painted the androgynous Sonja, with fashionable cloth­es, cropped hair and smoking Camel cigarettes, all attributes of the independent New Woman. New Object­ivity spread through various cities, creating cynical depictions of injured war veter­ans, jobless workers and war profiteers. They portrayed an scarred society, denouncing WW1's devastating effects.

Many works railed against both capitalism and WW1's effects on society. Otto Dix’s anti-militarist The Skat Players 1920 marked his trans­ition to the social­ly critical New Realism, depicting 3 hideously disfigured office­rs in a café playing skat card game. And Dix completed 4 panels in a triptych, like a church altarpiece, depicting horrid morb­idity with putrefied flesh, gangrene and death. Was Dix reflecting the German nationalism that was surging in the more tense political atmosphere in the Depression? His critics certainly hated his anti-German, hypercritical views of WW1 and post-war society.

George Grosz, 
Eclipse of the Sun, 1926
Weimar Republic

Films Through the 1920s Fritz Lang made ambitious films, includ­ing the al­l­egorical melo­drama Destiny (1921) and Dr Mabuse The Gambler (1922). In 1924 he first travelled to film companies in New York and Hollywood. Lang’s first project back in Germany was the futuristic, expensive master-piece Metropolis (1927). The plot showed a repressive society with exp­loited workers, lazy rulers and emotionless robots. Lang created his vis­ually detailed films where he blended shots of miniatures with live action. After a crime film Spies in 1928, Lang returned to science fict­ion for Woman in the Moon (1929). M (1931) was a German thriller, filled with horrifying light­ing and sound. It was Fritz Lang’s first sound film, starring a chill­ing Peter Lorre, Lang’s greatest global success.

Wedekind’s early play formed the basis for Viennese director G.W Pabst's famous silent film Pand­ora's Box in 1929 star­ring Louise Brooks as Lulu, a masterpiece of C20th opera. Fritz Kohn-Kortner was an Austrian stage-actor who became one of the era's most famous silent actors. Talkies arrived in late 1929, producing a flourish of German film. Sound production and distribution were quickly taken up and soon Germany had 3,800 cinemas with sound. G.W Pabst's version of Bertolt Brecht's The Three-penny Opera 1931 and Lang's M 1931 were landmark talkies.

Berlin jazz girls with mandolins at a 1929 cabaret
A Midsummer Night’s Dream

Cabaret were nightclubs where patrons sat at tables, entertained by singers, dancers and comedians on a stage like Moulin Rouge. Berlin’s first cabaret nightclub (1901) was during the reign of Kaiser Wilhelm II when German cabarets were not permitted to perform lewd humour, bawdy dancing or political satire. But by 1920s, Berlin became known for its high living and vibrant urban life. Some cabarets were patronised by gay men and lesbians; once forced to conceal their sexuality, they used the cabaret scene to openly display it. Right wingers were horrified.

So what was the impact of Weimar democracy and cultural dominance? The Weimar Years: Rise and Fall 1918-1933 by Frank McDonough suggested that finding a detailed narrative history of Weimar Germany was tricky. Other writers focused on specific aspects of the era where the rise of Adolf Hitler dominated history. Fortunately The Weimar Years was NOT a history of Hitler’s rise to power. 

The first key man was Chancellor and Foreign Minister Gustav Stresemann, the man McDonough considered the only politician who could have saved German democracy. Stresemann’s diplomatic skills inspired political compromise within the Republic, while his peaceful foreign policy vision triumphed at Locarno, sparking a new spirit of friendship towards Germany and winning him the Nobel Peace Prize before his death in 1929. I had never heard this mentioned.


“The second was President Paul von Hindenburg, widely seen in the 1920s as a hero. Initially non-partisan, the old monarchist and ex-military leader soon reverted to the right. From 1930 he governed in accordance with his right-wing preferences and gave little thought to the views of the elected Reichstag. But as McDonough argued, the blame did not lie with individuals: there were structural issues with Weimar democracy baked into its constitution, Article 48 of which enabled Hindenburg to disregard the Reichstag. Proportional representation made coalition government difficult. Issues with the system, more than the economic misery, inspired Germans to vote for the Nazis. So the mortal damage was dealt by Hindenburg. Thank you to Frank McDonough for his excellent history.

