Showing posts with label stolen lost or faked art. Show all posts
Showing posts with label stolen lost or faked art. Show all posts

14 November 2026

Plunderer: Life & Times of a Nazi Art Thief

The documentary Plunderer: The Life and Times of a Nazi Art Thief (2024) focused on Bruno Lohse, a Nazi art dealer who shared in systematic looting of art from Jewish families. In 1936, Lohse earned a doctorate in art history and took his first steps into the art market. He ran the business from his father’s apartment, buying and selling artworks. The film investigated how Lohse profited in the post-war art market and explored the ongoing efforts of Jewish families to reclaim their cultural heritage. It examined historic crimes, illicit art markets and the struggle for restitution. It expertly confronted the art market’s frequent disregard for provenance and confronted the enduring human cost of these crimes.

The film has featured in various Jewish film festivals eg the Jewish International Film Festival/JIFF in Australia and the UK Jewish Film Festival. Directed by Hugo Macgregor in English, French and German, it was produced by John Friedman, National Centre for Jewish Film, Brandeis.

Plunderer analysed the dark part of the international art world, largely built on wartime tragedy. Using important masterpieces and personal letters, this documentary investigated the theft of thousands of artworks from Jewish families by Nazis in WW2. As noted, a key player in these war crimes was Bruno Lohse, an SS officer who became the art agent in Paris for Hermann Göring, a powerful Nazi figure in WW2. So this feature-length film focuses on the Nazis’ clearinghouse for confiscated pictorial art in France.

Bruno Lohse (second right) and Hermann Göring (cent) on a tour of stolen artworks,
at the Jeu de Paume museum in Paris.
NY Times
/
Meet historian Jonathan Petropoulos, author of Göring's Man in Paris: Story of a Nazi Art Plunderer. He first met Lohse in 1998, interviewing him often before his death in 2007 about his role in Nazi looting operations. Petropoulos told of the unkind game he played with Lohse, leading to horrible discoveries of collusion with galleries and auction houses, and paintings stashed in European bank vaults. Lohse had risen to prominence in Göring’s inner circle, personally organising art thefts for Hitler’s right-hand man; Lohse’s role in stealing masterpieces from desperate European Jews was spelled out. Petropoulos clarified the web of postwar complicity that shielded Lohse from proper justice, exposing the formal art market’s disregard for provenance.

Having been captured & grilled by Monuments Men post-war, Lohse had a brief prison sentence. Once released, he again dealt in stolen art for 60 years, happily selling to collectors, galleries and big museums. No other film so closely analysed the ex-Nazi art dealers who operated their own postwar Odessa network i.e the unregulated art market. See stories of Holocaust survivors working to reclaim their families’ lost artworks and see the continuity between the post-war era and the contemporary, sometimes secretive art world.

Museums everywhere have to consider implications of retaining items many argue were taken from their owners under persecution or duress. And while many of the rows over restitution pertain to old pieces, the recovery of which is complicated by the sweeping eras that have passed since their removal, a new documentary shows how the fight to recover more modern artwork can be just as problematic.

Jewish art dealer Max Stern owned the popular Galerie Stern in Düsseldorf in 1930s, but he had to sell all his art at auction for bargain prices, while his accounts and assets were frozen and seized. He fled Germany for the UK, where he was held for 2 years then sent to Canada. In Montreal, he become one of Canada’s greatest art dealers, representing Rodin and Henry Moore, and Emily Carr. See a problem at an exhibition honouring Max Stern at Düsseldorf City Museum which was due to open in 2018. But it was delayed for years due to debates over the restitution of artworks looted by the Nazis. See how loaded in political and cultural issues in restitution were.

Göring and Lohse studying a book on Rembrandt. 
Archives des Musées Nationaux/
 
Stern died childless in 1987 and left most of his estate to Montreal’s McGill & Concordia universities & Jerusalem’s Hebrew University. In 2002 his estate started to reclaim his lost art. The Max Stern Art Restitution Project has restored 25 paintings, making it a successful project. But hundreds of Stern claims are still waiting. The film focused on the project’s attempts to restore two paintings by Wilhelm von Schadow in the last decade: Self-portrait (1805) and Artist’s Children from the City of Düsseldorf (1830).

Under the Allied Restitution Principles, an estate making a claim had to prove that the assets changed hands under duress. It then became a pedantic argument about what constituted “duress” and when did duress actually begin for German Jews eg in 1933 versus 1935?

Stern’s heirs are now seeking to restore a painting in the Tate Britain works, Jan Griffier the Elder’s View of Hampton Court Palace, bought by the gallery in 1961. The Stern project says newly found documents show the painting was in the Stern collection when he was forced to sell his assets. They also believed that other Stern paintings might be held by the National Trust; Joachim Patinir’s Temptation of Christ at Upton House, is also eligible for restitution as it was “sold” by Stern under Nazi threats.

The documentary shows the fight to recover works that a Jewish art dealer was forced to sell by the Nazis. In the disputes, there was a familiar pattern: politicians & museum officials, having ignored the claim as long as possible, finally making noises about doing the right thing. But things got stuck in endless legal, scholarly or scientific wranglings.

Documentary Plunderer is based on Göring's Man in Paris: Story of a Nazi Art Plunderer and His World, 
written by Jonathan Petropoulos.

Question the failures of postwar justice and the continuing complicity of governments and the art trade in unpunished crimes. The film’s issues are very broad and resonate with larger questions facing the art world right now, the Director said. Recently restitution has been endlessly loaded with political and cultural issues, relating to antiquities, colonial plunder or paintings. From the Benin bronzes to the Parthenon marbles, debates over the restitution of cultural artefacts happen across the international art world that is forced to reckon with the treasures’ controversial histories. Thus the film should be shown at Film Festivals everywhere, and not just Jewish Festivals.

Many thanks to TheArtNewspaper.



25 August 2026

Goudstikker: stolen art returned to Holland


Jacques Goudstikker's gallery, 1927-40
Amsterdam. Wiki

Jacques Goudstikker (1897–1940) was born in Amsterdam, son of a Jewish art dealer. He studied at the Commercial School in Amsterdam, then in Leid­en and Utrecht. In 1919 he joined his fath­er's Amsterdam gallery, remodelled it as a pub­lic limited liab­ility company with himself as the director, and created an inter­nat­ional style.

