09 August 2025

D.Trumbo: great screenwright blacklisted

Dalton Trumbo (1905-76) was born in Montrose CO, son of shoeshop worker Orus and his wife. When Trumbo was 3, his fam­ily moved to nearby Grand Junction, and meanwhile he wrote as a cub reporter for a local paper. Trumbo continued journalism at the Uni of Colorado, and in 1925 had moved to Los Angeles. When dad died, Trumbo worked in a bakery for 10 years to help sup­port his mother and siblings. Meanwhile he wrote heaps of short stories.

Trumbo began writing profession­ally in the 1930s, publishing articles in Saturday Evening Post, Vanity Fair and Hollywood Sp­ec­t­ator. He became The Spectat­or’s managing editor in 1934, pub­lished his first novel Eclipse, and worked as a script reader for Warn­er Bros.

In 1936, Trumbo received his first screenwriting credit for the crime drama Road Gang, and over the next decade became a suc­cessful and resp­ected writer in Holly­wood. A 2nd highspot was A Man to Remember (1938). In  the meantime, he married Cleo Fincher in 1939 and had 3 child­ren: Nikola, Chris­t­opher and Mitzi.

 Hollywood 10 charged with contempt in Nov 1947

He also succeeded with the anti-war novel Johnny Got His Gun (1939). The novel won a National Book Award and has been adapted many times for radio, stage and screen. Although Johnny’s success earn­ed Trumbo fame, the work eventually gathered him unwanted attention as well. He receiv­ed fan let­ters from Nazi sympath­isers believed the writer was also pro-Nazi. So Trumbo reported the Nazis to the FBI but rather than pursue the Nazis, the Bureau investig­ated Trumbo!

The House Committee on Un-American Ac­tivities/HUAC was created in 1938 to investigate alleged disloyal activities by public employees and org­anisations suspected of having Communist ties. More about this later.

The 1940 romantic drama Kitty Foyle, starring Ginger Rogers, earned Trumbo his first Academy Award nomination for best adapted screenplay. Another much praised WW2 drama was Thirty Seconds Over Tokyo (1944), starring Spencer Tracy and Robert Mitchum.

Like many intellectuals, Trumbo had joined the Comm­unist Party in 1943 for a few years, and during his career, had frequ­en­t­ly proposed leftish political positions. From 1946 on, the number of FBI ag­ents doubled, as part of President Truman’s loyalty-security programme, identifying gov­ernment employees with communist sympathies.

In Oct 1947, as postwar paranoia about Comm­un­ism was surging in USA. Trumbo was among 10 Hollywood directors and writers, The Holly­wood Ten, called to testify before the HUAC. The Committee had to investigate whether Communist sympathisers had pro­p­ag­and­ised audiences. The HUAC began to sub­poena screen writers and directors to test­ify about alleged communist links.

Dalton Trumbo might have been Hollywood's most famous screenwriter of his generat­ion, yet he too had to testify before the HUAC. They all refused to give up the names of colleagues with ?comm­unist sym­p­athies; Trumbo was imprisoned for 11 months, guil­ty of Contempt of Con­gr­ess. After re­lease, he was Black­listed by the major studio heads and could not work in his own name.

Dalton Trumbo grilled by the House Un-American Activities Committee
28th Oct 1947. NBC News

Other witnesses called in front of the committee, including Elia Kazan, director of On The Waterfront, named names and could continue working. The playwright Arthur Miller, who had been life­long friends with Kazan, never spoke to him again. But Trumbo couldn’t find work in California so the family moved to Mexico City. There he continued to write screen­plays, which he could sell using pseudonyms. 

Dalton Trumbo (glasses) prepared to fly to Wash DC to begin gaol
with family and protesters Los Angeles Airport, 1950.
SFGATE

Sen Joe McCarthy launched his most brutal campaign in 1950, when he accused 200+ state department staff of being communists. In Mexico City, Trumbo continued to write screen­plays which he was able to sell by getting other writers to front for his work. Dur­ing this time, Trum­bo wrote 10+ screenplays that were made into films, including the clas­s­ic Oscar-winning Roman Holiday (1953), starring Gre­g­­ory Peck and Audrey Hepburn.

After years of working in exile, Trumbo at last returned to Hollywood, when his screenplay for The Brave One (1956), under the nick Robert Rich, received an Ac­ad­emy Aw­ard. But his earnings dwindled: over a two year period, Trumbo wrote 18 screenplays cheaply.

Trumbo was known for writing in his bathtub.
X.com

When McCarthy died in 1957, there was a sense of joy because the senat­or had managed the whole disaster. By 1959, HUAC was denounced even by for­m­er Pres Truman as “a most un-American thing”.

Trumbo was chosen by Kirk Douglas to write the screenplay for Spar­t­acus, which went on to win four Academy Awards!! Trumbo was also hired to write the adap­t­ation for the best-selling novel about the State of Is­rael, Exodus, directed by Otto Prem­in­g­er. The Blacklist had lost all credibility!

