01 March 2025

UK's National Health Service, slow & vital development

Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, originally built in 1933
and replaced by the new hospital in 2010.
It is one of the largest single-site hospitals in the UK

After the Boer War, a Committee on Phys­ic­al Deterioration (1903) was created to study Br­itain’s health, to determine why so many army men were ill. This Committee promoted the 1906 Lib­erals’ re­forms in public health, including the first Nat­ional Health Insurance scheme (1911). Not universal in cover­age to be sure, but a modest start.

Then examine the Minority Report of the Royal Commission on the Poor Law in 1909. Headed by socialist economist Baroness Beatrice Webb, the report urged a new sys­tem to replace the Poor Laws that had existed since the Vic­t­or­ian workhouse era. Vic­torian politicians had upheld a narrow-minded app­roach, exp­ecting the impoverished to be totally accountable for th­em­selves. So the Report was unsucc­essful; its ideas were disreg­ar­d­ed by the new government.

4 years of WW1 ravaged British society, greatly increasing morbidity and mortality rates. So the Interwar Period pushed the gov­ernment into reorganising public healthcare. The Min­ist­ry of Health Act was passed in 1919, giving Britain its first-ever Health Minister! In the int­er­war era, spec­ialist clinics were established to treat dis­ease and to advise on nutrition and fit­ness. And breakthroughs were made in treating pneum­onia. Britain recog­­nis­ed the need for greater government involvement, to improve social sec­ur­ity and public health.

The 1929 Local Government Act dissolved Poor Law Unions, estab­l­ish­ing Public Assistance Committees in the County Councils instead. By integrating medical serv­ices, the LGA allowed for many old infirm­ar­ies to be developed into gen­er­al hospitals with acute care. And in 1930 London County Council took over re­s­ponsibility for 140 hospitals & medical schools, after the Metropolitan Asylums Board ended.

The Emergency Health Service/EHS was created in 1938. Pre-WW2, the EHS was tasked with planning for possible mass bombing of cit­ies. It rev­ol­utionised healthcare in Britain, mainly by re­quiring all hospitals and clinics to coordinate for the first time eg sharing sup­p­l­ies. Thus the British government was learning from evolving wartime heal­th­care prac­tices.

The book Fighting Fit charted the develop­ment of Britain’s pub­lic health measures in WW2. It began in 1939 with the threat to Atlantic convoys, dealing with rat­ion­ing and ended in 1947 when Reg­ul­ation 33B (re control of venereal disease) was rep­ealed before the Nat­­ional Health Service Act started. To keep Brit­ain war fit, the gov­ern­ment mobilised adults in its services eg to supply blood transfus­ion service.

Church­ill’s stir­ring speeches ran th­roughout Fight­ing Fit as the P.M (1940-5) saw the strategic impor­tance of im­p­r­oving Britain’s health. It was not surprising that the NHS inh­erited im­portant el­em­ents of wartime projects: co-ordinated hos­pitals, nat­ional pathol­ogy, integrated blood-banks.

Sir William Beveridge was asked to investigate British soc­ial security and in Dec 1942, the Committee’s Report on Social Insurance and Allied Services identified 5 major issues in British soc­iety: want, squalour, ignorance, idleness and especially disease. Each is­sue played a major part in estab­l­ishing the Welfare State post-war & in the creation of the NHS. There was a growing consensus that the exist­ing heal­th insur­ance system should be extended to include dep­end­ents of wage-earners and that private hospitals should be integ­rated. The Bev­er­idge Report finally made its final recommendations, supported in Parliament by all parties.

Eventually the Cabinet endorsed the White Paper proposed by Minister of Health Henry Willink in 1944, setting out NHS guidelines eg how it would be funded from general tax­ation and not national insurance. Ev­ery­one was entitled to treatment and it would be prov­ided free at point of delivery.