He was becoming a connoisseur and scholar whose expertise was admired across Europe. Goudstikker's taste extended to the des­ign of his catalogues, minor works of art in them­selves, and close ties with art historians and col­lect­ors. His clients eg Baron Thyssen-Bornemisza shared this mix of connoisseurship and scholarship.

Post-WW1, Amsterdam was a centre of inter­nat­ional trade where top galleries flourished. In 1927 he moved to a larger gallery and presented works from the Dutch Golden Age, alongside panels by Dutch, Flemish, German and Italian artists, mixing paintings, sculptures & carpets. His Old Masters coll­ection included Lucas Cranach, Jan Steen, Adriaen van Ostade, Isaac van Ostade & landscapers Jan van Goyen and Salomon van Ruysdael. Goudstikker had fine paint­ings by Jan van der Heyden at his country home Nijen­rode Cas­tle where he ent­er­tained clients. Plus some still-lifes eg Jan van Huysum in National Gallery, and figure painters eg Ferdinand Bol and Aert de Gelder.

Some of Goudstikker’s Dutch and Flemish paintings, including 5 van Goghs, 2 van Dongens and a Mondrian, went to NY’s Anderson Gall­ery in 1923, organised by the Netherlands Chamber of Commerce. Between the wars, Goud­stikker was the ?most important Dutch dealer of Old Master paintings, even though the Depression badly affected art trade. None­theless Goud­­­stikker could still organise a Rubens ex­hib­ition in 1933. And a classy ex­hib­ition of Italian Paint­ings in Dutch Col­lect­ions at the Amsterdam Stedel­ijk Mus­eum in 1934. 

Floris van Schooten,
Still Life with Cheeses, c1620
Contemporary Jewish Museum, San Francisco

Cottages by the Can­al
by Jan van Goyen, 1630
National Museum, Gdańsk

His fine works included the Ferry Boat with Cattle on the Riv­er Vecht by Salomon van Ruysdael, Judgment of Paris by Fran­çois Boucher and Christ Car­rying the Cross by Hieronymous Bosch, now in Vienna’s Kunsthis­tor­isches Museum. Young Girl with a Flute by Vermeer was later pur­chased by Joseph Wid­ener to donate to National Gallery in Wash­ington DC. A large altar­piece, Assump­t­ion of the Virgin with Sts Michael & Benedict, is in Metrop­olitan Mus NY.

In 1937, Goudstikker married Viennese opera singer Désirée von Halban Kurz, daughter of famed Jewish soprano Selma Kurz. They had a son, and in 1939, with the imminent German occupation of Netherlands, Goudstikker applied for American visas. As the Germans advanced on Ams­terdam in May 1940, the family fled. While escap­ing via the English Channel aboard SS Bodegr­aven, Goudstikker fell into an open hatch on the deck, broke his neck and died. His widow Désirée and only child Edo both got safely to North America.

In June 1940, Goudstikker's employee Arie ten Broek became company dir­ector; then in July two of Goudstikker's employ­ees were paid to sell all the remaining works of art to Reichsmarschall  Hermann Goering. Goering took c800 of the most valuable works back to Germany where they were displayed in several residences. The art gal­l­­ery went to Goering's man German banker Alois Miedl who paid to acquire title to the J Goudstikker trade name and to Goud­stikker's real estate in Amsterdam and elsewhere.

With Goudstikker's respected trade name, Miedl made a fortune marketing art in Nazi Germany. Parts of the collection were taken over by East Prussian gov­ernor Erich Koch and one of these paint­ings, Cottages by the Can­al by Jan van Goyen, is still in the Gdańsk National Museum.

After WW2 the Allied forces recovered many treas­ures from Ger­many and gave them to the Dutch government to ret­urn­ them to their right­ful owners. The Dutch recorded 3,000+ plundered works that came back to the country post-war.

From 1946 the widow Désirée Goudstikker asked the Dutch government for the family coll­ection. In Aug 1952, after a 7-year legal battle, the widow received some works of art while the rem­aining objects, classed as Dutch National Property, were divided amongst the State museums.

In 1996-8, Dutch investigative journal­ists drew int­ernational att­ention to the post-war restit­ution of stolen art and the ignored rights of the legal owners. Eventually the issues were docum­ented in Pieter den Holl­ander’s 1998 book, The Goudstikker Case. The Goudstikker heir, his widowed daughter-in-law Marei von Saher, then sued for possession of the works. Unfortunately her claim was rejected by the State Sec­ret­ary of Education, Cult­ure and Science.

Ferdinand Bol,
Louise-Marie Gonzaga de Nevers, 1645
The Jewish Museum, Manhattan

Salomon van Ruysdael
River Landscape with Ferry, 1649
Nat Gall Art, Washington


Netherlands was long considered a leader in returning Nazi-looted art. But official in­vestigations confirmed some mis­hand­ling of postwar restit­ut­ions; as a result, the government created the Dutch Restit­utions Committee in 2002. It reviewed claims to art treas­ures in the govern­ment’s possession and to oversee efforts to ret­urn such works. In Dec 2005, the Committee DID restore 202 out of 267 paint­ings taken by Goering to the rightful heir, Marei von Saher, including Salomon van Ruysdael’s River Landscape with Ferry, once held in the collection of the Rijksmuseum.

Some pieces were not restored to von Saher in 2006 because the Dutch government no longer had them. Von Saher sued unsuccessfully in a US court for their return. None­the­less in gratitude, von Saher donated one returned painting, van der Helst’s 1645 Child on Deathbed, to the Dutch state.

NB 1,000+ works from this collection remain to be found.  

Dutch officials established a pro­cess for dealing with heirless art or work whose owner is unident­if­ied. Such piec­es would be returned to a Jewish heritage institution. And Neth­er­lands’ Minister of Education, Culture and Science said the Dutch government is also aiming to repatriate objects from its holdings that were plundered from former colonies.


