19 May 2020

Prince Philip - homelessness and loss of family (until 1947).

Philip was born (1921) on Corfu, son of Prince Andrew of Greece & Denmark, and Princess Alice of Battenberg after 4 daugh­t­ers: Margarita (b1905), Theodora (b1906), Cecilie (b1911) and Soph­ie (b1914). Thus Philip was himself the Prince of Greece and Denmark.

Note that Philip’s maternal grandfather Prince Louis of Battenberg was a naturalised British citizen who took the surname Mountbatten in WWI.

I am following Tom Garner's journal paper, except where I think he was incorrect. Andrew was absent at Philip’s birth, away fighting in the Greco-Turkish War (1919-22). Andrew was a General comm­anding the Greek Second Army Corps, but refused to obey the or­ders of his superior officer in 1921. The Prince was arrested in the Sept 1922 Revol­ution, a revolt of the Greek armed forces again­st the government who they held responsible for the Turkish vict­ory. It led to King Cons­tantine’s abdication and to Andrew’s death sentence for treason.

Prince Philip, Princess Alice and Prince Andrew in the centre.
L->R Philip’s sisters, Margarita, Theodora, Sophie and Cecilie.
One of the last times they were altogether. Oct 1928.

Princess Alice turned to her British relatives to save her husband. King George V, haunted by not allowing cousin Tsar Nich­olas II of Russia and his family to seek asylum in Britain in WWI, urged a British evacuation. A Greek court banished Andrew from Greece for life and he left in Dec 1922. He was lucky: other senior government members were tried and executed. Soon afterwards a Royal Navy gunboat evacuated the family from Corfu. So from Dec 1922 until his marriage in 1948, young Philip had no permanent residence. 

The family tried to settle in Saint-Cloud near Paris where Andrew and Alice borrowed a house, living off family money. Until 1928 when Philip was sent to Britain to Cheam School where he appeared to have been an unsettled child who needed discip­line.

Deaf from childhood, Alice had been facing a nervous breakdown; this had been attributed to: 1. exile from Greece, 2. separ­at­ions from the child­ren, 3. traumatic menopause, 4. manic depress­ion, 5. religious cris­is or 6. my choice, a cruel husband. In any case, Philip’s mot­h­er was placed in a Swiss sanatorium in 1931. Meanwhile Phil­ip’s sisters married between 1930-31 and moved to settle in Germany. Andrew, who had spent more time with a mistress, finally left alt­og­ether and mo­v­ed to South France.

Philip was only 10, yet received no word from his parents bet­ween 1932-7. How can parents do that??? So the British part of Phil­ip’s family took the respons­ibility for his care. His maternal grandmother, Princess Victoria, sent him to live with Uncle George, Marquis of Milford, surrogate fat­her for 7 years. Philip became close fr­iends with the Marquis’ son David, who also attended Cheam School and gave Philip a sense of stability.

In 1933 Philip’s sister Theodora reappeared and introduced him to a major mentor: Kurt Hahn. Hahn had been the German chancellor’s per­s­onal secretary and had earlier founded a school at Schloss Salem in Baden-Württemberg. Theodora sent Philip there in 1933, just as Hitler came to power.

By 1934 Philip was sent back to Britain, to a new Scottish school established by the now-exiled Hahn: Gordonstoun, with its rad­ical teaching methods. Gordonstoun pupils were taught to counter the declines of initiative and self-discipline etc; they rose at 7am each day in shorts and ran barefoot to the cold water showers all year! Philip was sporty and competitive, and flourished.

In the five years that he attended Gordonstoun, neither George Mil­ford nor Philip’s other British guardian Lord Louis Mountbatten visited. Then in Nov 1937 Philip's pregnant sister Cec­il­ie was killed in plane crash in Belg­ium, along with her husband and children. The lonely teenager travelled alone to attend the funerals in Germany.

At the funerals in Darmstadt, Philip was photographed as part of a procession packed with uniformed Nazis, including Herman Goer­ing. But Philip was never a Nazi sympathiser.

Then Philip went home but sadly his uncle/guardian, Marq­uess of Milford Haven, died of cancer at 46. Under the ad­vice of Lord Mountbatten, Philip enrolled at the Britannia Royal Naval Col­l­­ege, Dartmouth in 1938. In July 1939, Philip had to conduct young Princesses Elizabeth and Margaret when they vis­it­ed the Navy Col­l­ege. They’d already met at George VI’s coronation two years earlier, but in 1939 Elizab­eth really fell for Philip.

Philip and Elizabeth on their honeymoon, 1947
Broadlands House

Britain did not want the Greek prince to be killed in an active warzone on a Royal Navy ship, so Philip’s war began when he was posted to distant Ceylon (Jan 1940). However this changed when It­aly invaded Greece and Philip became a midshipman on HMS Valiant, at a battle off the Greek coast in March 1941. It was Italy’s worst naval defeat and Philip was awarded the Greek Cross of Valour.

At 21, Philip was promoted to First Naval Lieutenant and in July 1943 he was again in action, aboard HMS Wallace invad­ing Sicily. Philip ended his war aboard a ship that took part in the formal surrender of Japanese forces in Sept 1945.

Post-war he expected to remain in his naval car­eer. But he’d kept in touch with Elizabeth and in 1946 he propos­ed marr­iage. In the wake of the 1936 Abdication Cris­is, Elizabeth’s father King George VI objected to the match - Philip was neith­er Brit­ish nor Church of Engl­and. So George asked Philip to postpone an official engage­ment until Elizabeth turned 21 in 1947. When the couple’s engage­ment was ann­oun­ced, Philip quickly became a British subject: he renoun­ced all foreign titles, convert­ed to Anglic­anism and took the name Mountbatten.

