17 June 2023

Frank LLoyd Wright II, Kaufmann family & Fallingwater

Fallingwater, built directly over the falls
Wiki

I visited Pittsburgh for the first time in 1994 and one of the great day-tours was to Fallingwater. This home was near Mill Run in Penn­syl­vania, designed by American architect Frank Lloyd Wright (1867-1959) in 1935 and completed in 1937. The house was designed as a private res­id­ence for the Pittsburgh department store owner, Ed­gar Kauf­mann (1885-1955), his wife Lillian (1889-1952) and their son.

Edgar I commissioned Wright to design a weekend retreat on the fam­ily’s land near Pittsburgh. Kaufmann had been introduced to Wright by his son in 1934, when the lad partic­ip­ated in Wright’s Talies­in Train­ing Fellowship for arch­it­ects and artists. Wright was 67 at the meet­ing, with few commissions in the midst of the Great Depres­sion. His car­eer was nearing retirement, the early suc­cess of his Prairie style residences in the early 1900s having long declined.

Construction of Fallingwater finally began in 1936. Local craftsmen and labourers were hired, and mater­ials were directly exc­av­ated from the Kaufmanns’ land. Wright might have been nudging 70, but he still had a bold vision for architecture. Fallingwater would be a master­piece of Wright’s theor­ies on organic ar­chitecture, which sought to integrate humans, arch­itecture and nat­ure together so that each one would be improved by the rel­at­ion­ship. Wright believed that architecture must sit com­fortably within its natural landscape, rep­licate its forms and use its materials. So Fallingwater grew from the site’s rocky landscape. Its concrete ter­races floated directly above the waterfalls, drawing attention to the water. Their horiz­on­t­­al forms high­lighted the boulders below. Although the ter­r­aces app­eared to hover, they were anchored to the cent­ral stone chim­ney using cant­il­evers!
  
The windows blended into natural stonewalls and fireplace, 
and corners were made of glass for unobstructed views
Nalata

Hence the expansive terraces occupied half the building, while the interior spaces were small with low ceilings, creating a sheltered cave in the rugged landscape. The building drew nature inside its 3 floors: natural cliffs protruded from the central fire-place and the sound of rushing water was always pres­ent. The design focused on the central fireplace, and the home off­er­ed unique fea­tures like cu­stom­ised niches to disp­lay the Kaufmanns’ art works.

Fallingwater was main­ly complete in 1937, with the family soon occ­up­ying the residence. It gained more fame when Time Magazine feat­ur­ed Wright and the building plan on its Jan 1938 cover; the dar­ing cons­truction over a waterfall was instrumental in reviving Wright’s ar­ch­itecture career.

Wright added a guest house in sandstone quarried from the property, in 1939. Fallingwater had proved that Wright was an enduring visionary ready for the rest of his career. Some of his most high-profile commis­sions came after, including the Guggenheim Museum in N.Y. The Kaufmanns con­tinued to reside in Fallingwater.

Light and garden views stream into the loungeroom
INSIDEWRIGHT

Son Edgar Kaufmann II (1910-1989) attended the School for Arts & Crafts at the Austrian Museum of Applied Art in Vienna, in the late 1920s. Then he stud­ied painting for 3 years in Flor­ence. Af­t­er reading Frank Lloyd Wright's autobiog­raphy, young Edgar decided to become a resident apprentice in archit­ecture at Wright's Taliesin East School and Studio from 1933-4.

When he left Wright's Taliesin Fellowship in 1935, Edgar II joined the family business and became merchandise manager for home furn­ish­ings, and in 1938, worked for the Kaufmann Dept Stores. In 1940 Edgar wrote to Alfred Barr of the Museum of Modern Art/MOMA, propos­ing the Or­g­anic Design in Home Furnishings Comp­etition, won by Charles Eam­es and Eero Saarinen.

He served with the Army Air Forces from 1942-6 in WW2. After, he became dir­ector of the Industrial Design Dept at M.O.M.A in NY. Ed­g­ar's greatest success during his time at MOMA was the Good Design Programme of 1950-5, in which the museum joined with the Mer­chandise Mart in Chicago, promoting design in household furniture. 