Read the excellent book Reclaimed: Paintings from the Collection of Jacques Goud­stikker by Peter Sutton, 2008 




05 July 2026

recent art thefts: Italian Villa Masterpieces

The theft discussed here was the latest in a series of robberies targeting major European museums, soon after a series of other high-profile heists. “Poppy Flowers” by Vincent van Gogh, stolen from Cairo's Khalil Museum in 2010, was never found. Neither was “Soldier on Horseback” by Anthony van Dyck, stolen from University of Oxford in 2020. The shameless day-light robbery of precious jewels from the Louvre in Paris in Oct 2025 was worth $102 mill. The Louvre had been the latest to be subject to a heist. The thieves in this robbery forced their way through the main Museum door, grabbing the art from the French Room on the building's first floor. The criminals escaped by climbing over a fence, according to public broadcaster TGR, which first reported the theft. They believed a structured and organised gang was responsible for the theft.

The Villa of Masterpieces is home to the Magnani-Rocca Foundation, one of the most important art institutions in Europe and one of the most active museums for its cultural programmes. The villa was surrounded by the Romantic Park, a large English garden displaying exotic plants, monumental trees and magnificent peacocks.
Magnani-Rocca Foundation near Parma, Nth Italy
Artnet News

The Foundation was created in 1977 by art historian Luigi Magnani (1906–1984) whose special collection featured works by Gentile da Fabriano, Monet, Renoir, Goya, Titian, Dürer, De Chirico, Rubens, Van Dyck, Filippo Lippi, Carpaccio, Burri, De Pisis, Tiepolo, Canova, Cézanne and a large collection of Giorgio Morandi. And sculptures by Canova & Bartolini. The star painting, The Family of the Infant Don Luis by Goya was the emblem of this very fine collection.

Inside the villa, the old placement of furnishings was kept to maintain a lived-in home feel. Visitors can admire precious Empire-style furniture and objects, classy charm coming from its neo-classical and Empire-style furnishings by Jacob. Impressive also was Thomire’s large malachite cup, a gift from Tsar Alexander I to Napoleon. The restoration & transformation of the villa into a museum used most advanced standards set by the Italian Cultural Heritage & Landscape Code. This was to ensure the preservation of works and to suit hosting high-quality visiting exhibitions.

4 masked men entered Magnani Rocca Foundation Villa, near Parma in N. Italy, and made off with artworks in Mar 2026. They stole Renoir, Cézanne and Matisse paintings:

1.Fish by Pierre-Auguste Renoir, 1913
2.Still Life with Cherries by Paul Cézanne, c1886 and
3.Odalisque on the Terrace by Henri Matisse, 1885

Fish, by Pierre-Auguste Renoir
news.sky

Odalisque on the terrace, by Henri Matisse
mirror.co

`
Still Life With Cherries, by Paul Cezanne
news.sky

The theft took place within 3 minutes at night worth c£7.8m. The thieves forced open the entrance door to get into a room on the first floor before escaping across the museum gardens. The criminal operation seemed well organised,  entering the villa at the night, and disguised themselves even more by wearing hoods and masks. Media reports noted the gang quickly carried out the operation because they were interrupted by the museum's alarm system. They had apparently planned to steal more than just 3 works but had not been able to go any further due to the surveillance system (both in the museum and in the neighbouring facilities) and the rapid intervention of police and security officers.  So they had grabbed the 3 paintings, forced open the door and ran across the lawn.

Villa of Masterpieces, Van Dyck Room. 
kreativehouse.it

Villa of Masterpieces, Goya Room
kreativehouse.it

What will happen to Renoir, Cézanne and Matisse? I hope they will be found because The Carabinieri Cultural Heritage Protection Unit, a famous elite squad specialising in art theft, is actively inspecting. As is the Cultural Heritage Protection Unit of Bologna. So it may depend on whether the thieves sold the paintings onto Italian auction houses, smuggled them to the USA, burned the works so searchers would find only embers, or left the paintings in their wills to their grandchildren. 

Italian news agency ANSA posted pictures of the stolen works on line, to alert anyone who might see the stolen art, so perhaps the auction houses will be cautious. Despite being investigated by Italy’s Carabinieri and the Cultural Heritage Protection Unit of Bologna, nothing has been found yet. If I, Helen, was stealing a painting for my home (i.e not to sell), I would not have taken Matisse’s. Rather, I'd have preferred a Van Dyck. Enjoy finestresullarte and BBC.
 


14 April 2026

"The Stamp Thief" a good documentary

The Stamp Thief was a documentary investigating a Holocaust event: that some unknown Nazi stole priceless stamp collections from concentration camp victims and buried the stolen stamps in a small town in Poland. Producer Gary Gilbert set out to confirm the story and recover the stamps. His approach: do a fake film shoot. His goal: to deliver justice by returning the stamps to their rightful owners or community.

The Stamp Thief documentary was written by Gary Gilbert, 2025
Reddit

The film chased the story of a rogue Nazi officer tasked with cataloguing the valuables of Jews sent to concentration camps. Apparently he seized the chance to steal millions of dollars worth of rare stamps and buried them in his home, now in Poland. In a real-life mission, Gilbert embarked on a daring quest to uncover the truth and recover the stamps. Disguising his investigation, Gilbert sought to return the stamps to their rightful heirs or to a museum, delivering a small yet powerful act of justice 75+ years post-Holocaust. This true tale unfolded in the suspenseful documentary.

Director Dan Sturman was an investigative journalist and is now noted L.A-based director, writer and producer who created Academy Award-winning documentaries. Sturman has since filmed many subjects, his works including quality documentaries shown at classy festivals eg Twin Towers.

Sturman and Gilbert debated about finding stamps stolen by the Nazi officer and buried in a basement in Legnica Poland. Stamp Thief set out to find the stamps after hearing the story from his fellow screen writer, David Weisberg. Who could invent a more intriguing premise? David's father, psychiatrist   Paul Weisberg treated a fireman married to the daughter of the Nazi who allegedly stole the stamps from a concentration camp. 

