01 February 2022

Marty Glickman and Sam Stoller, great US athletes excluded: 1936.

Robert Barty grew up as part of the Indigenous Ngarigo tribe in Bowen in rur­al Nth Queensland. Daughter Ashleigh Barty is therefore a mem­ber of the same Ngarigo people who grew up in Ipswich Queensland. In 2022, when Ash became the Women’s Single champion at the Australian Tennis Grand Slam, every single Australian proudly gathered around, to celebrate her success. Cathy Freeman & Evonne Goolagong Cawley were Barty’s important ath­letic mentors and indigenous heroines.

Newly-crowned Australian Open champion Ash Barty 
standing between Cathy Freeman (L) and Evonne Goolagong-Cawley (R), 
Jan 2022. NITV

Now consider the opposite case, when talented athletes were punished specifically because of their minority ethnic status. Different era, of course.

In 1931 the International Olympic Committee awarded the 1936 Summer Olympics to Berlin, specifically to incl­ude Germany in the de­mocratic world. Only after Hitler became Chancellor in Jan 1933 did Ger­many become a totalitar­ian state control­l­ed by Nazi policies. Ger­man sports imagery from 1933-on promoted the id­eal of Ar­y­an racial sup­­er­iority and physical power.

Democrats warned that the Nazis would use the 1936 Ber­l­in Games for propaganda purposes and that the USA team should boycott the games. But Avery Brundage, Pres of U.S Olympic Committ­ee, opposed the boycott. He believed that a] German Jews were not persecuted and b] politics and sport should never mix. Wasn’t Brun­dage worried about black U.S ath­letes?

As the Olympics Boycott fight heated up in 1935, Brundage alleged the ex­­is­tence of a Jewish-Communist con­sp­iracy to keep the USA out. In the end, Brun­dage won. Note that Hit­ler rewarded Brund­age 2 years later by giving his company the con­tract to build Wash DC’s German embassy.

In Aug 1936, the Games opened in Berlin. 49 countries competed, with Germany having the largest team and USA having the 2nd largest team. The ceremonies commenced in the new Olym­pic Stadium, a 110,000 goliath built under Jo­s­eph Goebb­els' direction to showcase Aryan supremacy.

German officials believed Ger­many would dominate the Games with vict­ories, since non-Aryans were inferior. Desp­ite pers­on­­ally congratulat­ing two German gold medallists and a Fin­­nish win­ner on the opening day, Hitler left the stadium after a black American Corn­elius John­son won the high jump. The Führer said that Americ­ans should be ash­am­ed for letting their medals be won by black athletes.

So it was excellent news for democratic Americans that the most brill­iant athlete in Berlin was black Jesse Owens. He went on to win four gold medals, including a world record. The spectators were mesmerised. 

German soccer team, Berlin Olympic Games 1936. Irish Times
Apparently politics WERE allowed into sport

Note that Hitler st­orm­ed out of Berlin’s Olympic Stadium, leaving Ow­en’s hand dangling. Germany had been hum­il­iat­ed; his Aryan supermen had been beaten by a sub-human, rac­­­ial infer­ior. Hit­ler's racist snub­bing of Owens was clear; he shook hands only with Aryan com­p­etitors!

Marty Glickman and Sam Stoller, 1936

Exclusion of Jewish American athletes
Another cont­r­overs­ial decision at these Games was the excluding of two Am­er­ican sprinters, Marty Glickman & Sam Stoller, from 4x100m relay, the day before. Stoller and Glickman, the only Jews in the entire U.S team, were totally withdrawn from the relay team. They were both horrified.

Jesse Owens, Ralph Metcalfe, Foy Draper, Frank Wykoff, 
American relay team, minus the Jews

But why did it happen? The relay coaches cl­aim­ed they needed their fast­est run­ners to win the race, regardless of who’d been promised the spots. But most people said it was because Avery Brund­age did not want to em­bar­ra­ss Hitler by hav­ing Jews win gold medals. Glickman said both the U.S athletic coach Dean Crom­well and Avery Br­und­age were motivated by their own anti-Semitism.