Weimar Republic, 1919–1933
MoMA
Press to expand



14 December 2024

Stefan Weintraub's top German jazz band!

Austrian artist Max Oppenheimer (1885-1954) painted in 1927, capturing the rough energy of a music that was taking Berlin’s nightlife by storm in the interwar era.

Max Oppenheimer, Weintraub's Syncopators, 1927. 
Jewish Museum Berlin

Used to illustrate brochures advertising Stefan Weintraub's (1897–1981) concerts in late 1920s, it showed the group as a quartet, though they often performed with 5+ musicians. Stefan Weintraub and Horst Graff, the founding duo, starred on the drums and saxophone respectively; and they were equally as talented on the piano or clarinet. Weintraub’s band stood out for their range of skills, both in their instruments and the genres of music they performed.

They played symphonic jazz, swing, waltz and schlager, catchy German-language pop songs, wittier than contemporary equivalents. Their biggest hits included My Sweetheart Wants to Take Me Sailing on Sunday and My Gorilla Has a Villa at the Zoo. Berlin’s most creative cabaret composer, Friedrich Hollaender, joined the band in the 1920s and replaced Weintraub on the piano.

They also performed with Josephine Baker and the Tiller Girls Dance Group, and unsurprisingly the Syncopators provided the musical strains to the defining song of the Weimar Republic’s cultural flourishing eg Marlene Dietrich’s Falling in Love Again (1930). Even better was when the band accompanied Marlene Dietrich’ cabaret songs in the famous film The Blue Angel (1930).

Marlene Dietrich and her favourite jazz band
Inside Story

See several other exiles who were brought about by the rise of Fascism, behind the Oppenheimer portrait of the band. The artist himself left Berlin in 1931, emigrating to Switzerland then US. The painting’s owner, prominent lawyer Hugo Staub, fled the city in March 1933, the artwork remaining in his Kurfürstendamm flat.

The rise of Nazism slowed the Syncopators’ booming career. Though the Nazis dismissed jazz as degenerate Negro music, for a few years the band continued to play Berlin venues under the name Die Weintraubs. However after seeing the Reichstag Fire in Feb 1933, the band decided to embark on an international tour (and never returned). Weintraubs Syncopators were never officially banned, but since the man whose name they bore and most of their members were Jewish, their future was doomed (Dümling).

These international musical celebrities of the 1930s left on a 4-year journey across Europe and Russia, in exile from the German Third Reich’s antisemitism. After successes in the Far East and Japan, they moved to Australia. This band of mainly Jewish musicians arrived in Sydney in 1937. The decision of some of them to stay brought them into conflict with the aggressively protectionist Musicians’ Union of Australia. The Union’s wish was to spread available work among a maximum number of Australian musicians, particularly in the difficult Depression-shadowed years of the 1930s. In a similar way, the counterpoint of nationalities within the group was a source of concern to the Australian authorities and grief to the musicians once war began.

Weintraubs Syncopators rehearsing
Weimar Berlin

When war came the men were forced to come to terms with a change in their status, from jazz celebs to enemy aliens. Accused of spying activities in Russia, they were interned, ending the band. In 1941 German, Polish and Chilean national members in its lineup were interned as Enemy Aliens. As Dümling discovered in the National Archives of Australia, a British officer had betrayed them as Soviet spies; for lack of proof for the allegations either way, the Syncopators were locked behind razor wire. Only after the war could most of the band’s members stay in Sydney but drifted apart, working as mechanics etc. Weiberg never played music professionally again. Read Albrecht Dümling The Vanished Musicians to see what happened to the other musos in Australia.

