12 September 2023

Jorn Utzon spectacular architecture in Australia & Denmark

The inspiration for Jorn Utzon’s unique Syd­ney Opera House was in the arch­itect’s former hometown. Aalborg, nor­thern Den­mark’s larg­est city, is c5 hours from Copenhagen, bisected by Limf­j­ord Wat­er­way. Ut­zon (1918-2008) was a local teen who loved Sea Scout regattas, ch­an­n­el­l­ing nature into a build­ing decades later.

Utzon’s affinity with the sea shaped his oeuvre. Boat building was part of his creative universe, a place he could escape to. Utzon visited his naval-engineer father in Aalborg’s shipyard, lying under the boats to study how they were assembled. Later he tested boat des­igns; he found boat-design beaut­if­ul but chall­eng­ing, a con­dition that may have affect­ed his later design efforts in Sydney.

Sails and glass walls in the
Sydney Opera House
Utzon's Photos

The project of the Syd­ney Opera House began in 1954 when NSW state premier Joe Cahill brought together a comm­it­tee. An internat­ion­­al design com­p­etition was launched in 1957, attracting international 233 entries. The jury searched for an ambitious concept of an opera house which could become one of the great buildings of the world. They eventually selected 38-year-old Danish Arch­itect Jørn Utzon as the winner, "because of its very original­ity. In Aug 1958 the building process began with flattening the Fort Macquarie Tramsheds on Bennel­ong point

Architect Dr Line Norskov Dav­enport, Exhibitions Director at Aal­borg’s Utzon Centre said Utzon saw the Opera House in parts: the 1]platform, 2]roof and 3]interior, separate but in harmony. It was the interior, partic­ularly the tricky ac­oustics issue, where nature’s influence on the de­sign counted; sound bounced off waves and spread.

Instead of the modernist architecture that had been developing for 30 years, Ut­zon’s design was more sculptural and expressionist. In May 1965 the NSW state government changed when the Conservative parties formed a Coal­ition. By late 1965, Utzon needed £60,000 to build the prototypes he needed to test the large, plywood beams that would be suspended from the shell’s ar­ches to support the ceiling. Without these prototypes, Utzon couldn’t advance with the Opera House’s interior draw­ings, so payments stopped!

In Feb 1966 Utzon met Davis Hughes, NSW minister for Public Works, to discuss the money he was owed for managing the stage machinery con­t­racts. Hughes said he could not make a decision and hours later, Ut­zon’s secretary handed a letter to Hughes in which Utzon accused the Minister of forcing him out. Hughes quickly made arrange­ments for an Opera House without Utzon’s involvement and sought assurances from the engineers and builders that they could continue. Hughes told the press and Parliament that very evening that Utzon had resigned.

Utzon’s sacking caused an outcry eg protest letters from em­in­ent ar­t­ists, designers and intellectuals. People marched on NSW’s State Par­l­iam­ent, led by great architect Har­ry Seidler and famous au­thor Patrick White for Utzon’s restoration. At the same time, there was a constant, unpleasant media swirl around the project. The work cont­in­ued but Hughes offered Utzon only the subordinate consultant role.

English engineer Ove Arup, responsible for building the Opera House shells, pleaded with Utzon to reconsider. The Op­­era House’s fu­t­­ure without him was unthinkable, but the Ut­zon-Gov­ernment rupture was complete; the Min­is­t­er banned further negoti­ati­­on.

In Ap 1966 Minister Hughes appointed another panel of Australian ar­ch­it­ects to complete the Opera House, with Peter Hall heading De­sign and completing the interiors. The Utzon family flew home, carrying an inc­omplete set of the Stage 3 drawings. Utzon had told his staff that the Minister would realise the Op­era House could not be com­pl­eted without him and that he’d be back within 2 years. Wrong ☹

How did Denmark feel about Australia’s treatment of Utzon? Most Dan­es felt a sense of pride that a countryman went to distant Australia to create the symbol of cultural Australia. But does the story of his depart­ure still have sad meanings for Danes?

Bagsvaerd Church, Copen­hagen
ArchDaily
 
After returning home, Utzon’s first project (1976) was Bagsvaerd Church, Copen­hagen. The exterior has strange concrete walls and metal roof but it was the interior that most resembled the Opera House. A sp­l­it and curving ceiling rose to an arch where light ent­er­s via semi-hidden windows. The interior space amazes architect­ural groups.