Alas some of the key lessons of WW2 were soon forgotten, espec­ial­ly that to be effective, public health had to consider community, diet, social class, mental health, preventative medicine and work­place health. Presumably this was due to the growing post-war belief that most problems could be solved by modern technology. Plus how many doctors resisted the intrusion of government into medicine?

 Aneurin Bevan, Health Minister

A guide to the National Health Service Act, 1946
Published by The Labour Party.
Pinterest

Finally Labour's Clement Attlee became Prime Minister in 1945 and Aneurin Bevan became Health Minister. It was Bevan who campaigned to bring about the NHS in modern form, based on 3 essent­ial values ideas which Bevan expressed in the launch July 1948: 1] that the services helped all citizens; 2] health­care was free and 3] that care would be provided based on need rather than ability to pay.

The Birth of the NHS by Jessica Brain was a great book. The launch of the NHS in July 1948 came from decades of work from those who felt the current healthcare system needed to be revolutionised. It was launched at the Park Hospital Man­ch­ester, providing free health­care and med­ical services for ordinary families. The NHS’ work­ers, main­ly G.Ps, were paid large­ly through taxation. But as equipment and tech­nology advanced, fin­an­cially stability became harder.

All 4 U.K countries provided the following services: hosp­it­als and specialists, local health authorities, GPs and dentists. Since then the NHS has gone through many changes, dev­eloping and expan­d­ing. In the early years of the NHS, expend­iture was already exceeding exp­ectations and prescriptions ch­ar­ges were con­sid­er­ed to meet the rising costs. By the 1960s these ear­ly adjustments were altered and it was considered to be a strong era of growth for the NHS, especially in drug devel­op­ments. And new re­or­g­anisations occ­urred in 1974 as the econom­ic op­tim­ism of the earlier decade waned. By the 1980s and Margaret Thatcher’s gover­n­ment (1979-90), modern manage­ment methods were int­r­o­duced. But ev­en Thatcher saw the necessity for the NHS to remain a core of British life.

Conclusion
WW2 had a major impact on the development of pub­lic health. But not just the war. The NHS created in 1948 marked the most import­ant moment in British social and medical hist­ory, with new ideas about health, servic­es, med­ical ethics and soc­iety. Yes it faced crises and economic changes in its 70 years of op­er­at­ion, but the questions of funding and demand still continue.

The History of the NHS by by Geoffrey Rivett



25 February 2025

You'll Never Walk Alone Liverpool Ftball Cl

The world of musical theatre seemed a very long way from Anfield Football Stadium in Liverpool. So how did a big, wonderful song from Rodgers and Hammerstein’s show Carousel (1945) end up as a football anthem? You’ll Never Walk Alone began life on Broadway, used in Carousel to comfort and encourage a suffering character. 

First released in 1945, Gerry and the Pacemakers adapted YNWA in 1963 to a song of their own, which has since taken on a life much bigger than the band could have ever imagined. Today it is the most special supporters’ anthem in the game. It is belted out at the home ground by c40,000 fans before every home game in a powerful spectacle. 

Crowds waving their scarves and singing
Youtube

The song was an instant hit; its message of triumph in hard times spoke to the wartime crowds of Ap 1945, just before WW2 ended. It remained popular throughout the ’50s and then in 1963, a version of the song was performed by Liverpool’s musician Gerry Marsden, lead singer of Gerry and the Pacemakers. The recording by this Merseybeat band brought the song to Liverpool FC! Thus the thrilling song has been sung at the games at Anfield since 1963. Apart from Marsden being a huge Liverpool fan himself, there are some other reasons why the song appealed.

Jerry and the Pacemakers turned the song into a single that entered the charts across the UK in Oct 1963. It stayed there for some months, topping the charts for 4 weeks and was a huge hit with Liverpool fans. 

Marsden gave famous Liverpool manager Bill Shankly a copy of the song during Liverpool’s tour of the U.S in 1964. After the band and Liverpool FC all appeared on the Ed Sullivan show to sing You Never Walk Alone, Shankly was excited by the song’s power. He decided to make it Liverpool’s formal club anthem. Given it so suited the spirit of Liverpool FC and its fans, it became much more than a song! 