What happened to the art in WW2 and in the post-war years was unclear, but in 1962 the work was auctioned to an ex-Berlin property developer living in Canada, Hugo Staub. For 50 years it adorned his family homes in Montreal & Ottawa, then loaned to Canada’s National Gallery, The painting was sold with the permission of Staub’s descendants who received an ex gratia payment from the sale. The individuals linked together by Oppenheimer’s painting attended its unveiling in Berlin’s Jewish Museum in 2024, giving a sense of completion. To see the band return to the city they left behind, a day after the Reichstag fire, was essential.

Summary They could play 7 instruments each, and critics hailed them as the best jazz combo in 1920s Berlin; Marlene Dietrich and Josephine Baker were keen to secure them as their backing band. But after the Nazi takeover, and frustrating years of exile and internment in Australia, the legacy of Weintraub’s Syncopators was lost.

 A 100 years after opening, the Weimar republic’s best jazz band returned from Canada to the city that had once adored them, not in real life but on canvas. Now it is on permanent public display in Berlin’s Jewish Museum where the public can see the men safely return to the city they had left behind, after the Reichstag fire. Many thanks to Philip Oltermann who wrote Celebrated again: Portrait of German Jazz-age Pioneers Lost.

10 September 2024

Polish musician Szpilman/Adrien Brody in The Pianist

Władysław Szpilman (1911-2000) was born in Sosnowiec Poland into a cultured family. He showed an early talent for the piano, training in Warsaw, then in the 1920s continuing in Berlin. In the most exciting art and musical environment anywhere, Weimar Germany, Szpilman studied piano and composition at the Ber­l­in Acad­emy of Arts, working with Franz Schreker. When the Nazis took power in 1933 he returned to his family in Warsaw and worked as a pianist for Polish Radio. By 1939, he had composed many popular songs and classical works, and became quite famous.

Szpilman and his parents pre-war, elegantly dressed
In Your Pocket

This promising musical career was stopped by Germany's invas­ion of Poland, Sept 1939. Szpilman & his family were driven into the War­saw ghetto, along with thousands of other local Jews. To prot­ect them from starvation, Szpilman played piano at Café Nowaczesna Sienna St, a happy gathering place for Nazis, while thous­ands outside were starv­ing. He also worked at other cafés and night­clubs, possible bec­ause Szpil­man had strong connections to many other artists in the ghetto. Ironically Café Nowaczesna had once been frequented by the Jewish elite.

Tragically in mid 1942, when packed deport­ations from the gh­etto began, Szpilman saw his relatives and friends being sent on trucks but managed to keep his immediate family safe. Alas they too were finally put on board for transport to The East, Treblinka. As they were boarding the train, an unknown hand pulled him away to safety, and he watched as his family was sent to the gas chambers.

Jewish families being deported from Warsaw Ghetto
by German soldiers, Yad Vashem

Warsaw deportees put on the cattle cars
by German soldiers, Wiki

Unable to leave the ghetto due to the constant threats, Sz­pilman relied on the kindness of colleagues to live. In the following months, Warsaw was largely destroyed; Szpilman barely survived, moving from destroyed buildings.

After months of a hungry life, it was in winter 1945 that Szpilman met the German officer who saved his life. The film’s cl­osing scenes involved Szpilman's meeting with Capt Wilm Hosenfeld who accidentally found the hiding place.

Once the war ended, Szpilman returned to Polish Radio and to composing. He also gave concert performances as a soloist and mem­ber of chamber ensembles. He stopped touring in 1986 to devote him­self to composing, and died in Warsaw in 2000. By then Szpilman was a very popular musician of post-war Poland. But until his biography was published in German and English, and espec­ially Roman Polanski’s great film, Szpilman was virtually unk­n­own in the West.

Szpilman at Polish Radio after WW2
In Your Pocket

The Pianist (2002) told the true story of acclaimed musician Wl­ad­ys­­law Szpilman, who strugg­led to keep his family alive in WW2 but failed. Directed by Roman Polanski, filmed in Poland and released in 2002, the drama was inspired by the autobiography, The Pianist: Extraordinary True Story of One Man’s Survival in Warsaw 1939-45, and followed the radio station pianist as he went on a terrible journey in the Warsaw Ghetto once it was sealed off in Nov 1940.