In the end the U.S relay team of Jesse Owens, Ralph Met­calfe, Foy Dr­ap­er and Frank Wykoff brilliantly won in a world record time of 39.8. Yet Glick­man and St­oller had travelled from the U.S to compete ONLY in the Am­erican relay team. So how did their Jewish heritage get public­ised? Were they seen without knickers in the changing room? Did they ask for kosher meat from the kitchen?

Note that Berlin had already been cleaned up with rac­ist graffiti tak­en down and Fascist papers removed from newsstands. Hitler had already passed the Cit­izenship Laws, strip­ping Jews of their nationality but the Füh­rer wanted to maximise the Berlin Games as a propa­ganda exer­cise for Nazism. So I must conclude that the overt anti-Sem­it­­ism against Glickman and Stoller was not solely displayed by Nazi Ger­many. The Jewish ath­letes were snubbed by THEIR OWN Olympic Committee.

The US Olympic Committee did admit eventually that Glickman and Stoll­er were replaced by Av­ery Brundage at the Germans’ insistence. This was repeated in the HBO do­cumen­tary called Glickman (Aug 2013). But had Avery Brundage not readily agreed to throw the Amer­ican Jews out, what would the Germans have done?

Stoller later denied that it was purely anti-Semitism but re­corded the in­ci­d­ent in his diary as the most humiliating episode in his life. His career quickly faded.

Paul Taylor's book, 2008

Glickman en­listed in the Mar­ines during WW2, then post-war he launched a very suc­cessful broadcasting career, cov­er­ing top New York sports. His inability to compete in the 1936 U.S ath­letic team because of his religion had not ruined his career. He dev­ot­ed his life to helping teens, working with New York high schools and Pol­ice Ath­let­ic League. Glickman was a lifelong advocate of sports to transcend divisions created by race, class and relig­ion. Glickman died in 2001.




 



19 comments:

LMK said...

Stoller held the world record for the 60 yard sprint in the very year they went to Berlin. For the coach to argue they needed the faster runners and therefore Stoller had to go was bizarre.

Hels said...

LMK

Owens was faster over the longer distance, but he was already committed to many Olympic events.

Like all Olympians before 1970, Stoller had to be an amateur. Thus by committing the young man to the relay team, Stoller couldn't do his studies at University of Michigan, earn money or defend his world record during the training or Olympic eras. He made the sacrifices happily, .. until his commitment was sabotaged.

Joseph said...

Evonne Goolagong was a truly fantastic tennis player and Ashleigh Barty is an even better one now. But I wonder what sort of racist difficulties Evonne had to deal with back in the day, behind the scenes.

Hels said...

Joseph

Evonne let her work on the court speak for itself. But read this. "As with so many Aborigines, Evonne was often treated as a second-class citizen. Many Australians thought the best practice was for Aboriginal children to be removed from their families to be given a life away from poverty and an education in white Australian society. Whenever a car would come down the road, my mum would tell us to hide or else the welfare man would take you away. Even as an adult she was acutely aware of how Aborigines could be excluded from everyday life -- even after winning Wimbledon".

CNN https://edition.cnn.com/2015/01/29/tennis/evonne-goolagong-cawley-australian-open/index.html

Anonymous said...

We've come a long way since then, in sport at least. There is still plenty of tinkering required though.

Hels said...

Andrew

yes indeed. But then when Chinese tennis star Peng Shuai seemed to disappear in 2021, it showed yet again how uncertain we are about what goes on behind the international sporting scenes.

Handmade in Israel said...

Such an interesting post. Times have changed, but perhaps still not enough?

Parnassus said...

Hello Hels, Sports are all about teams and sides and local pride and winning, so it is ridiculous to think that international sports could be de-politicized. When the personal careers of fine individual athletes are derailed in the process, however, the result is quadruply shameful.
--Jim

Luiz Gomes said...

Boa tarde minha querida amiga. Parabéns pelo seu excelente trabalho e matéria. Não conhecia essa história. Obrigado pela oportunidade de conhecer e aprender cada vez mais.

mem said...

This just makes my blood boil . When oh when are we going to get past race and religion and just judge people on their basic humanity and qualities as a personality who has a character?
We are so hung up on these constructs which divide us and cause so much stress and bother . Its not based on biology or fact but on pour beliefs around "the other" Maybe it is naïve to think we will ever get beyond this I sure hope we do , because it is a human fault used by dictators and those who manipulate for their own ghastly ends . The goings on in China are indeed scary and also in Russia. We are close to war I suspect, and those who have the power to stop it are just assuming the same which makes it even more dangerous and scary .