Nazi Trio, found by producer Dylan Nelson
Film Freeway

Stamp Thief was a probing search: while the Nazis occupied Poland in WW2, the Nazi officer whose job was to catalogue valuables belonging to Jews sent to camps saw his chance. Sadly this was not the case of a hero who disobeyed orders and tried to help the victims of the Holocaust. The Nazi officer, who decided to pocket millions of dollars worth of stamps stolen from the victims, buried them in the basement of his home. Thanks to the discovery of a detailed map showing the approximate location of the stamps, a group of Americans flew to Poland.

 When the L.A television writer-producer learned that an SS officer probably stole stamps from Jewish concentration camp prisoners and hidden them in a Polish basement, the American launched a long quest to find the rumoured box of treasures, despite the minimal chance of locating them.

Sample of stamps from pre-WW2
JIFF

How Gilbert found about the stamps was an unlikely tale. It began with a psychiatrist who happened to have a patient in the 1970s. The patient told the story of the missing stamps, and the psychiatrist became so intrigued, he helped devise an elaborate retrieval plan to dig them up behind the Iron Curtain. He never followed through, but he shared the plan with his son, who happened to be an avid stamp collector. As the film unfolded, the pieces fell into place and the story became increasingly engrossing. The team that went to Poland in 2015 grew more invested in returning the stamps to their rightful owners. So does the audience!

The mission was steeped in symbolism. For Gilbert, a single stamp not only represented the many thousands of stamps stolen from Jews, but the 6 million who’d never reclaim their personal treasures. Gilbert knew the second he heard the story that he was going to go, because the only thing crazier than going would be to not go. What’s craziest was how Gilbert tried to retrieve the stamps. The more he talked to lawyers, the more he realised how difficult it was to get seized Jewish property out of Poland. So he planned to access the basement by pretending to use it as a film set for a fake historical drama. [It was hard labour, digging 4+’ into the basement ground that had been solid since WW2]. The Poland expedition meant deceiving the Polish building manager, residents and film crew, and members of the U.S team had to grapple with the ethics of their dishonesty!

The team included Sturman as well as Gilbert’s personal contractor who posed as the set designer. But Sturman really came to supervise the surreptitious dig for the stamps during fake rehearsals in the basement. Those involved all hoped that once the truth emerged, the misled people would see that the deceit happened to right a greater wrong.

Instead Polish reactions to discovering the truth were largely scary, but an unknown hero emerged in Polish crew member, Sylvia. She chose to fully support the Americans and their mission. Her decision as a Polish person was that each Polish person should have been self-responsible.

There were no criticisms in the on-line reviews, but here's my own feedback. I didn’t know the film was going to be about research and although that was my own fault, it was occasionally annoying. I wasn’t fascinated in their endless interviews, phone calls, meetings and letters. It might have been a fictional adaptation of the normal story of Nazis taking gold wedding rings & gold dental crowns from victims before they went into the gas chambers. And although I knew exactly why the team acted secretly and illegally as they did, the immorality of Lying for a Good Cause was barely tackled. 

I already knew that many modern Poles were still denying their nation’s part in the Holocaust. But the intractable mistrust between some Poles and Jewish Polish survivor families was not really challenged in the film.

Gary Gilbert, Judy Kirshner Gilbert, Elizabeth Malloy, Dan Sturman
in Hollywood, April 2025, 
Larchmontbuzz

 





17 February 2026

Vikings' North Exhibition in York !!

As the premier museum in North England for ancient objects, The Yorkshire Museum in York is displaying the Viking North Exhibition from July 2025-July 2027. In partnership with the British Museum it explores the world of the Vikings and the North’s Power Base from 800-1066 AD. Dr Adam Parker, Curator of Archaeology York Museums Trust wrote: “Viking North is a story of geopolitical change & clash of cultures. When the Viking Great Army arrived in North England in 866 AD, everything changed. Anglo-Saxon kings were defeated, new territories and allegiances rose and fell, new identities were forged and new connections made. The true story is brought alive by the emergent research into these temporary towns in the late C9th as these settlers expanded their geographical locations and made England home. 

Yorkshire Museum
Little Vikings

Based on new archaeological research and new technology, the exhibition combines objects from Yorkshire Museum’s own collection, the Vale of York hoard and specially loaned national and regional items eg objects from Viking Army Camp at Aldwark Nth Yorkshire. Many of these items in gold and silver are valuable and prestigious, showing the power, wealth and skills of the Vikings who lived in Nth England.

York helmet, c760
Yorkshire Museum

The York Helmet is an impressive star in the Viking North Exhibition, possibly the best-preserved early medieval helmet in Britain. This iron cap with brass edging and a chain mail neckguard, beautifully decorated with tiny animals, displays how these helmets were made, used and stored. Latin across the two bands reads: “In the name of our Lord Jesus, the Holy Spirit and God; and to all we say Amen. Christ.”  The helmet was a great status symbol for the owner, Oshere, a nobleman and a ?member of the Northumbrian royal family, the most powerful dynasty in England then.

The Ormside Bowl was discovered in 1823 in St James’ Churchyard in Great Ormside Cumbria, just where a Viking warrior grave was also discovered decades later. Was the bowl looted from York by the Viking warrior and then buried with him in his grave alongside his sword & shield boss? This gilded silver and bronze with glass bowl was the ?finest piece of silver work, with remarkable craftsmanship, surviving from Anglo-Saxon England.

The 2 shells are intricately decorated and fused, making a unique luxury item. It would have been treasured by its original owner for its beauty, quality and value. It is decorated with vine scrolls in the outer design, being a common Christian theme. This suggests that the delicate outer shell started life as a religious vessel. It was owned used by monks for religious services in a Northumbrian monastery, likely looted by Viking raiders, or given to them in tribute. A religious object could be adapted by Vikings as a drinking vessel (850-900). When an inner bowl was added, it was used at celebrations with friends.

The inner bowl was made later made from gilt-bronze and riveted with studs of blue glass and silver with an internal bowl and 16 circular pieces of glass in a ring of cloisons-partitions. The base plate of the internal bowl and features five further rivets, of which the central is missing.

Ormside Bowl, c775
Esmeralda's Cumbrian History
 
The bowl is a double-shelled cup made from 2 pieces joined with dome-headed rivets and beaded collars. The bowl’s interlaced cruciform surface is decorated with a chased repousse technique.  The gilding on the bowl was added after the other decoration. The inner bowl could have been made in York where a matching blue-glass stud was found.