 What music was used in The Pianist film? Polanski’s screen adaptation demanded a melancholy soundtrack to match its sombre themes, and no one suited better than Romantic composer, Frédéric Chopin. Approp­riately, Szpilman had often shared his love of Chopin with list­en­ers while working on air, so many of Chopin’s master­­pieces featured in the film, played on the soundtrack album by Polish classical pianist and Chopin Competition winner, Janusz Olejniczak.

Did young American method actor star Adrien Brody really play the piano in The Pianist? Polanski made Brody practise the piano for four hours a day, until he could master passages from some of Chopin’s finest works. Brody also made a lot of personal sacrifices to live the life of the tragic Polish pianist. To embody a man who had lost everything, Brody left his girlfriend and went on a severe diet, losing 14 ks. Despite ha­v­ing very little energy, starving himself to experience the des­per­ation that comes with hun­g­er, Brody persisted with his piano lessons. There was an empti­ness that came with starving that he hadn’t experienced.

actor Adrien Brody, playing piano in the film
Facebook

Brody also spent time self-educating on the Holocaust, even though his maternal grandmother was a Hungarian Jew. “I was depressed for a year after The Pianist. And I don’t suffer from depression generally, but this was mourning. I was very dist­urbed by what I embraced in making that film, and of the awareness that it opened up in me. I gave up my apartment, sold my car, dis­con­nected the phones and left. I took two bags and my keyboard and moved to Europe.”

The film won the Palme d’Or at the 2002 Cannes Film Festival. At the 2003 Academy Awards, The Pianist won Oscars for Best Director (Roman Polanski), Best Adapted Screenplay (Ronald Harwood) and Best Actor (Adrien Brody), and was nominated for Best Picture.

This was called Roman Polanski’s strongest and most person­ally felt movie, given that as a child Polanski survived the Kraków ghetto and lost beloved family in the camps.





21 November 2023

A Einstein (1917-55): Germany, Switzerland, Belgium, UK, USA

Albert and his first wife Mileva

German-born Albert Einstein (1879-1955) became the world’s most fam­ous physicist. I briefly examined his early life and first wife Mil­eva Marić (1875–1948) whom he married in Zurich in 1903. In 1905 he published his vital scientific papers that made him famous. By 1908, he was rec­ognised as a lead­ing scientist at Bern Uni, completing his work on the general theory of relativity.

In 1917, as director of the new Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Ph­ysics in Berlin, Einstein re-took German citizenship. Meanwhile the publication of experimental evid­ence supporting his general relat­iv­ity theory made huge impacts in acad­eme. After their 1919 divorce, Mileva took their two sons to Zurich, so Albert could immediately marry his wife-cousin Elsa and adopt her children.

Einstein first visited New York in 1921 where he was offic­ially welcomed by organiser Chaim Weizmann, President of the World Zionist Organisation. This was followed by weeks of lectures and re­c­eptions at Columbia and Princeton Un­i­v­ers­ities, and at the Nat­ional Academy of Scien­ce.

How did Einstein earn the title of one of the greatest ever gen­ius­es? With his arrival in New York; American journalists quickly picked up on the broad­er appreciation for the foreign sc­ien­tist. Apprec­iat­ion wasn’t univ­ersal because the US then was quite xenophobic, suspicious of sc­ience and fearful of dom­in­at­ion. But the nation was also greatly con­cerned with advance­ment. By the time he left the U.S in mid 1921, Einstein was indeed a genius.

He won the Physics Nobel Prize in 1922! But as a Jew, he’d closely observed the rise of Nazism in Berlin in the 1920s.