The Utzon Centre in Aalborg opened 6 months before the architect’s death in 2008, modern design that contrasts with Aal­borg’s old streets. The Cent­re holds all of his arch­ives, on display in a perm­anent exh­ib­ition. This treasure chamber of exhibits has prot­o­types, models, documents and reports, some reflecting on the Sydney crisis in 1966. See the Yellow Book Exhibit which captured Utzon’s final geometric principle of the roof.

While his work is the Utzon Centre’s heart, it operates as a broa­d­er display of architecture and design. There’s a department at Aal­borg University in a post-Utzon discipline, robotics studio, child­ren’s space and upstairs auditorium with a ceiling curving to skylights.

Aalborg has a fine Music House of its own, containing a concert hall and practice rooms for the Aalborg Symphony Orchestra and The Royal Academy of Music. It didn’t open (2014) until after Utzon passed away.

See the distinct­ive Museum of Modern Art designed by an Utzon mentor, Finnish archit­ect Alvar Aalto; Aalborg is a very cultural city. Since 1987 music stars visiting Aalborg were invited to plant trees in a park, and noted artists have painted c80 buildings with murals.

House of Music AAlborg
Floornature.com

Utzon Centre, Aalborg
Tropter

In Oct 2023 Sydney Opera House’s 50th birthday festival will display the performing arts. Utzon’s children, designer Lin & architect Jan, will discuss their father’s legacy in a lecture. And see a pro­gr­amme of performances by Australian contemporary artists, the ch­amber orch­estra Academy of St Martin in the Fields and Sadler’s Wells Theatre

Read the excellent Our Story Jørn Utzon.





28 comments:

jabblog said...

Most interesting. How sad, though, that such unpleasantness intruded. The opera house is such a beautiful building.

Hels said...

jabblog

The state Labour government selected Danish Arch­itect Jorn Utzon as the winner of the 223 architects in the 1957 competition because of his plans' original­ity and modernity. Utzon was possibly a bit controversial back even then, but until the Conservatives got into power in 1965, Utzon had no idea how much his work would be reviled. The Conservatives weren't just unpleasant; they breached the detailed contract :(

Deb said...

The Utzon Centre in Aalborg is an experimental cultural facility, where the guides said architecture, design, art and communication combined. It was very impressive but for me the Sydney Opera House had a more spectacular location.

My name is Erika. said...

Wow, what an interesting story. I can see the boat theme now that you mention it, but I never did before. But that wasn't very nice to oust Utzon like that. I'll never look at images of the Sydney Opera HOuse in the same way after reading this. Hope you're having a lovely week so far.

Hels said...

Deb

the two buildings are both located on the water edge, but the Sydney Opera House was built on Bennelong Point. This promontory on the south side of the harbour, near the Sydney Harbour Bridge, looks as if it was there specifically to make the Opera House look like a yacht ON the water. If there was no naturally occurring promontory there, I would have had people "build" a promontory. Beauty is everything!

Hels said...

Erika

it just goes to show us... what is loved by one generation might be hated by the next. Once one political party or religion gives its imprimatur to a building, another political party or religion was withdraw permission only a decade later.

When the Eiffel Tower was first built (1887-9), the people of Paris were very angry with its ugly intrusion into the landscape. The plan was Eiffel could use the tower for a while, then the Parisian authorities would destroy it. Yet.. yet it became a precious Parisian icon.

Jo-Anne's Ramblings said...

There are so many lovely buildings in the world as well as some what the hell looking buildings

Andrew said...

He was shamefully treated and it is fortunate that we had enough talent in Australia to complete the construction.

In the 1980s we took a backstage tour of the Opera House and we were told of all the remediation work that had to be undertaken to make the sound half decent but still far from perfect. I expect some forty years later modern acoustical engineering has made the sound quality much better.

Hels said...

Jo-Anne

That is why it was important to have a world wide competition so that the judges could see hundreds of responses from many different countries, thus accounting for many different tastes. But even without the impact of climate, pollution and neglect over the decades, some people are going to loathe the outcome in the long term.

Hels said...

Andrew

When the Sydney Opera House was first conceived, the competing architects were told it had to be one of the 20th century’s most iconic buildings. Although I don't suppose the architects knew anything about acoustic engineering, the selection panel knew the winning entry had to break new ground for design and engineering. The Sydney building would make people all around the world awe struck! And it did.

