26 October 2024

Medieval travellers were quite like us

 Our perception of medieval Europe is of a confined world in which people rarely travelled beyond their own locality, and when they did it was for religious reasons. But Paul Oldfield asked us to consider Southern Italy and Sic­ily. Due to its central Mediterranean location, the region began to at­tract more European visitors for three main reasons:

Canterbury Tales
Amazon

Firstly various factors converged to boost the popularity of distant pilgrimage. After the crus­ading movement started in 1095, Europe experienced its golden era of devotional trav­el to Jerusalem. Pilgrimage offered the best med­ieval equiv­al­ent of the modern tourist trade, even though some pilgrims travelled not solely for pious motivations eg a crusade might have cloaked political and economic agendas.

Secondly South­ern Italy and Sicily were conquered by bands of Normans who unified a region which had previously been polit­ically frag­ment­ed (eg Greek Christians, Latin Christians, Jews and Mus­lims). By 1130 the Normans had created a powerful new mon­archy which had been domin­at­ed by Muslim sea-power.

Thirdly Europe underwent a cultural renaissance so learn­ed ind­ividuals travelled to seek clas­sical traditions. South­ern Italy and Sicily, with clas­sical history and with a Greek and Islamic past, attracted both an­cient & eastern learning.

The result of these three combined strands saw an influx of visit­ors who could properly be called tour­ists. High numbers of people regularly travelled both short and long distances, and some of this move­ment was driven by modern motivations: renewal, leisure and thrill-seeking.

While the pilgrims were travelling across foreign lands, they were encouraged to imitate Christ, to feel hardship and to focus on salvation. At many shrines en route, pil­g­rims could stay near a holy tomb, to receive cures or divine rev­el­ations. Even pilgrims were exper­ient­ial travellers.

South Italy possessed one of medieval Europe’s more sophist­ic­ated travel infrastruc­tures. Being so close to the heart of the former Roman empire, it still boasted functioning Roman roads which linked into the main route - it brought travel­l­ers from western Europe across the Alps to Rome. Via Appia helped travellers to move across the south Italian Ap­en­nines to the coastal ports of Apulia, while another road went via Calabria towards the bustling Messina port.

South Italian ports hosted fleets of local ships as well as those of the emerging commercial powers of Genoa, Pisa and Venice. So the pilgrim had secure, effic­ient and direct connections. At the same time, new hospitals, inns, bridges and monasteries emerged along It­aly’s main pilgrim routes, or near shrines for foreign vis­it­ors. The major Apulian and Sicilian ports often hosted pilgrim hospit­als belonging to Holy Land military monastic orders, Templars and Hospitallers. Mes­s­ina was a particularly hectic port.

 
Pilgrim badge bought at
shrine at Saint-Josse-sur-Mer, France
Pinterest

Most of the surviving evidence focuses on elite travellers – nobles and bishops. But travel, and pilgrimage in particular, was also undertaken by the very poorest. Monastic rules out­lined their monks’ duty to offer free hospitality to all trav­ellers. It was also good advertising for shrine centres to be seen to cater for all backgrounds. After all, foreign visit­ors spent money on local serv­ices and on profitable tolls. The guardians of southern Italy’s shrine centres actively competed for travellers.

Many pilgrims suffered from debilitating conditions, and struggled to cope with travelling demands. Many died. One chronicler of the First Crusade saw the drowning of 400 pilgrims in Brindisi harbour but, he said, dying as a pilgrim brought the hope of salvation. Of course threats of robbery, shipwreck and dis­ease remained - no wonder pilgrims travelled in groups. It makes sense that the word travel comes from ancient word travail, meaning hardship.

Southern Italy’s landscape elicited wonder and fear. Its seas in the busy Straits of Mess­ina were full of tidal rips. Muslim travellers suffered a near-fatal shipwreck in the Straits in the 1180s. The famous 1280 map, Hereford Mappa Mundi, por­t­rayed two sea monsters lurking in Sicilian waters.

Erupt­ions at Vesuvius and Etna were a regul­ar feature: one struck at Catania Sicily in 1169 killing 15,000 people. The region’s volcanoes had even greater potency, connecting them to Hell’s Entrance and showing God’s disapproval.

In c1170 a Spanish Jewish traveller and author, Benjamin of Tudela, pas­s­ed near Naples and marvelled at the sight of an ancient city submerged just off the coast. Like many travellers, he came there to access cutting-edge medical knowl­ed­ge, a fusion of Arabic and ancient Greek learning that had been a specialty in Salerno.