Einstein admired Toni Meyer Mendel; they first met ear­ly in Weimar Republic (1919-33), Germ­any’s noble years of demo­cracy; both the Ein­st­ein and Mendel fam­il­ies belonged to the same pacif­ist ass­oc­­iat­ion Bund Neues Vater­land. In pre-Hitler Ber­l­in, they’d all liv­ed tog­ether in Tony’s grand villa on the Wannsee, the inter­ior desig­ned by Walter Gropius. Bruno Mendel was a med­ical researcher who built a pri­vate laborat­ory in his villa!

Einstein loved playing music himself
and loved listening to concerts
 
Toni became a wealthy, emanc­ipated widow who loved travel. She was a regular compan­ion of Ein­stein, and their close friend­ship was grimly tolerated by wife Elsa. Einstein and Toni sailed together, discussed Freud, and shared concerts. Toni’s Weimar-culture intrig­ued Einstein, whose interests rang­ed­ far beyond phys­ics. He was devoted to music, playing chamber mus­ic him­self. And he was closely engaged in the excited sch­olarship of the Weimar era! When Hitler came to power, Toni quickly emigrated to Toronto.

In Mar 1933, Albert ex­iled himself in Belgium with Elsa. In late Jul 1933, after the Nazi regime forced famous German Jews to flee, Ein­stein visited the UK on a pol­it­ical mis­s­ion: to help Germ­any’s Jews. He first had a meet­ing with Winston Church­ill at Ch­art­well House to discuss Nazism.

From the Distinguished Visitors’ Gal­lery of Parliament, Einstein lis­ten­ed to a speech in the House of Com­mons. The speaker was an upper-class, right-wing Con­servative M.P, Commander Oliver Locker-Lampson who want­ed Britain to extend citizenship to desperate ref­ug­ees from outside the British Em­pire. And the House voted to sup­p­ort the MP’s bill on its first read­ing! The Nazi newsp­ap­er Völkischer Beo­bacht­er imm­ediately attacked, saying Locker-Lampson staged the event sole­ly for self-publicity.

Albert and his second wife, Elsa
always travelling

Chaim Weizmann welcomed Albert to New York, 1921
Later the president of Israel (1949–52)

Thousands cheered hia motorcade driving to City Hall 
for a welcome by New York City's mayor, April 1921.

Einstein returned to Belgium, where the Nazi leadership savaged him. Firstly they attacked Albert’s “pacifism” when he called for Europ­ean rearmament against the Ger­man th­reat. Secondly Einstein had pub­licly end­orsed a left-wing book The Brown Book of the Hitler Ter­r­or i.e an eye­witness report from Germ­any with horrify­ing photos of Nazi pogroms, burn­ings and tort­ur­es. Fortunately the Belgian king had the police constantly protect Einstein. Still, a secret Nazi terror org­anis­ation Fehme had targeted the scientist

Einstein packed some vital books and papers, and trav­elled from Bel­g­ium to the UK. He went to a hut on a Norfolk heath, to focus on theor­etical physics in peace. During his UK visit in Sep-Oct 1933, organised by Locker-Lampson, Britain’s national news­papers photog­raphed Einstein in hiding! Locker-Lampson org­an­ised a public meeting at the Royal Albert Hall; the German phys­icist and British speakers raised funds for academic Jewish Germ­an ref­ug­ees. Einstein spoke on Science and Civil­is­ation in his cautious Eng­lish, to huge applause from the huge audience. Note there were also British Union of Fascists Blackshirts att­end­ing. Einstein told newspapers the kindness of the British people had touched his heart deeply. Then left for USA.

Einstein lived the rest of his life in America, at the In­stitute for Advanced Study in Princeton. He was so involved with both physics and Cold War politics that he never returned to Eur­ope. Elsa was diag­­­­­nosed with organ failure in 1935 and died in 1936. He continued his work and his active social life, with a Russian sculptor’s wife, secretary Betty Neumann, and Toni Mendel again.

In 1953 with the USA gripped by the televised McCarthy hear­ings, Einstein took a well reported public stand against the loathed House Un-American Activities Committee.