Bird and vine decorations
Instagram

The original outer shell was made of gilt-silver decorated with Anglo-Saxon style interlaced creatures in Continental vines. Note plants, fruit, animals and birds in decoration. The outer bowl decoration was done using the chase repousse method where the design was hit from the reverse side, creating it in relief outside of bowl. The rim had a strip of ungilded silver although this has now mostly been lost. This strip was first attached using some clips in the shape of animal heads. The frontal gaze of some creatures was a familiar occurrence in carvings of this type, with both naturalistic & grotesque decorations.

After seeing Christians wearing crosses around their necks, Vikings wore pendants in the shape of Thor’s hammer from their own pagan beliefs. And other religious symbolism. A collection of late C10th-mid C11th stone crossheads is currently on display in the monks’ dormitory at Durham Cathedral, found and reused at building materials or found during excavation of the 1891 Norman Chapter House (so note that Durham borders Yorkshire but is separate). The scenes depicted include the Baptism & Crucifixion of Christ, and an ordination scene.

memorial cross, found in 2nd century foundations
Durham Cathedral
 
Dr Parker, Viking North is telling new stories about the Vikings 
BBC
Thanks to Esmeralda's Cumbrian History & Folklore; I recommend reading her posts.







23 September 2025

Caravaggio or Finson? Who???

Caravaggio, Young Sick Bacchus, 
1593-4

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio (1571-1610) was a brilliant artist who easily found patrons; but his unstable character and nasty temper caused him to constantly move around. Worse still, he was sentenced to death for killing a Roman nobleman in a duel in May 1606. He went to Malta (1607), became a Knight of St John and painted brilliantly. Following another violent brawl, Caravaggio was arrested and gaoled, so he made a daring escape in 1608 and fled to Sicily, then Naples. In Oct 1609 he was attacked by soldiers sent from Malta.

But Caravaggio was seriously ill; he saw Rome as a safe haven and asked his patron Cardinal Scipione Borghese for protection. The deal was Borghese would obtain the pardon, and Caravaggio would give the Cardinal all his unsold works. Expecting Pope Paul V (1605-21) would enforce the deal, Caravaggio left for Rome with his art all packed up. A week after leaving Naples, Caravaggio’s small boat sailed into the large, barracked Palo Laziale port and was promptly arrested. Seeing trouble looming again, the boat went to sea for Porto Ercole, taking the art works. After days, Caravaggio bought his freedom, searching for his art and running on the beach that hot July. He reached Porto Ercole by mid July 1610, but prison and fleeing had seriously weakened him, dying the next day. Caravaggio was thrown in a pauper’s grave, yet when news of his death spread, grief was intense.

Since Caravaggio had promised the paintings to Cardinal Borghese, he knew they were his! He sent his agent to find them and on 29th July the agent found 3 in the palace of Caravaggio’s former patron, Costanza Colonna Sforza. Alas the Prior of Capua from the Order of Malta app-eared, forcibly taking the paintings. NB Caravaggio had been defrocked in Malta, but the Prior ordered that when a knight died, his estate reverted to the Order of Malta.

Remember that since youth, Caravaggio had been a hoodlum; he scorned convention, disdained the law and was often violent. And unlike his contemporaries, Caravaggio worked alone, in his own style, and showed his patrons little respect. Yet his work had captivated people with its unique intensity. While Protestants disliked image cults, Cathol-ics embraced art’s religious power. Art played a key role in guiding the Faithful, including the illiterate, so religious art was explicit and powerful; it had to inspire Catholics to feel Christ’s sacrifice and martyrs’ suffering. Many artists loved dramatic realism, with boldly contrasting light and dark. Caravaggio had gained naturalism in both religious and secular scenes. And Orazio Gentileschi, Jusepe de Ribera and Pietro Paolini were faithful Caravaggisti.

**
Louis Finson (1574–1617) was a Flemish draughtsman, copyist and art dealer who painted portraits, religious compositions, symbolic art and genre scenes. Moving to Italy early in his career, he became one of the first Flemish followers of Caravaggio whom he knew in Naples; and the two artists were similarly aged.

Finson produced a number of copies after works by Caravaggio. He worked for years in various cities in France where he created altarpieces and portraits. And he was known for being the co-owner, together with his fellow Flemish painter and business partner Abraham Vinck, of two paintings by Caravaggio. Finson played a major role in the Northern Caravaggesque movement through his own works, and through his art dealership. Finson's Self Portrait 1613 is in the Musée des Beaux-Arts Marseille. This work was one of the matching self-portraits painted by Finson in what he called a distinct Caravaggesque style.

For c400 years nothing more was seen of them. Then in 1978 a French medical student, Christian Morand, got lucky. At a Marseille Exhibition of Provençal Art, he saw two special works. Attributed to Louis Finson (1580–1617), the two works come from the collection of scholar Nicolas-Claude Fabri de Peiresc. The oil paintings, 1) St Sebastian and 2) Penitent St Jerome 1595, were being auctioned in 1991. By then a specialist, Dr Morand failed to convince Marseille’s Musée des Beaux-Arts to buy them. So he went to the auction himself, to save the art for Provence .. but was outbid.

Later in Avignon, Morand walked in a back street and saw the 2 paintings in a shop window!! The doctor told the shop-owner his tale but didn’t have enough money to buy them; the owner was so taken by his passion that he offered a deal. Morand could take the paintings away with him, and each month he’d pay what he could. Morand was delighted. He bought a splendid new home and his 2 Finsons became the heart of his art collection. Now the family wondered if these fine paintings seemed too good for copies. And were unsigned! So what if they were actually by Caravaggio? Then Morand would need special insurance, security and conservation, all too costly!

In 2014 another miracle occurred - a Judith Beheading Holofernes was found in a Toulouse attic. Like Morand’s works, Judith was unsigned and there was also debate about the attribution. Some experts thought it was by Finson, or another Caravaggesque artist. Others thought that it was a lost Caravaggio which he’d given to Finson when he left Naples in 1607. Alas an American bought it pre-auction.