Liverpool’s Anfield Stadium was one of the first footy grounds to have a PA system and a DJ in the grounds. In Liverpool’s musical prime, the DJ played the Top 10 UK hits over the sound system. This was when Liverpool bands like The Beatles and The Merseybeats dominated the charts, so the fans re-heard their beloved groups. You’ll Never Walk Alone/YNWA stayed at #1 in the charts for 4 weeks in 1963, by which time it became Liverpool FC’s signature tune.

With music being such a pivotal part of Liverpool’s culture, the music was played over the public address system at Anfield with the Kop/fans’ grandstand singing along. In the weeks that their anthem was at #1, the Kop wanted it played as the players ran out. Fittingly Liverpool won the League’s 1963-64 season and their song was carved into football history forever.

Players, staff and fans of Liverpool were suffering through very tough times, on and off the field! Clearly the motivating effect of all those fans singing YNWA together gave the players hope in grim times. This small act of defiance in front of adversity galvanised the Liverpool team, and they managed to win unexpected matches. When asked which club had the most avid fans, even foreigners said Liverpool fans. When they sing a song they come together in unity

The song absorbed a much more tragic meaning after the Hillsborough Disaster 1989, when a human crush at the stadium in Sheffield left 96 fans dead and hundreds more were injured. After the Hillsborough tragedy, 13,000 people assembled at Liverpool’s Roman Catholic Cathedral, in the church and outside. You’ll Never Walk Alone was sung by a lone choir boy, offering comfort to the city in mourning. 

Following the Hillsborough disaster, Liverpool’s club anthem took on a whole new significance. It has become the soundtrack of hope for the club, its fans and for Liverpool City through extremely tough times. It signified Liverpool’s fight for justice for their fans and it supported the families of those killed at Hillsborough that they’d never be alone. 

The lyrics eventually found a permanent home at Anfield, fixed in wrought iron above the gates of the Anfield Stadium - a permanent reminder to fans that football was not just sport; it was family. 

Shankly Gate, Anfield Stadium
lfcHistory

Alongside Liverpool, Celtic and Borussia Dortmund are the two clubs famous for using YNWA as the club anthem. It was after Liverpool’s clash against Celtic in the 1966 European Cup Winners’ Cup semi-finals that led to the Scottish side adopting it as their own amazing song. For Borussia Dortmund, the use of YNWA pre match originates from the band Pur Harmony, who did a cover version of Gerry and the Pacemakers. Much later YNWA was heard in Liverpool when they hosted Borussia Dortmund at Anfield in the Europa League. Fans all raised their scarves in the air, with the Anfield crowd then taking over the song as the music was cut from the speakers, leaving just the two sets of voices. 

Although undoubtedly not the reason for YNWA’s initial popularity across football grounds, it is fitting for a club like Liverpool, with the city’s resilience after the tragic Hillsborough disaster, that the song’s message was one of unity and determination. So I think this anthem will always truly belong to Liverpool Football Club. I remember every word, even today. 

Thank you to Ben Marsden in FourFourTwo and Joe Prince-Wright in nbcsports. And to Youtube for the music.

Liverpool FC Quarter-Final First Leg - UEFA Europa League
Getty

When you walk through a storm, hold your head up high

And don’t be afraid of the dark

At the end of the storm, there’s a golden sky 

And the sweet, silver song of a lark 

Walk on through the wind 

Walk on through the rain 

Alhough your dreams be tossed and blown

Walk on, walk on 

With hope in your heart 

And you’ll never walk alone 

You’ll never walk alone






22 February 2025

Archduke Franz Ferdinand, assassination ->

Danubia: A Personal History of Habsburg Europe was a big book. Happily once we get to 1848, the year of revolutions across Europe, the book became much more balanced and more interest­ing. The 53 million people under Habsburg rule spoke German, Hung­arian, Moravian, Polish, Yidd­ish, Czech, Croatian, Slovakian, Bulgarian, Romanian, Serbian, Ukrain­ian and even Italian. Perhaps this was a recipe for disaster.