In July 1955 after Einstein’s death, British academic Bertrand Rus­sell announced the Russell-Einstein Man­ifesto in London. Warn­ing the world of the dangers of a nuc­l­ear war, the signature had been Eins­tein’s last public act.

Find Einstein on the Road, to read his travelling diaries.




24 September 2022

16 reference books shaping art history.. and shaped my career

Svetlana Alpers
Art of Describing, 1984

In this account of the history of art as it was written in the C20th, 16 essays were written by leading art critics and curators, looking at the impact of each pivotal art book. Each essay in The Books that Shaped Art History by editors Richard Shone and John-Paul Stonard (2013) mapped the intellectual development of its author, set­ting out the premise of the work and placing it within the broader disciplinary field. Each chapter analysed a single major book, setting out its prem­ises, discussing its position within the field of art history, and looking at its significance in the context both of its original reception and its legacy.

This book provides a great roadmap of the field by reading art history and reassessing the impact of some of the most important works of art history. An excel­lent introduction by the co-editors specifically explored how art history was shaped by the outstanding contribut­ions, as well as by the dialogues and ruptures between them. 

Kenneth Clark
The Nude, 1976

The contributors to this book had a brief to tell of the personalities and stories that lay behind the special texts of modern art history. Such an approach of course ran contrary to the current of much academic art writing in the C20th, which regarded personalities and stories as the province of chatty amat­eurs. As a result these biographically informed essays achieved insights that would be lost if these great books were read as if they were self-contained artworks.

If I had selected the seminal art books myself, I would certainly have chosen Nikolaus Pevsner’s Pioneers of the Modern Movement; Ernst Gombrich's Art and Illusion; Cl­em­ent Greenberg's Art and Culture; Erwin Panofsky’s Early Neth­erl­and­ish Painting; and TJ Clark's Image of the People: Courbet and the 1848 Revolution. And Svetlana Alpers’ The Art of Describing: Dutch Art in the C17th.

But I must admit to never reading the essays on art genres that I did not like or didn’t know about. Rosalind Krauss’ The Origin­al­ity of the Avant-Garde and Other Modernist Myths, for example, brought struct­ur­alist and post-structuralist thinking into art history.

Irwin Panofsky,
Early Netherlandish Painting, 1971

Many of these art historians turned out to be popular with scholars and lecturers for decades, which meant that they had ample opportunity to update their texts to suit the changing times. In the first edition of Pevsner’s Pioneers of the Modern Movement (1936), he couldn’t wait to welcome the new cold age of steel and glass, which he hoped would do away with the warm muddle of individual creativity. What he wanted was an impersonal architecture serving the greater social and political good.  Lately arrived from the chaotic Weimar Repub­lic, Pevsner's longing for the blank slate of perfect order made psychological sense back then. But, as the 1930s reached their ter­r­ible end, his certainty about absolutism started to fade. By the time Pioneers of the Modern Movement was re­published in 1949, he had toned down his architectural views, becoming one of the C20th's most honoured of English art historians.

Roger Fry's Cézanne was first published in 1926 in a French magaz­ine with virtually no illustrations, and all Fry received in return were some free copies. Even when his friends Virginia and Leonard Woolf came to the rescue a year later and did an English version for their Hogarth Press, Cézanne: A Study of His Development, it still left a lot to be desired. Fry did not locate Cézanne historically on the change from the naturalistic C19th to the conceptual C20th. What really made Fry's heart pound were the geometric shapes making up Cézanne's serene, stable art. By carefully scrutinising the interrelations of form and colour, Fry set down the principles of a proto‑formalism that would become the dominant way of writing art criticism for decades.

Regarding Kenneth Clark, we know that he wrote the first draft of The Nude: A Study of Ideal Art (1956) when he was chairing the Independent Television Authority, the body charged with ushering in commercial television. Clark was already embarked on his journey from public servant to public intellectual, from the relative anon­ym­ity of the National Gallery to the global exposure of his tv series Civilisat­ion. While there was no doubting the fine scholarship underpin­ning The Nude, this was a book seeking a mass audience.