Fallingwater architect, Frank Lloyd Wright
MinnieMuse

After his father's death in 1955, Edgar II inherited Falling-water, using it as a mountain retreat. Act­ing on his fat­her’s wishes, Edgar entrusted the building and surrounding land to the West­ern Pennsylvania Conservancy in 1963. In 1964 Fal­l­ing­wat­er open­ed to the public as an architectural house museum, surrounded by 5,100 acres of nat­ur­al land called the Bear Run Nature Reserve. Fal­l­­ing­water was the only major Wright work to come into the public domain with its original furnishings and artwork intact. 

From 1963-86, Edgar II was Ass professor of Architecture and Art History at Col­um­bia Uni and wrote books on architecture and modern design. When he died in 1989, Edgar II’s ashes were scattered around Fall­ing­water by his partner since the 1950s, Paul Mayén. 21 pieces of the family’s art and sculpture coll­ect­ion were auc­tioned at Soth­eby's New York - works of Mon­d­rian, Léger, Klee, Picasso, Braque, Monet, Matisse, de Koon­ing, Calder, Duchamp and Miró. Finally Paul Mayén oversaw the building of Falling­wat­er’s pavilion from 1979-81, housing the café, gift store and visitor’s centre. 

In 2019 the residence was designated a UNESCO World Heritage site, along with 7 other Lloyd Wright designs. In total 5+ million visitors have toured Fallingwater.





22 comments:

roentare said...

Can't believe this is also UNESCO world heritage site. There are so many stories behind this Fallingwater.

Andrew said...

If ever an example was needed to describe the two words 'street appeal', this is it. What a stunning yet unobtrusive building.

Train Man said...

This very morning, the Weekend Australian showed a Garden Award nominee in Hawthorn East. With no front fence or front lawn, there was plenty of space for plants and floating concrete platforms. The garden attracts many people who stop and talk about the plants, encouraging conversation and sparking joy.

jabblog said...

That is an amazing piece of architecture. One would feel part of nature living in such a building.

Hels said...

roentare

you have my complete attention now :) What sort of stories?

Hels said...

Andrew

Wright believed that architecture must sit com­fortably within its natural landscape, rep­licate its forms and use its materials. But normally that sort of language is usually more poetic and less technical. This time, he made the theoretical -> literal.

Hels said...

Train Man

I don't remember if Fallingwater was surrounded by a fence or not; if it was, I didn't notice it at all. In any case, I would agree that Fallingwater had plenty of space for plants and floating concrete platforms. Thank you for your Hawthorn East comparison; Wright's garden brought great joy to the area.

Hels said...

jabblog

designing buildings where the family can feel part of nature is not easy, except perhaps in Jordanian deserts, Australian beach-bush land and Icelandic snow territory. But Wright was keen to make it happen.

No wonder he was rude about his Bauhaus contemporaries who promoted a constructive discipline melding sculpture, painting, design and architecture into a synthesis of free imagination and strict structure.

Student of History said...

Helen I know you are a Bauhaus fan. So let me quote the Khan Academy. In 1932 Henry-Russell Hitchcock and Philip Johnson opened the "Modern Architecture: International Exhibition" at the newly founded Museum of Modern Art in NY, publishing the book International Style. This was perhaps the most influential architectural exhibit ever mounted in the United States and the book became a manifesto for modern architecture and would profoundly affect almost every major architectural project worldwide for the next 30 years. It focused on the work of four great European functionalists Walter Gropius, Ludwig Mies van der Rohe, Le Corbusier and JJP Oud. Wright was largely snubbed.

https://www.khanacademy.org/humanities/ap-art-history/later-europe-and-americas/modernity-ap/a/frank-lloyd-wright-fallingwater

DUTA said...

Nowadays, at least where I live, there'll be second thoughts on whether to allow someone to build on, or close to, a Nature's element as Nature's resources are considered public.There's a big debate going on for some years about a river flowing through a kibbutz (settlement) near the residents' houses; people of a neighboring town consider this very improper, and are demanding free use of the river.

My name is Erika. said...