The Morands visited galleries & archives, consulted specialists and sent the Finson paintings for tests. Unable to find any other artists who could have painted these works, the Morands became convinced that Caravaggio was the only plausible artist of the paintings Caravaggio had lost at sea in 1610! But there were still issues. After Caravaggio’s death, Prior of Capua DID take some paintings from Naples’ Colonna Palace, under the Order of Malta’s instructions. He probably sent them back to Malta or used them to settle Caravaggio’s debts. It was possible that Morand’s works were among those he took, or perhaps smuggled out of Colonna Palace earlier.

Finson, St Jerome, 
1595

One last thought, presented by art expert Eric Turquin, France’s leading authority on Old Masters paintings, had staked his reputation on authenticating Carvaggio’s lost Judith and Holofernes being the real thing. The painting, depicting a grisly biblical scene of the beautiful Jewish widow Judith beheading a sleeping Assyrian general, was to be auctioned in Toulouse. Turquin told Agence France-Presse he was sure the painting was by the volatile and violent genius. Not only is it a Caravaggio, but of all the Caravaggios that are known today, this is one of the great pictures! But Italian specialists had their doubts.

Finson, Self Portrait, 1613

 
Louis Finson, Saint Sebastian
c1610

They believe it is a copy made by the Flemish artist Louis Finson, who worked alongside Caravaggio. On top of x-rays, cleaning showed that the painting was changed afterwards, with lots of retouching. The experts speculated that Finson possibly added his own touches to the canvas after Caravaggio left suddenly for Malta in 1607. The fiercely original painter had created his first canvas on the theme, the far more formal Judith Beheading Holofernes in 1598, in Palazzo Barberini in Rome.



21 June 2025

stolen art WW2: Cassirers, Camille Pissarro

 
Camille Pissarro, 1897
Rue St Honoré, Après-Midi, Effet de Pluie
Wiki

Millions of European Jews were forced to quickly sell their hom­es and businesses with WW2, their assets being confiscated by the Nazis. Works of art often seemed very significant to war heirs; they represented a last cultural conn­ect­­ion to their dead families. I particularly thank Marilyn Henry.

Sadly there had been an intentional campaign of con­fis­cation and destruction of European cultural prop­er­ty. Post-war, Allied Forces uncovered cac­h­es of looted goods and the U.S military returned mill­ions of art objects to the countries of the works’ origin. But those nat­ions were responsible for locating the actual heirs. Did they find them?

Once the Nazis sold the objects, the works entered the art market and were dispersed. Both the pre-war owner and the current owner may have had moral claims to the works, but legal ownership varied. Most Western legal sys­t­ems couldn’t deal with losses from other decades, and from oth­er coun­tries. Claims could be barred because Statutes of Lim­it­at­ion expired. Or claims and the rights of a curr­ent possessor were con­fused when art crossed borders. Add­ition­ally most nations had laws that protected good-faith pur­ch­as­ers. And who could define a forced sale? Only Germany recog­nis­ed some sales under duress.

In the U.S, most museums are private so ownership disputes were and are civil matters. The New York State Banking Dept estab­lish­ed its Hol­ocaust Claims Processing Office in 1997, to resolve claims without litigation. Since then, it accepted 142 art claims covering 25,000 objects. But the small staff of lawyers, linguists and hist­orians only secured the VERY slow return of 12 art works!

Camille Pissarro, 1897, Wiki
Boulevard Montmartre, Morning, Cloudy Weather
NGV Melbourne

Also in the U.S, the Nazi-Era Provenance Internet Portal created a database linked to American museums, identifying thousands of items that had been in Europe from 1933-45. But while the portal could be searched by an artist’s name, country of origin and a painting’s name, it could not be searched by the family own­er.

An artwork’s ownership chain was often patchy. There WAS a res­ponsibility to participate in provenance research, but it was exp­ensive. The paper trail about prov­enance history was often deposited in: multi-national settings, private family memorabilia, govern­mental or museum arch­iv­es.

Some museums did no additional research to clarify the history, until a claimant came forward. Others eg North Carolina Museum of Art, took the initiative. Artworks with uncertain gaps of war-time ownership were reviewed by prof­essional provenance research­ers.

Museums and collectors are more willing to acknowledge legitimate claims than they were a decade ago, and to settle them without lit­ig­ation. But of course museums and collectors still dispute ten­uous claims. Most museums have put their entire collections on Web sites so now the assertion of claims is much easier than it was.

The size of wartime art thefts will never be known. The size of their return, through some heroic post-war efforts, was very great. But those efforts were eventually seen as incon­sistent with foreign policy, or reflecting cold war ten­s­ions by the 1960s. Only West Germany paid partial com­p­en­sation to some claim­ants; read Nazi Confiscated Art Issues.

Camille Pissarro, 1897
Boulevard Montmartre Spring
Courtauld Institute of Art

These days attention to war-era ownership is emerging in the art wor­ld. Major auction houses and museums have provenance re­search­ers, so sellers and buyers routinely check objects with the Art Loss Reg­is­ter - an international database of lost and stolen art formed in 1991 by auction houses and art traders. Un­for­t­unately this did not happen 50 years ago.. when scrutiny could have helped.

As more artwork is identified and located, other nations are quest­ioning the ownership of their holdings. A number of European count­ries eg Austria and Britain have enacted restitut­ion policies or established independent panels to review claims. However these re­view processes didn’t ensure the recovery of loot­ed art, even with clear evidence. Many claimants, especially the children whose parents died in the Holocaust, continued to be frustrated at the expense and time required to pursue a work.   

The same Pissarro painting in Lilly Cassirer’s Berlin flat, c1930.
artnet news

There were 15 Camille Pissarros (1830–1903) that were painted from his Paris hotel room window. One version was called Boulevard Mont­martre, spring morning,  moved through the hands of two of my favourite art dealers: Galerie Durand-Ruel in Paris who acq­uired it from the art­ist in June 1898; and Paul Cassirer in Berl­in who acquired it from Durand-Ruel in Oct 1902.

