Day had yet to break over Vila Cruzeiro but already dozens of corpses were splayed out along the favela/slum’s main drag after more than 130 people were killed during the deadliest police operation in Rio’s history: grotesquely disfigured, blood-smeared bodies that had been dragged out of nearby forests and dumped on blue tarpaulins and black plastic sheets covering the street.
Residents of Vila Cruzeiro gather bodies after they were killed in pre-dawn assault
The Guardian
Erivelton Vidal Correia, head of the local residents’ association, bleary-eyed from a sleepless night spent hauling bullet-riddled local men down from the hills, brought 53 down himself. Correia collapsed as he described his relentless nocturnal hunt for the dead after Rio suffered what was one of the biggest police massacres in modern Brazilian history. I’ve never seen anything like this in my life, not even in the Gaza Strip does this happen … I can’t bear to see any more corpses, he wept, covering his face with the surgical gloves he was using.
Rio officials said on Tuesday that dozens of people, including 4 police officers, had been killed after a force of 2,500 launched a pre-dawn assault on Alemão and Penha, the vast patchwork of favelas of which Vila Cruzeiro is part. By early Wednesday the public prosecutor said the death toll had risen to 132, higher than in São Paulo’s notorious Carandiru prison massacre in 1992, when 111 prisoners lost their lives. Between 4.15-9am, when government body collectors finally arrived, the Guardian witnessed pickup trucks delivering dozens of corpses to a Vila Cruzeiro square named after St Luke the Evangelist.
I’ve never seen anything like this … I still haven’t managed to comprehend what has happened. I feel empty. I have no words, said Raull Santiago, a favela activist, as another cargo of corpses arrived. This sent local women scrambling in search of their missing husbands, brothers or sons.
Many of the dead men, most in their late teens, 20s and 30s, are likely to have been members of the local Red Command drug faction, which Tuesday’s operation was intended to target. Most of the corpses were unclothed but a few wore ghillie suits, camouflage clothing used by snipers, hunters and nature photographers to be conceal in foliage. But there was fury among the scores of people who had flocked to the plaza and who claimed police had summarily executed the young men instead of detaining them. Irrespective of whether these people were involved in the local drug trade or not, we don’t have the death penalty in Brazil. They should have been arrested, he said.
Murderers! Murderers! cried Cida Santana, recalling how her son Fabio had messaged her at 3pm on Tuesday to tell her he had been shot in the foot and was trying to surrender to police. 16 hours later Fabio’s corpse was shrouded under a blood-stained floral rug with what looked like knife wounds to his chest. My God! Work a miracle, God! Santana begged, as she collapsed on to the ground beside her child. But there was to be no resurrection for her son, nor for the dozens of other bodies lined up beside him outside a sushi restaurant with bullet wounds to their limbs, torsos and heads. One had been dec-apitated, the person’s head stashed inside an olive green pouch that was placed on the ground. Several men had badly broken bones or puncture wounds in their flesh.
At times, as pickup trucks continued to deliver the dead, a stunned silence fell over the mob. No one had ever seen bloodshed on this scale, not even veteran crime reporters. Rio’s deadliest police attack had been a 2021 raid on another Red Command centre, Jacarezino when 28 people were killed. It’s surreal, said Antônio Carlos Costa, a church leader-human rights campaigner, calling for the immediate removal of Rio’s governor, Cláudio Castro. He is an ally of Brazil’s former far-right president, Jair Bolsonaro.
Costa called the killings a historic humiliation for Brazil just before next month’s Cop climate summit in the Amazon city of Belém. At other moments, onlookers exploded in rage as they took in the nightmarish scene. Shell-shocked friends and relatives of the deceased ripped off the sheets covering their mangled bodies and demanded journalists film the butchery to show the world.
Police officers escort surviving "criminals" arrested at Vila Cruzeiro favela.
Irish Times
Help us, please, implored Cláudia Silva 53 shaking with rage as she denounced what she and others called a genocide. When they come in here, they kill even the rats, she said of the police. This was a slaughter, not an operation. They came here to kill, said Cida Santana as she sat on a blood-covered bin liner next to her son’s corpse. In 30 years working in the favelas this is the greatest act of savagery, the biggest massacre he’d seen, said lawyer Pinheiro Fróes who’d come to support the families of the dead.
Claudio Castro continued to defend the operation amid a growing chorus of outrage, including from the UN’s human rights office which was horrified by the killings. Rio’s governor celebrated a harsh blow to the heavily-armed drug traffickers who have seized control of many of Rio’s hundreds of favelas over the past 40 years. The only victims yesterday were the police, Castro said of the four officers killed during Tuesday’s intense gun battles with criminals he called narco-terrorists. As the governor spoke, Edmar Augusto 50, a priest with a purple stole draped over his shoulders, sprinkled holy water on the 50+ bodies that had accumulated at the entrance to the favela.
We don’t want war. We want peace, Augusto told the favela’s mourners, his voice breaking with emotion. So many families are crying. And I want to cry with them. Society cannot stay silent, the priest bellowed, staring sky-wards to recite the Lord’s prayer. As he waited for another carload of bodies to arrive, community leader Correia recalled how two decades earlier a group of local evangelical missionaries had warned that the favela would one day suffer a momentous bloodbath. We didn’t believe them. We never believed it would happen. But they prophesised it and it came to pass.
**
Poor, poor Brazil :( I hope my old friends' siblings and colleagues survived.



