26 November 2024

Frank Lloyd Wright Chicago church 1905-8.

Frank Lloyd Wright (1867–1959)’s father had been a Universal­ist preacher. With their emphasis on a loving God, Universalists were early advocates of endling slavery and the first church to ordain women. In 1886 Univ­ers­alist Aug­usta Chapin bec­ame minister of the Oak Park Unity Church Chicago, attr­acting new members to the assembly including Lloyd Wright’s mother Anna. Frank’s maternal family were Welsh Unitarians; his uncle Jenkin Lloyd Jones was a noted Unit­arian preacher in Chic­ago where Frank and his first wife Cath­erine Tobin were married in 1889. Wright identified with Unit­ar­­ian­ism’s rational humanism i.e the uniting of all beings with the divine presence. 

Unity Church Oak Park Il
1905-8, Wiki 

A graduate of Harvard Divin­ity School, Pastor R Joh­onnot of Unity Church of Oak Park was known for his lib­eral views. When Unity Ch­urch burned down in Jun 1905, Frank Lloyd Wright was commissioned to re­build for the Unitarian congregation. And in 1906 Dr Joh­onnot published a booklet: A New Edifice for Unity Church. He want­ed a modern building to express the prin­ciples of unity, sim­plicity, freed­om, truth, beauty and reason. Aged 38, Wright was the ideal architect. The design he pres­ent­ed ignored most exist­ing conv­entions for church ar­ch­it­ecture. On the choice of building material Wright stated “There was only one mat­er­ial to choose; concrete, because it was cheap.” Yet Wright kn­ew that concrete was un­con­­ventional for Amer­ic­an and Europ­ean rel­igious arch­itecture; concrete was ugly!

Wright’s philosophy of organic architecture meant his concrete was left uncovered. His mat­erials defined his architect­ure in In the Cause of Ar­chitecture (1908). Without good reason we should not depart from the custom­ary, especially in regard to sacred things. But if the change was gov­­erned by sound reas­on, adjustment is needed. Bring out the nat­ure of the mat­er­ials. Let their nature intim­at­ely into your scheme. Reveal the wood, brick or stone in your designs, they are all by nature friendly and beautiful. No treat­ment can be a matter of fine art when those natural features are neglected.

Approached from Lake St, the building was a massive con­crete shape, sh­elt­ered under a wide flat roof, on a corner of two busy roads. Wright cl­everly ma­nipulated the sanctuary entrance; he guided the visitor via dark passages, as­c­ending into the open, br­ight sanctuary, the heart of a spacious buil­d­ing. Its elegant art­iculat­ion and warm colours contr­asted with the grey concrete ext­er­ior. With no overt rel­ig­ious symb­ols, its geometric proportions harmonised. No open­ing was seen; the top portion of the sanctuary appeared light and transparent except for high clerestory windows with leaded glass and recessed behind piers and overhanging eaves. Thus the building received their natural light.

Set in a concrete grid were 25 squ­are skylights of amber tinted leaded glass. The effect was intended “…to get a sense of a happy cloud­less day into the room… daylight sifting through between the intersecting conc­rete beams, filtering through ceiling lights. Thus the light would have the warmth of sunlight.”

Wright's separate spaces provided for 2 different functions in the mod­ern ch­urch: a sacred place for worship/Unity Temple and a secular one/ Par­ish House for oth­er fac­il­ities. Separating these two functions all­ow­ed for the creation of a specific at­mosphere. The plan showed the two build­ings united by an ent­rance lobby hidden from its surr­oundings, all­owing visitors to ascend from st­reet lev­el to enter the sacred build­ing. The low hall united the build­ings; to the south it op­ened directly onto Parish House with its a central meet­ing hall and bal­c­ony classrooms.

The architect had been given a budget of $45,000, so he chose concrete to save money. Yet the completed building ultimately cost twice the cont­racted pr­ice, due to unexpected problems. In Sept 1909 the new building was dedicated, even though its unique de­sign bore little res­emblance to the other churches along Lake St.

Wright’s theory of organic design was seen in the harmony of the building’s geometric architecture and decorative elements. The cubes were a revolutionary design in the religious arch­itecture world. There was no steeple reaching upwards; instead Wright's focus was within the spaces themselves and their functions. The worship space was a grand 4-storey space with seating on different levels and 3 sides of the room so that noone was 40'+ from the pulpit.

Unity Temple was among the first monumental buildings to be com­prised of reinforced concrete that was poured on site. The con­cr­ete gave the tem­p­le a solid, bold finish that created its monumentality, used to mould the organic details that decorate the exterior of the Prairie-style building. Frank’s Unity Temple was called the greatest public building of the architect’s Chicago years, and one of the U.S’s most famous sac­red buildings. It has been a U.S National Historic Land­mark since 1971.