Archduke Franz Ferdinand (1863-1914) was born in Graz Austria, oldest son of Archduke Karl Ludwig and Princess Maria of Bourbon-Two Siciliesand nephew of Austro-Hungarian Emperor Franz Joseph (1867–1916).  These Hapsburg men were rulers of three empires: Holy Roman, Austro-Hun­gar­ian and Spanish

Habsburg Archduke Franz Ferdinand
1914, Wiki

Franz Ferdinand was educated by private tutors throughout his youth; he began his military career at age 12 and quickly advanced up the ranks becoming a major general at 31. After the emperor's son Crown Prince Rudolf’s suicide in 1889, Franz Fer­dinand's father­ Karl Ludwig became heir to the throne. At Karl Lud­wig's death from typhoid fever in 1896, Franz Ferdinand was suddenly the heir to the throne.

The young man had served in Hungary. So later, as heir to the throne, he was appointed as the In­sp­ector General of the Austro-Hungarian army. [Remember this below, re 1914].

In 1894 Ferdinand first met Countess Sophie Maria Chotek, daughter of a Boh­em­ian aristocrat, and they fell in love. However marr­iage to a Hapsburg required that he/she be a member of a reigning (or ex-) dyn­asty of Europe, and the Choteks weren’t. But the loved-up Franz Fer­dinand re­fused to marry anyone else, and it took a few years and the intervention of other heads of state, including Pope Leo XIII, before the Emperor agreed to the unacceptable marriage.

But Franz Joseph only agreed with rigorous conditions. This morgan­at­ic marriage demanded Sophie and any future children were not allowed her hus­b­and's throne, titles, priv­il­eg­es or inherited property. The couple married in July 1900. And they had 3 Hohenberg children: Prin­cess Sophie, Duke Maximilian & Prince Ernst. In 1909 Sophie became the Duchess of Hohenberg.

Austria-Hungary was a multi-ethnic, multi-lingual empire of groups antagonistic over religion and politics. The only thing the different ethnic people hated more than each other was the Hapsburg dynasty. Franz Fer­­dinand's public per­s­ona was cold and short-tempered, and ?insane due to in­breeding.

Still, Franz Ferdinand understood that the empire was disintegrating. And he DID propose changing the Austro-Hungarian rule with a triple monarchy of Slavs, Germans and Magyars, each having an equal voice in govern­ment. Naturally this idea was unpopular with the ruling elite.

Royal couple travelling to Sarajevo town hall reception

in their open car, blogpost

The assassination, Traderlife

Franz Ferdinand also consid­er­ed a federal government of 16 states, the United States of Greater Austria. Naturally this idea was in direct conflict with the Serbian nat­ionalists who wanted to break off with Bosnia and Herzegovina to form an independent state. Though he didn’t care much about their nat­ionalist ambitions, Franz Ferdin­and supported greater freedom for self-determination. And he ad­vocated for a careful approach with the Serbs, warning his military leaders that harsh treatment could lead to conflict in the region and with Russia. Correct! Meanwhile he maintained an alliance with Germany.

In 1914, Franz Ferdinand and Sophie accepted an in­vitation by Gen Oskar Potiorek, governor of Bosnia-Herzegovina province. In the capital of Bosnia, Sarajevo, he inspected the imp­er­ial armed forces in Bosnia and Herzeg­ov­ina, annexed by Austria-Hungary (in 1908). The annexation angered Serbian nationalists, who believed the ter­r­it­ories should be part of Serbia. So the Archduke knew all about the ter­­­r­­orism organ­ised by the Serbian nationalist organisation The Black Hand but ignored the warnings. Meanwhile a group of young national­ists plot­ted to kill the Archduke!