Hels said...

Handmade

Times certainly have changed, thank goodness.

Now the pro-active responses to racism come from the athletes themselves, not from racist administrators. Yet sports heroes who expressed their anti-racism views via black bands or gloved fists still found it to be career threatening. Remember when Tommie Smith and John Carlos were suspended from the Olympic team and kicked out of the Olympic village?

Hels said...

Parnassus

I need to think about the concept of politicising racism or ethnic oppression in international sport.

If the racist oppression was unconscious or secretive, the careers of top athletes could be as ruined as when the racism was overt. When the racist oppression was blatantly denied, the lying was even more destructive.

Hels said...

Luiz

Have a look at the story of a great black athlete from Brasil, Aída dos Santos. In the 1964 Games, Aída was given no sport shoes, no medical care and her name wasn't registered by the team managers for her events. Nasty stories everywhere, it would seem.

Hels said...

mem

You wrote "we are close to war I suspect, and those who have the power to stop it are just assuming the same which makes it even more dangerous and scary". But even if that is true, are you thinking that international hostility provokes and tolerates personal racism?

In 1936, that was certainly true because it was building up to an inevitable world war AND because racist policies were part of German legislation.

bazza said...

Isn't it so sad to have to reflect that, after the spectacle of the 1936 Olympics and the Wat, that NO LESSONS WERE LEARNED. Racism remains, antisemitism is still with us, politics in sport is endemic, genocide continues to happen. It's part of the Human Condition and will never disappear.
On a happier note: Barty is a really worthy champion and seems to be a very grounded and likable person.
CLICK HERE for Bazza’s knavishly knackered Blog ‘To Discover Ice’

Hels said...

bazza

few racist, violent leaders got even 48% of the vote eg Franco, Hitler, Trump, Bolsonaro etc. I can't remember if the Taliban even bothered having an election *groan*. So that suggests that a minority of the population are committed racists or are happy enough to obey the new leaders.

I truly believe that most people are not nasty; rather they just want to survive as best they can.

Hels said...

Parnassus

Brightbird said that sports, entertainment and politics are forever entwined, in a post called Sports as Politics - Jesse Owens and the 1936 Olympics.

https://www.earthfedmuscle.com/blogs/articles/sports-as-politics-jesse-owens-and-the-1936-olympics

Does "forever" mean "inevitably"?

Britta said...

Dear Helen, a very dark episode in our History - and though I am glad "to have the mercy of a late birth", some years after the end of the war, I am always shocked what humans are capable of.
In Berlin I was also astounded that they still use the Olympia station - it is a preposterous Nazi-building - making people feel very small.
I also visited the old Olympia grounds (outside Berlin, not easy to get in, one needed appointments even before Corona.) Really impressive - abandoned and silently derelict. I was in the house where Jessie Owens prepared and was deeply shocked that there was still a caricature of him, - of course: to show the situation as it was is ok, I am not for euphemism - yet it was a shock.
The world might have changed to the better - in our parts at least - and I was angry and bewildered to see the pompous Nazi-buildings (Nurnberg you might have seen? the Reichsparteitag-Gelände?) I discussed with the Flying Dutchman how my life might have looked if they had won - I do not dare to think of that. (The Nazis killed one daughter of my grandmother in a concentration camp). As a child we only heard so little about all that.

Hels said...

Britta

I have been all over central Europe many times, basically as a distant historian examining remote times. Most of my family left Russia before WW2, but I know all about the Holocaust because my parents-in-laws couldn't leave Czechoslovakia until the early 1950s. Sadly my beloved spouse had no grandparents, 1 aunt, 1 uncle and no cousins.

I am grateful that you have visited, and closely experienced, both the old Olympia grounds and the house where Jessie Owens prepared. The 1936 Olympics were vitally important to Germany, of course, but I was surprised that the Games were as vital to the USA. Avery Brundage not only opposed any possible American boycott; he also made the decisions to protect Hitler from having to shake hands with Jews and African Americans.