Margaret D said...

Very interesting Hels. I remember the building of the Opera House, its was so long ago yet it doesn't seem so.
I rather like those buildings too..

Hels said...

Margaret

my beloved was in Sydney until 1970, and was acutely aware of the building of the Opera House and then the slowing down and fighting. He probably didn't understand the political and financial feuds, but he certainly remembered that Sydney was becoming the most glamorous city in Australia.

In Melbourne I knew nothing much about that entire Sydney project, except for outside photos taken from passing ferries. You in Tassie probably watched The Menzies Institute for Medical Research the University of Tasmania or other large projects.

roentare said...

Reading your piece about the Opera house was a great learning experience again. I was told by people that they were not impressed by the opera in there.

Hels said...

roentare

as Andrew suggested, the remediation work that done on the sound was imcomplete and in any case needs modernising. I wouldn't know acoustical engineering if it smacked me on the cheek, but I do know you are right about complaints.

bazza said...

This must be one of the world's top three or four instantly recognisable structures!: Eiffel Tower, Statue of Liberty, Big Ben's Elizabeth Tower (or possibly Tower Bridge.) There have been many other buildings inspired by the Sydney Opera house.
Incidentally it's amazing to think that a five hour journey is even possible within Denmark - but it is.

prakhar said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Hels said...

bazza

there must have been a number of epic structures in every country in every century. Just think of Imperial Rome, where the Colosseum and the Pantheon are spectacular. Then consider Hagia Sophia in Turkey, and Notre Dame Cathedral in medieval Paris. That is not to say these buildings couldn't be destroyed by wars or earthquakes! But it does agree with what you called instantly recognisable structures.

Hels said...

prakhr

thanks for reading the post, but no advertising please.

ប្រលោមលោក​ ក្តៅសាច់ said...

Thanks for sharing! Truly inspiring! My website: បាល់ទះ​ 2023 Thank you for your interest.

Parnassus said...

Australia is lucky to have this Utzon original, despite the government treating the architect like dirt. SO often with sculpture-like buildings, the original is amazing, while the thousand later derivatives are, well, derivative.
--Jim

Britta said...

Dear Helen, thank you for this post!
I didn't know that Utzon had such a deep connection with boats. I adore the photos (haven't been there) of the Sidney Opera House. It has such an organic form - like shells from the sea - and now I know more about it's creator.

Hels said...

Emma

Have you visited Sydney, or Aalborg? If not, I warmly recommend a guided tour with lots of photographs :)

Hels said...

Parnassus

when a new movement started in any of the arts, there may have be only 1 or 2 people who started making it famous. Then it slowly started to spread to 5, 10 and even 100 followers, before it was generally accepted by the official Academies. So The Bauhaus was founded in 1919 in Weimar by German architect Walter Gropius, then Paul Klee, Laszlo Moholy-Nagy and Wassily Kandinsky. Soon bold, clean lines, simple functionality, one main colour, minimalism and little decoration appeared everywhere in German and beyond. This was not derivative in the sense you mean... this was being part of a growing movement.

The NSW State Government was nasty, but worse still they could have ruined Utzon's masterpiece.

Hels said...

Britta

young Utzon's connection with the sea and boats was a pleasure for his own life and an inspiration for much of his architectural career. Australia, Denmark and other countries benefited, happily.

Hilary Melton-Butcher said...

Hi Hels - the same unpleasantness happened with my grandfather and the Sydney Harbour Bridge back in the '20s; Utzon created a wonderful architectural building with great acoustics I gather. I hadn't realised all the shell pieces, if put together would form a perfect sphere ... as you mention above he was an inspiration. Cheers Hilary

Hels said...

Hilary

even professional architects had to analyse Utzon's work carefully, to understand his goals. I suspect that was part of the problem from the NSW minister for Public Works' perspective. And from the more traditionalist architects and designers. But that is exactly why Utzon won the competition in the first place!

Sydney Morning Herald said...

Lin Utzon recalls her father’s gentle humanity and brilliant mind, that time the King of Spain called and the rapprochement with Australia she never thought would happen. By Jeni Porter, Sydney Morning Herald, Sept 28, 2023

The story is party of the Sydney Opera House 50th Anniversary Magazine.

Hels said...

Thank you Lin and thank you Jeni.

Since I couldn't have travelled to Sydney, I knew the Sydney Opera House Anniversary Magazine
was always going to be important.