Now consider Lilly Cassirer and her second husband Otto Neubauer, who swapped a beautiful Camille Pissarro impressionist painting for their free­d­om. A Nazi-appointed appraiser forced her to sell Rue St Honoré, Après-Midi, Effet de Pluie for $360 then. But when the coup­le fled Munich in 1939, they could not take the funds. Lil­ly’s first husb­and Fritz Cassirer, from the prom­inent German Jewish family of publishers and art dealers, had bought the painting from Pissarro’s agent in 1900.

Although the post-war German government voided the sale, Lilly nev­er re­covered the Pissarro. It was sold multiple times. In 1993, the Sp­anish government paid $350 million for the col­lection of industr­ialist-Nazi supp­ort­er Baron Hans Heinrich Thyssen-Bornemisza and placed in their Museum.

In 2001 in the US, grandson Claude Cassirer (1921-2010) found the painting after years of searching and spent five years trying to recover the Pissarro through diplomatic channels. Finally Claude filed a federal lawsuit in California against Spain and against Thyssen-Bornemisza Foundation to recover the paint­ing, now worth $40mill.   

Lilly Cassirer Neubauer and her beloved heir grandson Claude, born Berlin 1921
Claude's mother died flu 1921; Claude's grandmother loved and raised the child
itsartlaw

Claude Cassirer learned the painting was at the Thyssen-Bornemisza in 2000 and petitioned Spain and the museum to return it. See the legal proceedings: the District Court case was in 2006, the first appeal was 2009-10, the second appeal was 2013, the Spanish Law case was 2015 and a last decision was in 2019. Whose law should app­ly, Spain’s or the USA’s? In 2024 the U.S Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit awarded the painting to the Spanish museum; it was legally bound to decide the case using Spanish law because the thefts occurred there. The Cassirers appealed the 9th Circuit ruling to the Supreme Court which vacated the Circuit Court of Appeals decision. It will now have to reconsider the case in light of the new California law on holocaust survivors' right to reclaim looted art.





08 March 2025

Cimabue art in a kitchen Vs in Le Louvre

A prized C13th painting found hanging over a stove in the kitchen of an elderly woman in Compiègne, north of Paris in 2019. The painting was go­ing to the rubbish tip during her house clear­ance; suddenly her fam­ily called in an expert to see if there was anything of value in the pro­perty, just before the house was sold. Think­ing the work could be worth money, the local expert sent it to a Paris art specialist who de­cl­ared it to be a genuine Cimabue. The art world was VERY surprised.

Christ Mocked c1280
by Cimabue
artfixdaily
                                                       
Its sale made the Fren­ch woman a millionaire, but when she died two days after the auction, her estate was split between her heirs. It said that Culture Minister Franck Riester had followed the recom­mendation of France's Commission for National Treasures, blocking the painting's export abroad to allow funds to be raised. This would enable the work to be exhibited in the Louvre in Paris beside the Maestà de Santa Trinita, another Cimabue mast­er­piece in the Louvre being restored.  

Cimabue was born in Florence, among the first Italian masters to move away from the formal Byzantine style of art to a more realistic treatment of sitters. Largely known as a fresco pain­t­er in Fl­orence and Rome, he signalled the start of the Florentine Renaiss­ance and was probably the master of Giotto, the great C14th Florentine artist. Only about a dozen works attributed to Cim­abue, who did not sign his paintings, are known to exist. But I cannot remember much about Cimabue from lectures.

It's easy to see why Christ Mocked was mistaken for a rel­ig­ious icon as his work was produced on poplar wood panels with back­grounds of gold-leaf paint. The tiny image (25 x 20cm) dep­ict­ed Jesus being mocked before his cruc­ifixion, one of 8 panels that survived from his work called the Diptych of Devotion c1280. Of these 8 panels, 5 are still missing. Only two other panels in the series were found: Flagel­l­ation of Christ in NY’s Frick Collection and The Virgin and Child with Two Angels in London’s National Gallery. That Christ Mocked was one of the missing piec­es from that altarpiece was soon authenticated with certain­ty; it had exactly the right dimensions, style and col­ours, and the wood panel came from the same plank of poplar as the rest of the altarpiece.

Cimabue's exceptionally rare gold-ground panel painting made headlines. Offered by an auction house north of Paris in Oct that year, the treasure sparked a bidding war, soaring past its estimate to sell for €24.2 million with fees!!  The Louvre museum lost the bidding war!  Although the foreign buyer was not named, French reports say the work was bought by two Chilean collectors specialising in Ital­ian Renaissance art. 

So the Louvre had to keep the work in France to raise more money. France’s Culture Ministry declared Christ Mocked to be a National Treas­ure and implemented a tem­porary export ban in Dec 2019 that barred it from leaving the country for 30 months. Luckily the export ban bought enough time for the Louvre to raise funds needed to match the win­­n­ing bid and to acquire the work. Neither the Culture Ministry nor the Louvre announced how much it paid for Christ Mocked or how the money was raised to buy it; only that it involved a MAJOR project to encourage donations from patrons offered tax exemptions. Happily the Société des Amis du Louvre  contributed the final million euros that made this acquisition possible, along with income from outside France. Hard to guess that the painting had been hanging above a hot stove in a Paris house a short time earlier!

Thus the Louvre has taken over the pre-Renaissance painting, now one of the old­est works in its col­l­ect­ion, after a longgg effort to keep it in France. The Louvre already had a much larger Cimabue painting on display, Maestà (c1280). This huge work, 4.3 ms x 2.7 ms, completed its restoration, and now they have put both Cim­abues on public display in its 2025 exhibition (see below).  

Majesty of Santa Maria dei Servi
Cimabue, c1280
Wiki

Louvre’s Director Laurence des Cars said the work constituted a crucial milest­one in the history of art, marking the fascin­ating transition from icon to painting. He repeated that it would soon hang near the Maestà, a lar­g­er tempera work by Cimabue that also dates from that decade. This piece has been in the mus­eum’s collection since 1813, originally looted from Italy in the Napoleonic era.