Prince Andrew, who had not seen his son for years as Monaco was under occupation, died penniless in 1944. And Princess Alice had been work­ing for the Red Cross in occupied Ath­ens. Mean­while his surviving sisters were all in Germany and they were prev­ented from attending his wedding, because of their Nazi husbands. Only Alice participated.

In Nov 1947 Philip married Eliz­a­beth in Westminster Abbey. Prince Philip now had a role, permanent home and love, saying he’d triumphed over his early traumas. And he’s rep­res­ented the British monarchy for 60+ years, the longest-serving consort of a reigning British monarch. But no one survives a miserable youth unscarred. 







16 comments:

Anonymous said...

Rather a sad early life seemingly without any roots and strong attachments. However, didn't he ever make good.

Sue Bursztynski said...

A sad story indeed, though he has done all right since then. I believe his mother saved some Jews from the Nazis during the war.

mem said...

An amazing life . what a bit more TLC would have done fro his parenting skills with Charles is an interesting thing to contemplate . His mother was a really remarkable brave woman who I think has left her genetic mark on Charles who is also a brave person who has been able to think outside the square and achieve some real change with regards to environmental issues. I always think that the the Queens side of the story is one of conventional wisdom and Phillips one one of the less conventional . What is lovely and I am sure of great importance to Phillip , is that he was bale to develop a loving relationship with hiss mum in the last years of her life which she spent in Buckingham Palace .

Hels said...

Andrew

I realise many children lost their parents to mining accidents, alcoholism, the poor house, war wounds, Spanish Flu etc in the past, but Philip's father was royal and had every privilege.

Thankfully Prince Philip fell on his feet, as you note.

Hels said...

Sue

Princess Alice seemed to be a moral woman, once her husband died and she was allowed out of the asylum he locked her up in. I felt a lot of revenge on Alice's behalf when I wrote up her sad story in https://melbourneblogger.blogspot.com/2016/11/queen-elizabeth-iis-tragic-mother-in.html. She worked for the church, saved Greek Jews and founded a nursing order of Greek Orthodox nuns.

Hels said...

mem

thank goodness for Lord Louis Mountbatten whose mother was a granddaughter of Queen Victoria. He provided some care and mentoring for Philip when he was young, and then provided love and attention to Prince Charles later on.

And thank goodness that Princess Alice had loving relationship with her only son in the last 2 years of her life which she spent in Buckingham Palace. What a shame that they were separated during the most important years of Philip's life.

Joseph said...

Philip loved Gordonstoun but Charles hated every moment he was forced to be there by his dad.

Hels said...

Joseph

Charles was not a tough young lad and even when he was bed-ridden at school with flu, his parents didn’t visit him. And they were again on tour when he was hospitalised the next time. This shy young man loathed rough men's sports and he even disliked horse riding. So what was Prince Philip doing, insisting on his son being sent to arguably the toughest school in the UK?

The Queen Mother tried to protect her first grandson, but Prince Philip overrode any opposition to Gordonstoun. Bullying terrified the prince from the very first day :(

Parnassus said...

Hello Hels, It sounds like Philip was the classic poor little rich kid in the early part of his life, but luckily he was able to turn himself around. I was going to criticize Gordonstoun (still in existence, but presumably toned down a bit) for being a Hitler-Youth type school in Britain, but I then read about Hahn--he was Jewish, and was forced to leave Germany for publicly criticizing Hitler. However, Hahn also founded Outward Bound, a program I dislike. Apparently you can take the educator out of Germany, but you cant take the German martinet attitude out of the teacher.
--Jim

Hilary Melton-Butcher said...

Hi Hels - I wrote a long post about him on his 95th birthday in 2016 ... with a lot of detail though not as much as your background to the family history in Greece in the early 1920s. The only thing I'd mention ... is that once married there wasn't a role for him - that took time to work through - eventually he's become a brilliant consort and very good for the country - he's innovative and technologically interested. There's still challenges - but wouldn't we all in his circumstances. Thanks for this - a great read.

Hels said...

Parnassus

The values of Gordonstoun (and Outward Bound) clearly appealed to many lads, and helped them rise above their difficult childhoods. After all, Prince Philip said, for the right kind of pupil the school offered everything a growing boy could require, physically, intellectually and regarding self reliance.

But after Philip's own horrible youth, he MUST have been perceptive enough to see the school was not remotely suitable for more sensitive types. Apparently not. Gordonstoun prepared Philip for a wonderful career in the British Navy, and he assumed it would be great for his three sons as well.

Hels said...

Hilary

thanks for the link to your blog page:
https://positiveletters.blogspot.com/2016/06/abcs-of-prince-philip-duke-of-edinburgh.html
I found some more points that I hadn't realised before eg that Philip was an exceptional student at the Royal Naval College and well into his Naval career.

Hilary Melton-Butcher said...

Hi Hels - glad you found it informative ... I just wanted to get it written before I forgot it all ... or later on (i.e. now) when he's that much older - but thanks for taking a look and commenting. All the best - Hilary

Hels said...

Hilary

if you are proud of your own research, always create a link with other blogs that cover the same topic. Giving your post's URL in detail helps by a] establishing credit for your own work and b] giving the other bloggers good material to analyse.

Some topics are very easy for me to research. But some topics (like royal histories) seem to be well hidden.

bazza said...

Philip gets a hard ride in the UK press and is often the butt of unfair humour. He has had a habit of committing the odd social faux pas, so is sometimes thought of as a blunt undiplomatic speaker. Perhaps unfairly but your article has nicely adjusted the balance!
CLICK HERE for Bazza’s abnormally antic Blog ‘To Discover Ice’

Hels said...

bazza

All royal consorts were put into an invidious position, but perhaps Prince Philip was angrier than others. Prince Albert was the wisest - he stayed very busy supporting important projects that were well outside the royal family.