21 April 2020

Distance learning for American and Australian students - long before coronavirus

For those who see 2020 as the time when distance education/homeschooling exp­lod­ed, Three Centuries of Distance Learning by Livia Gershon described the long historic infrastructure that enabled this expansion. Coronvirus is new, but distance learning is far from new.

Roy Sleator began the USA's history of distance learning in 1728, suggesting that students could have “several lessons sent weekly to them, and be as perfectly instructed as those that live in Boston.” Correspondence courses emerged in the C19th, when improvements to the postal service made it practical. The Pittman Shorthand course, established in Cincinnati in 1852, allowed secretarial students to mail in their work and, upon successful completion of the course, received a certificate of expertise.

And would-be sec­ret­aries weren’t the only ones to turn to corresp­ondence courses. In 1874 at Illinois Wesleyan University where degrees could be earned without being actually present in the classes. In 1890, the Colliery School of Mines created a correspondence course on mine safety. Over the next 3 decades, it evolved into the International Corresp­ondence School, which offered courses by mail for iron and railroad workers, and miners.

But by then live radio shows allowed educators to talk directly to students at home, even if the broadcast only went one way. By 1923, 10+% of broadcast radio stations were owned by educational instit­utions. And by 1934, Iowa University was broadcasting televised courses. Other tertiary institutions followed suit.

In time satellite TV could deliver a combination of live and rec­orded course material. It also let students call their teachers by phone and have questions answered on air in real time. Event­ually the USA adopted the technology associated with distance learning today, the World Wide Web. Jones International University, the first completely internet-based higher education institution accredited by the Higher Learning Commission, opened in 1993.

In Australia distance learning has long been an issue for children living in isolated parts of the continent where no school was est­ab­lished. I imagine that distance was the greatest challenge for education in the largest states, and those with the least central­ised populat­ions eg Queen­sland and Western Australia. These states covered a vast area, with small communities spread over many thousands of square kilometres.

In the early C20th the states’ Departments of Education started an it­in­erant teacher scheme, travelling through the outback often on horseback. They visited families with children and prov­id­ed school­ing, if only for a brief time and for only a few times each year.

New South Wales was the first to create Travelling Schools in 1908 where correspondence lessons could be incorporated as part of a learning regime.

During WW1 the existing schools in rural areas were closing, lead­ing to the growth of the Correspondence School, a bet­ter distance education method. Teachers were based in the cap­ital cities and lessons posted to and from students. Thankfully the dev­elop­ment of a good postal system made it possible to deliver mat­erials to children across outback Aust­ralia via the post in the 1920s.

During the inter-war years, the invention of the pedal radio by Alfred Traeger was significant. And in 1944 Adelaide Miethke, a member of the Council of the Flying Doctor Service of South Aust­ralia, created a plan to use two-way radio to give educational talks to children in outback regions of Australia. This was the core of the soon-to-be estab­lish­ed School of the Air, the term for distance schools catering for the primary and early second­ary education of children in remote and outback Australia.

The first lessons were officially sent from the Royal Flying Doctor Service in Alice Springs in mid 1951. Each state of Australia that utilised this means of training (all except Tasmania) had well-documented supervision of the service.

The radio network, maintained by the Royal Flying Doctor Service, was used by each child at home.
Photo: Broken Hill School of the Air.

The radio network, maintained by the Royal Flying Doctor Service, was used by the teachers to make two-way broadcasts to the children. 
Photo credit: NSW Dept of Educatio

For students in isolated sites, the School of the Air was often their first chance of socialisation with children outside their im­mediate family. Each student typically spent an hour each day rec­eiving group or individual lessons from the teacher, and the rest of the day work­ing through the assigned materials with a parent or tutor. Additionally each student had direct cont­act with a teacher in an inland town like Broken Hill or Alice Springs each year, meeting other youngsters face to face. Studies have shown that such educat­ion was equal to the standards of traditional schools.

From the 1950s school classes were conducted via shortwave radio. Traditionally the students received their course materials and re­turned their written work and projects to their hub centre, using either the Royal Flying Doctor Service or post-office mail.

Isolated children soon had access to lessons via School of the Air, using HF radio to interact with their teach­ers and classmates. However the extension of Internet services into the outback event­ually enabled more rapid review of each child's homework. Most schools switched to the modern tech­nologies, delivering lessons that included live one-way video feeds and clear two-way audio.

By the 1990s developers of distance learning resources were max­im­ising the opportunities offered by digital technology eg res­ources could be delivered on CD-ROM or DVD. Now whole courses can be del­ivered online. Learning objects offer in­ter­active and engag­ing learning experiences around specific topics.

By 2005, all Schools of Distance Educat­ion delivered regular sched­uled lessons, representing one of the most signific­ant changes to the delivery of Australian distance educ­at­ion in de­cades. The great­ly improved service provides clearer reception and more reliable transmission.

Conclusion
Historically Australia delivered education over distance via corr­espondence and print based learning materials. Then radio was dev­eloped for use in distance-learning, to support and enhance the print based materials. And over time emerg­ing tech­nol­ogies were incorporated into the possible delivery op­tions.