When the royal train arrived 28th June 1914, a motorcade drove them to the official townhall reception. The royals were in the sec­ond car with the top rolled back, to give the crowds a good view. A Black Hand terrorist agent, Nedjelko Cabrinovic, threw a grenade. Thank­fully the driver saw an object in the air and sped up, causing the grenade to hit the car behind them, damaging occupants and spect­ators. However their driver made a wrong turn and drove toward a young Black Hand Bosnian Serb nat­ion­alist Gavrilo Prin­cip (1894–1918). As the car backed up, Princip fir­ed and shot the royals in their upper bodies. Both died en route to hospital. Ferdinand was buried alongside his wife in Artstetten Castle in Aust­ria. The car in which they were killed is on display at the Museum of Military History in Vienna, along with his bloodied uniform.

The assassination set off a rapid chain of events, giving the Aus­trian hardliners their chance to move against Serbia, ending their independence movement. Of course the situat­ion es­c­al­at­ed. When Austro-Hungary retaliated against Serbia, Rus­sia supported its ally Ser­bia. So Austria needed Germ­any’s as­s­urance that they would join against Russia and its all­ies, France & soon Britain. In July Austria-Hungary declared war on Serbia, and the fragile peace between Europe’s great powers collap­s­ed. Then an entangled web of alliances was activ­ated as Russia declared war on Austria-Hungary, Germany declared war on Russia, and France and Brit­ain decl­ared war on Germany and Austria-Hungary. By Aug 1914, The War To End All Wars had begun.

Gavrilo Prin­cip arrested at the assassination scene, BBC

When Franz Joseph died in 1916, he was succeeded by his grandnephew Charles I, who reigned until the collapse of the Austrian Empire following its defeat in Nov 1918. The monarchy ended.

Assassin Gavrilo Princip got 20 years in prison because at 19, he was too young for capital punishment in Hap­s­burg law. He was gaoled in Dec 1914, chained to a wall and died of TB in 1918. Of course Princip didn’t know that the Habsburg Empire end­ed in 1918, however others knew. In 1920 Princip and other revolut­ion­ary heroes were exhumed and brought to Sarajevo, then buried in the Holy Archangels Cemetery

The Austrian-Hungarian Empire and today’s national boundaries
Pinterest



18 February 2025

Russian born Yul Brynner's amazing story

Yuliy Borisovich Briner (1920-85) was born in Vladivostok, apparently with mixed ancestry. The mystery began with Brynner's birth, for which he gave dates anytime between 1915-22. He sometimes said that he had been born off the Siberian coast, and that his mother was a Gypsy. But he was born in the Far Eastern Republic, now Russia.

Statue of Brynner in front of his Vladivostok family home
Wiki

Brynner’s father Boris (1891-1942) was a ?Russian engineer and his mother Marousia was ?Mongolian. While still young, Boris ran a key family owned import-export house in Vladivostok. Alas he left the family for a young Russian dancer in 1924 so Yuliy’s name was changed to Yul Brynner.

Marousia had to raise her children alone, so they travelled to Harbin China because Harbin had a large Russian population. Young Brynner loved watching the stagecraft of a noted cross-dressing Chinese opera star.

With tensions rising between Japan and China in the 1930s, Marousia moved the family to Paris in 1934 where Yul studied at Lycée Moncelle. He learned French of course, as well as speaking Russian and Chinese but preferred sports and music to classes. Brynner also began playing the guitar after hearing a touring Russian Gypsy troupe in Paris' Montmartre area. His debut came in 1935, as a guitarist with a Gypsy orchestra. Once Yul was fluent in French, he worked as a Parisien radio announcer.

Yul's sister Vera had married and begun a musical career in the US. In his early 20s, Brynner also travelled to the US where he drifted into acting with a touring company. He wanted to study with Anton Chekhov’s nephew Michael Chekhov, who’d relocated from Moscow Art Theatre director to US, establishing a new workshop in Ridgefield Conn. Brynner made a successful Broadway stage debut in 1941, in Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night. And he was on stage with both The Moon Vine (1943) and Lute Song (1946).