Katherine Hughes noticed the connections that bound the writ­ers of this core library together. Pevsner studied under Hein­rich Wölfflin, whose  Principles of Art History: The Problem of the Development of Style in Later Art is included here. Clark was a friend of Fry, and wrote early drafts of The Nude at Bernard Berenson's idyllic Florentine Villa I Tatti (Harvard Centre for Italian Renais­s­ance Studies). Krauss started off as a follower of Greenberg.

Sometimes the essayists agreed, sometimes they argued and often they simply ignored one another. As a result, the overlaps between these 16 foundational texts were often messy and contested. So even though The Books that Shaped Art History questioned the very status of art history itself, any contested quality in the essays I missed would have gone straight over my head.

Heinrich Wölfflin
Principles of Art History, 1929

How appropriate that this book was initiated by Burlington Magazine, one of my two favourite art journals. A monthly publication that has covered the fine and decorative arts since 1903, this journal was the work of art historians and connoisseurs that included Roger Fry and Bernard Berenson.



08 September 2020

Fritz Lang's films, in Germany and the USA


Fritz Lang (1890-1976) was born in Vienna to a Jewish mother, although he was raised as a Cath­olic. Fritz stud­ied civil engin­eering in Vien­na but soon loved café life and art, especially Egon Schiele and Gus­tav Klimt. For some years he travel­l­ed, studying art in Munich and Par­is. In 1914 he joined the Austrian army and spent a year in a Vienna army hospital writing screen­plays in bed.

In 1919 Lang directed his first movie, Half-Caste. In 1920 he work­ed for producer Erich Pommer at Decla Biscop Studio, part of the Germ­an filmmaking giant UFA. And marr­ied screenwriter Thea von Harbou.

German exp­ressionism (post WW1) was a movement char­act­erised by dark shadows, weird angles and distorted id­ent­it­ies. Hysteria and deception reflected the comp­lic­ated German society when the intellectual Weimar Rep­ublic also suff­er­ed high inflation and unemp­loyment.

Through the 1920s Lang made more ambitious films, includ­ing the al­l­egorical melo­drama Destiny (1921) and Dr Mabuse The Gambler (1922). In 1924 he first travelled to film companies in New York and Hollywood.

Lang’s first project back in Germany was the futuristic, expensive masterpiece Metropolis (1927), filmed in 1925-6 for UFA. The plot showed a repressive society with exp­loited workers, lazy rulers and emotionless robots. Lang created his vis­ually detailed films where a camera-process blended shots of miniatures with live action. 

Spies, 1928 (top image)
Gerda Maurus and Willy Fritsch

After the crime film Spies in 1928, Lang returned to science fict­ion for the silent Woman in the Moon (1929). The arrival of talkies in late 1929 produced an artistic blossoming of German film, before the collapse of the Weimar Republic in 1933. M (1931) was a German thriller, famous for its revolut­ion­ary light­ing and horrifying off­screen sound. It was Fritz Lang’s first sound film, starring a chill­ing Peter Lorre. The murderer terr­or­is­ed Berlin, but was fin­ally hunted down by Ber­l­in’s criminal under­world. It was Lang’s greatest international success.

Films from UFA, including Lang’s Metropolis and Josef von Stern­berg’s The Blue Angel (1930), att­racted Hollywood cont­r­acts. Even before 1933, Hollywood had invited several German writ­ers, dir­ectors and stars to migrate. But when Hitler became chanc­el­lor, migration became less ambitious and more survival-focused. After the Reich­stag fire, Austrian Jewish dir­ect­or Billy Wilder fled to Paris, and lived in a hotel near Hungarian-Jewish refugee Peter Lorre.