I enjoy visiting interesting architecture (thanks to my Dad who was an architect). This home has been on my list for several years now. One day I hope I might visit the PIttburgh area to see it, but for now I just enjoyed your post Hels. And you've also reminded that there are 2 Frank Lloyd Wright houses about an hour away from me which you can tour through a local museum. They are definitely not Falling Water, but I think I will make an effort to go visit them this summer one day. Have a lovely rest of your weekend. hugs-Erika

Hels said...

Student

Yes!! It acknowledge's Wright's confidence in his own American architecture, but it also suggests the importance of Edgar Kaufmann II in Wright's rise to the top.. over a 25-year client/architect connection! Wright might have been cranky by then, but Kaufmann was a great client and understood the price of working with genius.

Hels said...

DUTA

I absolutely understand the new laws that preserve the natural environment for all people (and animals) to enjoy, so that private buildings need to be carefully considered and possibly be prevented.

But in 1934 Wright was a leader in trying to preserve nature, albeit in a different way. He became an organic architect, one who carefully designed building structures that blended into their natural surroundings. It was radical _then_ because Wright planned architecture that was a bridge to nature, not a blockage. He said he wanted to make nature more beautiful than before his building was built.

Hels said...

Erika

My dad did first year Architecture at uni just before WW2 started, so he understood that he would be more essential if he completed an engineering degree instead. You are blessed with your father.

Although both Manchester New Hampshire houses by Wright were built in the 1950s, much later than Fallingwater, it was clear that Wright’s domestic architecture had already reshaped American home design. So I agree that you must see Zimmerman House (1951) and Kalil House (1955). The tours will explain the architectural designs, choice of materials, gardens and even the furniture.

diane b said...

It is a beautiful house and Wright was way ahead of his time. So glad that it was kept for future generations.

Fun60 said...

Having just returned from Chicago, Frank Lloyd Wright is very much on my mind. I visited his home and studio and am now a huge fan. He was way ahead of his time. Someone mentioned Falling Water and I was going to look it up when I got home but your timely post has saved me the trouble.

Hels said...

diane

modernism in architecture, after the chaos of WW1, galloped ahead in leaps and bounds. So Frank Lloyd Wright, Ludwig Mies van der Rohe, Le Corbusier, Walter Gropius, Konstantin Melnikov, Erich Mendelsohn, Gerrit Rietveld, Arne Jacobsen, Oscar Niemeyer and Alvar Aalto were all notable architects who greatly influenced the development of modernist design. But they were in different countries, different decades and had different views of modernism.

Thus I too am delighted that later architects didn't destroy F.L Wright's work, thinking it had had its day.

Hels said...

Fun60

Wright wasn't born in Chicago, but by the time he arrived in the late 1880s, Chicago was hopping and jumping. Note in particular the 1893 World’s Columbian Exposition which showed Chicagoans the "transformative power of the built environment".

Wright was deeply influenced by Louis Sullivan's concept of a uniquely American architecture; it suited a modern American way of life while still reflecting the Midwestern landscape. So Chicago certainly was the dream site for Wright’s early Prairie style. You did well visiting Chicago in detail :)

Hilary Melton-Butcher said...

Hi Hels - I've seen a film on Wright and his work ... which certainly brought his architecture and work to my attention. I'd love to visit and learn more - cheers Hilary

Hels said...

Hilary

what was the name of the film and could you recommend it for art history undergrad students?

mem said...

Definitely on my Bucket list . Hopefully over the next few years . I have a SIL who lives in New York at the moment . I have a great yearning to see all the museums and "Wank Lloyd Frights"efforts. !!!
Falling Water is a sublime building and isn't it uplifting seeing him feat ageism and go onto to do some of his best work?

Hels said...

mem

you are a wise woman! ALWAYS have a close relative in each major city you will want to visit - to avoid all hotel costs and to have a knowledgeable city-guide. When Joe and I first started travelling around the world, we had an uncle/aunt/cousin in London, Manchester, Tel Aviv, Jerusalem, Vancouver, New York, Winnipeg, Perth and Sydney, but our relatives in Odessa and Vienna were too old by then.

Re an architectural movement being criticised after it moves on from previous movements is no surprise at all. The establishment architects feel their values are being ignored or rejected, and potential patrons may be frightened by the new aesthetics. So you must examine the houses FLWright's designed and decide for yourself.