Then he became active as a director during the early days of tv at CBS. At this time he became a US citizen and wanted to enlist in the U.S Army. Rejected because of symptoms of TB, he worked instead as a French-language broadcaster for the Office of War Information.

Yul was also an ardent humanitarian. Brynner visited refugee camps around the world, helping to expose the plight of millions of displaced people to governments and the UN.  He was appointed a special consultant to UNHCR in 1959, which coincided with World Refugee Year. And through film and radio, he helped highlight the plight of refugees to ordinary citizens. Brynner was a noted photographer, and he wrote Bring Forth the Children: A Journey to the Forgotten People of Europe and the Middle East (1960), which included his pictures.

 

Bring Forth the Children by Brynner, 1960
Biblio.com

His most famous play and film, The King and I, were based on Margaret Landon’s Anna and the King of Siam (1944), inspired by the real-life adventures of a British governess who worked for Siamese King Mongkut. The Broadway production of The King and I by Rodgers and Hammerstein was a huge success for Yul between 1951-85. Not surprisingly he won a Tony Award in 1952 as best actor in a musical. Brynner continued to make return appearances in the stage production of The King and I, because because the show paid well and age-related changes in his appearance didn’t affect the role. In 30 years, he gave thousands of performances on stage as King.

The play was adapted for the film The King and I (1956) where Brynner gave his best ever performance as the irritating, yet caring king who shaved his head. He starred with Deborah Kerr, the musical film again scored by Rodgers and Hammerstein. He won an Academy Award for best actor in 1956. Interestingly the Thai government has never officially allowed the film to be shown there because of historical errors about the king.
   
Yul Brynner and Deborah Kerr, in King and I
Pinterest

The 1950s were important. Brynner made his film debut as a drug smuggler in Port of New York (1949), the first of his c45 films. Taking a leading role, he starred opposite Ingrid Bergman in Anastasia (1956), playing a crooked Russian refugee making a living in Paris. He was Dmitri in Brothers Karamazov (1958) playing opposite Claire Bloom, Lee J Cobb and William Shatner. Brynner starred as Solomon in another Old Testament epic, Solomon and Sheba (1959), with Gina Lollabrigida and George Sanders. One of Brynner’s best-known film roles was in The Magnificent Seven (1960), a western based on Akira Kurosawa’s Seven Samurai. Co-stars were Eli Wallach, Steve McQueen, Charles Bronson, Robert Vaughn and James Coburn.

His film career peaked in a great film Ten Commandments (1956), in which he starred as King Rameses with Charlton Heston’s Moses. Morituri (1965) was set in WW2, starring Brynner and Marlon Brando; and Madwoman of Chaillot (1969), a drama starring Katharine Hepburn. Finally he was a killer robot in the sci-fi adventure Westworld (1973).
   
King Rameses, in Ten Commandments
Facebook

In 1960s Brynner returned to Europe, taking Swiss citizenship. He continued to perform on the guitar, sometimes on film, and in 1967 he released an album, The Gypsy and I: Yul Brynner Sings Gypsy Songs.

Brynner smoked packets of cigarettes daily, and in 1983 was diagnosed with lung cancer. His last performance was in 1985 and he died that year.

Thank you to his historian son Rock who wrote a biography of the Brynner family: Yul: The Man Who Would Be King, 1989, with accounts of dad’s personal and professional successes and failures. Yul married actress Virginia Gilmore in 1944 but the marriage ended in 1960, after Rock was born in 1946. His second marriage was to Doris Kleiner and their child Victoria. His third marriage was to Jacqueline de Croisset plus two adopted orphans, which also ended in divorce. His 4th marriage in 1983, to Kathy Lee, lasted until his death. Also note his famous affairs with Judy Garland, Joan Crawford, Ingrid Bergman and others.