The French culture ministry reported that Christ Mocked was in good condition, showing how Cimabue used a new language of expression, especially "visible in the humanistic treatment of the face of Jesus, the rendition of people's expressions or space". Appropriately Christ Mocked is the centrepiece of the Louvre’s Review Cimabue Exhibition which continues until May 2025. See the painting next to  St Francis Receiving the Stigmata by  Giotto. Bringing together 40 works, this fine exhibition highlights the “rupture” represented by Cimabue's Art.

St Francis receiving the stigmata from Jesus,
note the tempura and gold panel 
by Giotto,  c1295, Wiki


19 November 2024

Tom Keating: most moral art faker?

This is the strangest Faked Art story I've ever seen. Tom Keating (1917–84) was born into a poor London family. His father worked as a house painter, and barely made enough to feed the household. At 14, Keating was turned away from the college of his choice, so the teenager started working for the family business as a house painter instead. 

View Towards St Mary Dedham, by Keating
inspired by Constable
Artnet

He enlisted as a boiler-stoker in WW2. The benefit of his military service was eligibility for a 2-year re­habil­itation art course, enabling Keating to enter Goldsmiths' Col­l­ege, University of London. But in the programme, he discovered the cultural chasm separating him from his upper-class peers. And alth­ough he achieved high marks for paint­erly technique, his or­ig­inal­ity was called poor. It was humiliating.

While at Goldsmiths’, Keating did weekend jobs for art restorers, includ­ing Hahn Brothers in Mayfair. Utilising the skills he learned in these jobs, he began to restore paintings for a living. He ex­hib­ited his own paintings, but failed to break into the art market. And after 2 years, he left Goldsmiths' College ungraduated.

His forgery career started in art restorer Fred Roberts’ workshop, a man apparently not over-burdened by ethics. Am­ongst the many can­vas­es passing through Roberts' shop was a win­t­er scene by Frank Moss Bennett, an early C20th British artist whose works were widely reproduced cheaply. When Keating crit­icised a Bennett work, Roberts chal­l­enged him to “create a Bennett painting” himself. When he created his own Bennett-like piece, he was so proud of it that he signed it with his own name. Roberts saw it, unilaterally changed the sig­nature to FM Bennett and con­sign­ed it to a West End gallery.

Only twice did Keating say he was seduced by the spirit of a dead artist. In 1962, Edgar Degas “instructed” him to fake the French­man’s self-portrait. Later in life Keating found that Francisco de Goya “ord­er­ed” him to create a self-portrait, by firmly guiding the young man’s hand. That Goya and Degas had chosen him did not surp­rise Keating; past masters must have recognised themselves in him!

Keating, French Countryside
inspired by Monet's Poppy Fields
the editorial magazine

In 1963, he started his own art school. This is where middle-aged Keating met 16 year old Jane Kelly, a student! Kelly really enjoyed Keating's teaching and asked her parents to pay for fulltime art classes. They be­came close friends, then lovers and then business partners. Four years later, the two started an art restoration business in Cornwall together. 

Keating created 20 fake watercolours based on Samuel Palmer works. Keating and Kelly chose the best 3 forgeries and Kelly took them to gallery specialists for auction. Keating viewed the gallery system to be domin­at­ed by American avant-garde fashion, with nasty critics and dealers often conspiring to line their own pockets at the expense of both naïve collectors and of impoverished artists. So Keating retaliated by creating forgeries to fool the experts, hoping to destabilise the art world. He acknowledged that he planted time-bombs in his art, leaving clues of the paint­ings' true nature for fellow art restorers or conservators to find. He deliberately added flaws, or used C20th materials.  

Sunflowers by Tom Keating
inspired by Sunflowers (1850) by Vincent van Gogh.
Photo from London's National Gallery.

The art market became Keating’s focus, giving him a ration­ale for ad­­opting other painters' styles and earning money in their name. Keating's preferred approach in oils was a Venetian tech­nique insp­ired by Titian's practice. His paintings took time to complete, but they had a richness of colour, special optical effects and a variety of texture that Rembrandt would have loved.

In 1970 auct­ioneers noticed that there were 13 Samuel Palmer water­colours for sale, all depicting the village of Shoreham in Kent. The Times of Lond­on arts journalist, Geraldine Norman, looked into the 13 Palmers, sending them to be scient­ifically tested by a spec­ialist. They were fakes. But it was not until Jane Kelly's brother met Norman that she heard about Keat­ing’s story. Then she met Keat­ing who explained his life as a restorer and artist.

Keating estimated that 2,000+ of his forgeries were in circ­ul­ation. He had created them as a working-class social­ist protest against art traders who got rich at the artists’ expense. But note that he refused to list his forgeries. Keating connected even more deeply with her Geraldine’s husband Frank Norman, a petty-thief-turned-playwright. The two old rogues started swapping stories. Within a few hours, Frank had agreed to ghost Tom's autobiography.

Thus Keating published his auto­biography, The Fake's Progress, with Geraldine and Frank Norman in 1977. In it he wrote it seemed disgrace­ful to him how many artists died in poverty, having been exploited by unscrup­ulous dealers. The time had come for the art establish­ment to learn that this old socialist was avenging his brothers in art; his goal was to make the Old Mast­ers widely available and affordable, even for working families.

Keating & Jane Kelly were finally arrested in 1977, accused of conspiracy to defraud and obtaining payments through deception amounting to £22,000. Kelly pleaded guilty, promising to testify against Keating. But Keating pleaded innocent, on the basis that he'd never intended to defraud; rather he was simply working under the Old Mast­ers' guidance. The charges were eventually dropped due to his poor health after he was very injured in a motorcycle accident, worsened by heart disease. Since Kelly had already pleaded guilty, she had to serve her time in prison. However Keating served no time, and his health soon imp­ro

Starting in 1982, tv episodes of Tom Keating on Painters showed the working methods of Rembrandt and the Old Masters. In each very popular programme, the ageing Londoner dem­onstrated how to paint eg Turner's ships or van Gogh's sunflowers.

Keating died in 1984, and was buried in Dedham chur­ch­yard. After his death, many art coll­ect­ors and celebrities began to collect his work which became increasingly valuable. Even Keating’s known for­geries, des­cribed in cat­alogues as after-Gainsborough or after-Cézan­ne, now attain high prices.