Next was The Testament of Dr Mabuse (1933), a crime thril­ler sequel to Dr Mabuse: The Gambler. The sequel actually was intended as an anti-Nazi statement that equ­ated the German state and Adolph Hitler with crim­in­ality. And thus was promptly banned! Lang met Joseph Goebbels in the Ministry of Propaganda, to appeal the ban on The Testament of Dr Mabuse, but failed. Yet Goebbels had seen Lang’s other films, and offered Lang the pres­t­igious Artistic Dir­ect­orship of UFA. Lang thanked Goebbels, ran home and left Germany that night for Paris. His wife, already a member of the Nazi Party, promptly divorc­ed Lang!

Lang made one film while in France, Liliom (1934), and then acc­ept­ed David Selznick’s offer to direct a film in Hollywood for MGM. Fury (1936) starred Spencer Tracy, an unforg­iv­ing study of mob viol­ence. But it achieved only moderate box-office success.

Fury, 1936
Spencer Tracy and Sylvia Sidney

Germany had been the leading centre of the avant-garde in music, art, film and architecture. But the Nazis viewed Weimar culture with re­ac­tionary disgust. Their response stemmed part­ly from conservative aesthetic taste and partly from their deter­min­ation to use culture as a prop­a­ganda tool against the Jews.

Lang, Wilder and other anti-Nazi exiles brought German exp­ression­ism with them. Then Lang worked with indep­end­ent Americ­an prod­uc­er Wal­t­er Wanger on the grim You Only Live Once (1937). Bas­ed part­ly on the true Bon­nie & Clyde story, it starred Henry Fon­da as an ex-con­vict who was wrong­ly sent­enced to death for murd­er. He broke out of gaol and fled to Canada with his wife.

The few Hollywood films made before 1941 that supported the US ent­ering WW2 often carried German screen credits. So in Sept 1941, a U.S Senate subcommittee investigated whether Hollywood was campaigning to bring the country into WW2 by insert­ing pro-British and anti-German messages into films. An isol­at­ion­ist Senator charged Hollywood with producing 20+ pictures in the last year des­ig­ned to fill Americans with fear that Hitler would invade. Worst still, he noted, many of the studio creatives were Jewish.

Man Hunt, 1941
Walter Pidgeon and Roddy McDowall

Then Man Hunt (1941), based on a thrilling sus­pense novel. Walter Pidgeon starred in the tense drama as an Eng­lish hunter in pre-WW2 Germany who could have ass­ass­inated Hitler. Lang’s clash with producer Darryl F Zan­uck led to the director’s departure from Fox. 

Film noir (40s & 50s), the cinema of the disench­anted, grew out of Express­ionism. European directors, who’d moved to the US, utilised cynical heroes, stark lighting, frequent flashbacks and intricate plots. 

Lang collab­orated with Bertolt Brecht on the independent prod­uct­ion Hangmen Also Die! (1943), a WW2 film about assas­sinating SS leader Rein­hard Heydrich in Prague. The Woman in the Window (1944) was his most night­­­marish drama, starring Edward G Robinson as a married college prof­essor and the woman who was the model in a paint­ing! 

Wild­er’s Double Indemn­ity (1944) was called the quin­t­­essential noir, a nasty tale of a murderous affair. Lang’s next proj­ect, the grip­ping Ministry of Fear (1944), feat­ur­ed Ray Mill­and as a discharged mental patient whose life was endang­ered by double agents and bogus med­ia. Lang directed a string of unconventional noirs alone, populated not by gangsters and detectives, but by psychologically damaged middle-class losers. Lang then reassem­bled his Woman in the Window actors to play in Scarlet Street (1945) about a middle-aged amateur artist who became obsess­ed with a young woman. Otto Prem­inger, an Aust­rian Jewish dir­ector who reached the USA in 1935, followed with Laura and Fallen Angel (both 1945).

Woman in the Window, 1944
Joan Bennett

But after these triumphs, Lang’s career slumped. Cloak and Dagger (1946) and Secret Beyond the Door (1947) were not successful. The Big Heat (1953) unleashed Glenn Ford as a rogue police officer whose wife was killed by a criminal gang and corrupt city offic­ers. The critics were largely un­impressed, but Lang regarded it as his best.