If students are isolated from school into the future, through a pan­demic or any other cause, ensuring the best educational outcomes will still dep­end on the creation of app­ropriate learning resourc­es. And on inter­action with skilled teach­ers via the Internet.





16 comments:

Parnassus said...

Hello Hels, Yes, distance learning does have a long history, but it is especially important to look out for sharp practices--diploma mills, non-standard academic content, and the like. I am currently taking an on-line course, and while I am enjoying it and benefiting from it, I can tell the difference between it and what actually takes places on a campus, with its infinite resources and atmosphere for learning.

Today's students will have the challenge and potential benefits of forging new methods of learning away from distant resources.
--Jim

Deb said...

Home schooling, voluntarily chosen by the parents, sounds a bit different. No technology needed.

Hels said...

Parnassus

I was particularly interested in distance primary and high schooling, universal education and free.

I hadn't thought of tertiary education before, at least in Australia. It is inevitable that if tertiary courses are privately run (for profit) in the USA and elsewhere, they may well be diploma mills with non-standard academic content. Mind you, if coronavirus or similar continues into the future, Australia's tertiary courses may change as well.


Hels said...

Deb

The Australian Home Schooling page says home education is a legally recognised alternative to enrolling a child in school, from around the age of 6 until 17. If the parent chooses home education, they must apply to the state authority for permission. Parents must submit a plan for their home education, which should show an alignment between their child’s learning and the national curriculum. Or they can develop their own plan, in line with their philosophies of education or religious beliefs.

Very different from the Education Department's distance learning, I think.

Masud Hossain said...

Oh hells, yes, distance education is currently an on-line course and many are enjoying it and benefiting from it, my brother is taking courses online and my brother is very helpful.

drawingkidunia

Hels said...

Masud

you are quite right... people _are_ finding on line courses and seem to be enjoying them very much. Goes to show you how old fashioned I was :)

Most countries wanted some families to live on the land, in remote areas. But then what did the children in those families do - go without schooling altogether? or leave home and move into a boarding school?

Now with pandemics, unemployment and less disposable income, families will have to rely on top quality learning resourc­es on line.

Klaus Morgan said...

Thanks for sharing integrated shala darpan with us, guys! You are doing a great thing!

Hels said...

Klaus

I had to look up shala darpan. Shaala Darpan is an ICT programme of Ministry of Human Resource Development, Government of India that provides mobile access to parents of students of Government and Government aided schools.

Thank you for widening the discussion beyond Australia and the USA.

Anonymous said...

I really wondered about the panic of staying at home and learn using modern technology, as remote distance learning has been around for a long time using whatever method was available, as you have written about. There is a nice photo of one of the Royals with a student who is participating in a School of the Air lesson.

Hels said...

Andrew

no panic. But if learning from home is to become the norm, at least during this crisis, we need to worry about those families that don't have internet, or have too many children to share their computer fairly. I don't think the standard of on-line education for school children will be a problem, once the Education Dept takes control of the curriculum and reading material.

Hilary Melton-Butcher said...

Hi Hels - a lot of people have learnt a great deal very quickly ... I have to admit I'm avoiding it ... lots of other things to interest me ... but one day I'll be glad of it. It's interesting to read your historical take from the Aussie point of view - thanks for that ... take care - Hilary

Hels said...

Hilary

everything is changing so rapidly this year... we more mature people don't know what is happening to the world we grew up in. But then our parents had to do the same, after the husbands came home after the war, when tv appeared in our homes and women took on employment responsibilities etc.

Retirement, voluntary or otherwise, is a landmark point in life that every has to deal with. If we survive the current pandemic, all sorts of educational and social programmes will be opening to us.

bazza said...

This is such a timely and topical subject. The Flying Doctor Service is world-famous. Does it still exist? Are you familiar with the wonderful Eric Bogle song, Now I'm Easy?:
I married a fine girl when I was twenty
But she died in giving birth when she was thirty
No flying doctor then, just a gentle old black 'gin
But it's nearly over now, and now I'm easy
.
My daughter studied at a Pitman's college in London (a gift from Leah's mother) and that led to a job in the circulation department of the Jewish Chronicle. Now she is the practice manager of a large law firm in Inner Temple, London.
I left school at an early age because my father was a tradesman and not 'sold' on education. So I started to educate myself, via correspondence courses, evening classes and culminating in a degree from the Open University. I still do courses, mainly on line and mainly free!
CLICK HERE for Bazza’s truculently tenacious Blog ‘To Discover Ice’

Hels said...

bazza

Thankfully the Flying Doctor Service is bigger and even more important to outback people than ever before, yes.

People leave school too early, or don't go to a local school/tertiary institution at all, for very different reasons. But as we have seen over the 100 years, all sorts of alternatives had to develop. You were very wise to find the evening courses and Open University education that met your needs.

Distance Pathshala said...

It is really helpful article for students, Thank you for sharing this informative article.
"Online BBA in Marketing"

Hels said...

Distance Pathshala

thank you. This is a topic that is becoming more and more important every year. As you know from your own work.