Throughout the rest of his life, Trumbo continued his successful output and was re­in­st­at­ed in the Writers Guild of America. Of the many screen­plays that he wrote in this post-Blacklist era, some high­lights were the Dou­glas west­ern Lonely Are the Brave (1962), Golden Globe–nominated crime drama The Fixer (1968), and a prison clas­sic Pap­illon (1973) with Steve McQueen & Dustin Hoffman. Revisiting his old, once troubled works, Trumbo wrote and directed a 1971 film adaption of Johnny Got His Gun, and received two awards at the Cannes Film Fes­tival. And in 1975, he finally received his Oscar for The Brave One.

A heavy smoker Trumbo was diagnosed with lung cancer in 1973. He died in care in Sept 1976 in Los Angeles.

In 1993, 40 years after the film’s release, Trumbo was posthumously awarded an Oscar for his Roman Holiday screenplay. Since his death, Trumbo has been the hero of other peoples’ works, incl­uding a 2003 Broadway play: Trumbo: Red, White and Black­listed. In Sept 2015, a new bio­graphical drama cal­l­ed Trumbo premiered at the Toronto Intern­ational Film Festival. The ex­traordinary story of his defiance in the face of political oppression was key.

You might like to see the 2015 film, Trumbo, based on the 1977 biography by Bruce Alexander Cook





16 comments:

roentare said...

Dalton Trumbo’s life reads like a screenplay itself—brilliant success, political persecution, defiant resilience, and ultimate redemption

Deb said...

Remember Roman Holiday? I loved it but would never have known who the screenwriter was.

Margaret D said...

I recall some of his films. Amazing writer.

Hollywood Actors Who Were Blacklisted During the Red Scare said...

The Hollywood Ten were not the only Hollywood stars who suffered.
Chaplin Chaplin was blacklisted for refusing to co-operate when called before the House Un-American Activities Committee
Orson Welles was sidelined but not gaoled for his actions re the infamous War of the Worlds broadcast.
Pete Seeger was a member of the Communist Party, but refused to name anyone before HUAC in 1955. He was convicted of contempt of Congress and was sentenced to 10 years but released earlier.
Lena Horne was a singer and dancer labelled as a Communist sympathizer because of her civil rights activism etc etc

Andrew said...

I used to think nothing like the HUAC could ever happen in the US again. However, now I am not so confident. Kazan should have been the one to never work again. We don't like people who 'dob'.

Hels said...

Andrew
I could not believe that the The House Committee on Un-American Ac­tivities was created in _1938 _ to investigate disloyal activities by public employees and org­anisations. They blacklisted and gaoled the very people who the US needed most - its cleverest academics, authors, public employees, trade unionists, Hollywood stars etc etc.

So it is certainly happening again, although perhaps not via the old HUAC structure. Now he does it by sacking the court judges who protected citizens' rights or replacing Departmental Secretaries with new people who would cancel long standing funding and cause mass unemployment.

jabblog said...

Writers, musicians and actors were badly treated by the HUAC. Any attempt to curb freedom of speech is doomed to failure and condemns a country to a lack, or at least a slowdown, of social development.

Hels said...

Margaret
I wouldn't have known any films written and produced before WW2, but I certainly knew: Roman Holiday (1953); Spartacus (1960); Papillon (1973); The Brave One (1956); Exodus (1960) and perhaps one or two other great films. Not bad from one man!

Hels said...

roentare
I think if Trumbo's works had not been so successful and colourful, he might have been blacklisted quietly and the public might never have heard of him again. Even though he was only in hiding in Mexico for a few years, we know of almost none of the work he created during that hiding time.
His ultimate redemption was very fortunate, for him of course, but for us as well.

Hels said...

Deb
I didn't know either... I knew about Academy Awards for best: films, actor and actress, costumes, even set design. But producers and screenwriters were hidden.

Hels said...

Inside Hook
Many thanks. I can see you said that Hollywood's blacklist policy banned the work of 325 screenwriters, directors and actors who the committee had not yet cleared. Some people _were_ able to restart working, through eg pseudonyms, but others disappeared into the general community :(

Hels said...

jabblog
I agree with you. Any attempt to curb freedom of speech will slow down that nation's intellectual and social development, lead to trials and gaol sentences, growth of emigration and psychiatric disturbance.

But curbing free speech was only part of the crisis. The HUAC tracked social contacts, political activities and work commitments. Any of Lena Horne's connections to Paul Robeson were carefully monitored and recorded.

Luiz Gomes said...

Boa noite e bom final de semana. Uma excelente noite de sábado, com muita paz e saúde. Liberdade com restrições não é liberdade. Obrigado pela visita e comentário. Parabéns pela excelente matéria.

My name is Erika. said...

Wow, what a life. McCarthy's death really set a lot of talented people free, but he also did so much harm too. Kind of like some people in our US politics now. But I won't go on about that. Hope you are having a wonderful August.

Hels said...

Luiz
Freedom with restrictions is certainly not freedom, and democracy where leftists cannot work in their chosen professions is nothing like a democracy. When Dalton Trumbo wouldn't answer questions about other people hauled up before the HUAC, he knew his freedom was over :(

Hels said...

Erika
Because the Senator died in 1957, had he been the main force behind the HUAC, we might have expected the oppression to stop. But no! There were other like minded politicians who continued McCarthy's mission, although perhaps with less shame than McCarthy. In any case, the HUAC went on, was renamed the House Committee on Internal Security in 1969 and was only abolished in 1975.