Wright's leaded glass encircles the flat, coffered ceiling

Column decoration
Wiki

Community Space
FrankLloydWrightFoundation

The Trustees thanked Wright: “We extend to the architect our most hearty congratulations upon the wonderful achievement embodied in the new ed­if­ice and further extend to him our most sincere thanks for the great ser­vice which he has rendered to the parish and to the comm­un­ity. We bel­ieve the building will long endure as a monument to his art­is­tic genius and that it will stand forth as a masterpiece of art and architecture.” Their words were prophetic. Other concrete churches were soon accepted!

Wright’s church is not my favourite in the U.S, but I was very keen to examine his notion of Form Follows Function in a religious building. Thank you to the Frank Lloyd Wright Trust.



19 comments:

thelma said...

He sounds very much like Christopher Alexander who wrote 'A Pattern Language' and then 'The Nature of Order' books. Until I had looked at those books I had never imagined that buildings were nothing but straight lines on the drawing board. So did Wright influence Alexander I wonder.

Handmade in Israel said...

Not sure what I think about the building from the outside, but the inside is attractive. I am familiar with his work since reading "Loving Frank.

roentare said...

The utility temple has a unique design especially the interior

Joe said...

So using concrete was not just to save money.
Wright wrote "In harmony with Wright’s philosophy of organic architecture, the concrete was left uncovered by plaster, brick, or stone, a defining feature of his architecture from early on. Bring out the nature of the materials, reveal the nature of wood, plaster, brick, or stone in your designs, they are all by nature friendly and beautiful. No treatment can be really a matter of fine art when those natural characteristics are neglected.

Jo-Anne's Ramblings said...

I am familiar with the name Frank Llyod Wright but other then that he was a well known architect I knew nothing about him but now I know a bit more, thank you

Andrew said...

It's interior looks wonderful. The exterior, yes...ok.

My name is Erika. said...

That's such an interesting looking church. I don't know if I like it as a church, but it would make a great auditorium. However, you still have to admire the structure.

Margaret D said...

The outside is looking ok to me, the inside is rather pleasant for people to pray in, but 4 stories high, think I read that correctly - must have or had a large congregation, Hels. They say there is money in religion!

Hels said...

thelma
I am not familiar with Christopher Alexander (1936-2022) 's work, but I do know he left Europe for the U.S in 1958 to finish his studies at Harvard, becoming Prof of Architecture a few years later at Berkeley. So Wright's literature and buildings, all completed before he died in 1959, must have greatly impressed the young European architect.

Hels said...

Lisa
"Loving Frank" is well worth reading, but remember it is a novel written by one of Wright's many wives and girlfriends, each with her own perspective on the randy architect.

Now is the time to look at his major contributions:
Robie House Chicago, Illinois;
Fallingwater, Pennsylvania;
Guggenheim Museum, New York etc etc

Hels said...

roentare
The Unity Temple, commissioned by the congregation of Oak Park Unity Church in 1905, was said to be the greatest public building of the architect’s Chicago years. I too love the interior but I find the exterior a bit rough, especially for congregants who were looking for solace.

Hels said...

Joe
that is somewhat confusing, nod. On one hand, the concrete was intentionally left uncovered. On the other hand, the wood and stone were the friendly and beautiful materials with natural characteristics.

Hels said...

Jo-Anne
I recommend you read "Frank Lloyd Wright: His Life and His Architecture" 1987 by Twombly. The biography covers Wright's private life, architecture and role in American society, culture and politics.

River said...

The exterior certainly doesn't look like a church, more like a university library maybe, but the inside is very nice with all those windows and skylights.

Hels said...

Andrew
I suppose modern churches don't have to look like the stunning 13th century gothic Southwark Cathedral, right next to London Bridge. But I do want people to know the Chicago building is a religious site and not a football stadium.
Fortunately the lovely interior was restored, and has been declared a UNESCO World Heritage site.

Hels said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Hels said...

Margaret
I cannot find the exact number of storeys in this Chicago Church but the city was thoroughly enjoying an era of economic expansion. Architects were
producing the first tall buildings, made possible by the introduction of the structural steel skeleton.

Hels said...

River
very nice indeed! The upper part of the sanctuary appears light and transparent. A band of clerestory windows of Wright’s leaded glass encircles the flat, coffered ceiling. Set in a concrete grid are 25 square skylights of amber tinted leaded glass The effect was intended to get a sense of a happy cloudless day into the room… daylight sifting through between the intersecting concrete beams, filtering through amber glass ceiling lights. Thus managed, the light would have the warmth of sunlight.”

F.L.Wright Trust.

Hels said...

Erika
Unity House, the second half of the structure, IS indeed a great auditorium. Unity House was specifically designed for the service of man not God, a secular space with a central meeting hall and balconies for use as open classrooms. Like Wright’s house architecture, note this parish house is centered on a fireplace hearth.