To prove that travellers had been to the distant city they had aimed for, each would buy a badge to show off back at home. Typically made of lead alloy, the badges were sold as souven­irs at Christian pilgrimage sites and related to the part­ic­ular saint ven­er­ated there. The shrine at Saint-Josse-sur-Mer in France was named after a hermit, St Jos, in a monastery. His hermitage became a popular site for late C14th English pilgrims on the way to more distant shrines.

In the most appealing and popular sites across Europe (Jerusalem in Is­rael, Compost­ela in Spain, Canterbury in Eng­land, Cologne in Germany etc) the badges tended to be standardised eg St Thomas Becket was the most popular sub­ject in Canberbury and a shell was sold most frequently in Compostela.

Hereford Mappa Mundi
map created in 1280.
Media Storehouse

Conclusion 
Medieval travellers displayed traits that reflected aspects of our modern understanding of tourism. Southern Italy was an alluring travel hotspot - it had devel­oped travel and serv­ice structures, it catered for those seek­ing spiritual salvat­ion, it provided learning and tested those who sought chall­enges. Those challenges were often sought as ends in them­selves.





19 comments:

My name is Erika. said...

It's interesting how how the misconception about travel prevails through societies. But if you think about, people have probably always been on the move, even back to our earliest ancestors. Have a great weekend Hels.

roentare said...

It is that perception that medieval Europe was rather confined in their locality. A beautifully written article again

Ирина Полещенко said...

Dear Helen! I am sure that in the Middle Ages people were like us. They also suffered, loved their children, dreamed of a happy life, hated war.
Helen, I invite you to watch Steven Seagal's film on my blog. I hope you know this American actor.

hels said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Ирина Полещенко said...

Dear Helen! Steven Seagal is not an anti-Semite. He is simply comparing how carefully Russia wages war without killing a single civilian. Do you know how many women and children were killed in the Gaza Strip, in Lebanon, Iran, Syria, Yemen? Israel is at war with 5 countries. At the BRICS summit, our President V.V. Putin said that only the creation of a Palestinian state can stop the war.

Margaret D said...

Interesting. Back then they sure did have problems in their travel, not like today we just hop on a plane or in a car and off we go.

jabblog said...

That is a most interesting post. Today's pilgrims are not so very different in outlook to those of times past. It is faith and curiosity that leads them on. I don't regard tourists as pilgrims, though.

Parnassus said...

Hello Hels, I agree with Erika that travel was probably more common then previously imagined. Ancient mythologies are filled with epics that involved lots of travel, which at least shows that the idea was familiar. Also, the evidence keeps mounting for more and more complicated trade routes in the ancient world. Well, trading is like travel--it involves groups of people going to distant places, where they would need services such as lodging, food and medical care, which would pave the way for more ordinary travelers.
--Jim

Deb said...

Were mediaeval travellers warned about plagues in the same way we were warned about Covid?

hels said...

Erika
Good question. Mediaeval traders may have travelled often, but mediaeval people who left home because of religious or cultural reasons probably made their dream trip only once on their lives.

hels said...

roentare
Mediaeval travellers could only go as far in one day as their horse could manage. Wealthier travellers could at least take a wagon and swap the horse when they arrived at a horse exchange facility.

hels said...

Irina
Right! But not only did they have to worry about their own health and safety. Mediaeval men had to worry about the wives and children they left at home, without any income for some months.

hels said...

Margaret
Modern travellers still have to worry about:
1.Catching covid and other diseases in foreign lands;
2.Running into wars they may not even know of;
3.Their planes and ships being suddenly cancelled;
4.Insurance not covering sudden emergencies overseas etc.

albert said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
hels said...

jabblog
Exactly. Pilgrims may not have had any more money than others, but they were driven by their church's teaching to visit a key holy site at least once in their lives. Thus I tried not to use the word tourists.

hels said...

Parnassus
When I was writing about the Silk Road, those traders thought they and their precious goods were protected eg by travelling in caravans. And they were indeed better off than non-traders.

But even they were attacked by robber gangs.

hels said...

Deb
Pilgrims were certainly warned about plagues, knowing they were very often fatal.
Each pilgrim was given a badge to wear outside his clothing, blessed by the priest before leaving home. If and when they arrived safely at Santiago de Compostela or wherever, the badge was pressed against the saint, to strengthen the protection against the plague.

hels said...

Thanks for writing but I really don't value Seagal's name on my blog. I am sure you understand.

Hels said...

albert
ha ha... this is an Australian blog. Totally illegal here.