36 comments:
A very disturbing video is available on youtube
I've spent half a life in Brazil and what just happened was backers of Christian National Socialism trying to favorably impress the current U.S. Government. Yet this is not at all uncommon. Herbert Hoover, Reagan and Bush² wrecked the economy into hyperinflation while invading Panama. Prohibitionist movies like this Youtube trailer became as much of a fad as burning Beatles albums in Alabama: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sAetCWdPtUA
I voted against the initiation of force.
Happy Halloween from Indonesia! May your day be spook-tacular, your night full of laughter, and your dreams delightfully eerie.
Asep Haryono
Kubu Raya, West Kalimantan – INDONESIA
youtube
many thanks. It goes to show the major difference in views that there are about the dangerous drug trade and about the brutal police commanders.
Hank
I can certainly understand why backers of Christian National Socialism would try to favourably impress past and current U.S. Governments. But why on earth would Brazilian police slaughter their own citizens?
Asep
thanks for reading the post. It is a very dangerous situation.
I hope you are not suggested that slaughtering Brazil's young men was part of the frightening Halloween experience. I assume not :)
There’s a Brazilian saying that “God made the world in six days, the seventh he devoted to Rio”. Blessed with one of the most dramatic and beautiful settings in the world, Rio de Janeiro never fails to impress its visitors. It is well worth visiting.
Yet Vila Cruzeiro is situated in a group of favelas/slums in the north zone of Rio de Janeiro, and it is notorious for high levels of violence.
Luxury Travel,
my husband went to a conference in Rio where he had the best conference and the best organised tours he has ever been to. But I am assuming the Rio police don't randomly kill citizens and visitors in gorgeous parts of the city.
People living in the favelas don't deserve normal human protections?
This is another example of the growing police violence against Brazilian citizens. The International Federation for Human Rights condemns the statements made by the Rio governor who has ignored the victims of the massacre and referred to them all as narco-terrorists . Similarly, we strongly reject the exploitation of violence and killings as a political strategy to gain electoral advantage. The State has the right and duty to punish criminal groups, but always with due process and not through extrajudicial executions.
International Federation
Every nation creates its own political, cultural, economic and legal systems, and clearly every state has the right and duty to punish criminal groups on its own land. But if Brazil police know or strongly suspect who are the drug criminals, why don't they pursue, arrest and try them in the court system?
"Due process" certainly includes courts and gaols, but not extrajudicial executions. Is it because Brazil doesn't have capital punishment and the police want the drug criminals dead as quickly as possible?
A drug raid, Hels? Where police killed many. It's the innocent that also get caught or killed; that's the worry.
Shocking, but apparently not worthy of too many column inches in the papers or minutes in the broadcasts. What a skewed world we live in.
Margaret
I am assuming all crims are innocent, until the police prove their evidence in court. In fact the police didn't even know who all the dead bodies were so they undressed the men, lay them out in the centre of the streets, and hoped the widows could identify at least some of them.
Imagine not knowing who you are killing :(
jabblog
I saw many newspaper articles covering the massacre on-line, from all over the world. But I didn't see any Brazilian papers, in Portuguese or translated. Was official censorship in control? Or were the Brazilian journalists afraid of what might happen to them?
Boa sexta-feira, bom final de semana e um excelente mês de novembro. Só quem já ficou no meio de um tiroteio entre policiais e bandidos, como eu fiquei. Sabe sobre essa triste realidade.
E eu chamo de Necropolítica. Já fazem política em cima dos cadaveres, pensando nas eleições de 2026.
Como sou brasileiro e da cidade do Rio de Janeiro. Afirmo fazem política em cima de muitos cadaveres. O tiroteio, fiquei num morro onde eu morava na Tijuca, Zona Norte do Rio de Janeiro.
Wow. That is horrible. It was painful just reading this.
Hi hels,
So, the authorities were conducting massive raids in the slums of Rio's favelas. The organised drug cartels run the place. My partner is Brazilian and lived in Rio for some time and told me about it. The average police don't even enter the favelas. The cartel can retaliate against the judiciary and police at any moment. I wonder how many hundreds of thousands of ordinary civilian brazilians are executed by these cartels each year. How can a state protect lives if they have ceded control to the criminal factions of schools, hospitals etc.
I think the authorities are trying to clean up the place. You can't just arrest them, or send out a court hearing summons letter. You need special forces to go in, and even then the drug traffickers' weapons are better than the police's; they're unlikely to surrender. Some were arrested, and some weren't. Were there mistakes, I have no doubt some. But the motives were good and they were trying to push back against the real predators of the community.
I support the authorities of Brazil in this operation.
I saw this story on Democracy now. We sure live in hard world.
Luiz
I know many countries have had shootouts between criminals and police in the past. But unless ordinary citizens see the murders themselves, or see the dead bodies lying in the centre of the roads, it is something that fades from memory within a week or two. This was unthinkable... you will never forget the pain.
Luiz
If there are elections due next year, it is very possible that the politicians _are_ giving the police orders, indeed playing politics on top of the corpses. I would have thought it would be impossible to extricate the true motives behind the slaughter, but I cannot find any Brazilian newspaper reports on line. Everything I have read comes from overseas newspapers and tv, church leaders and human rights organisations.
Erika
Absolutely true :( I was so devastated, I didn't sleep for the first 3 nights.
Liam
I realise drug traffickers are a blight on Rio's society and on half of the rest of the world as well. But even if the motives were good (which I doubt), mass murder is mass murder.
peppylady
thank goodness for some information.
Do you know who publishes Democracy Now, Brazil or a different country?
Its a tough part of the world and obviously there is a lot of conflicting information but 150 dead in the streets brutal in any language
kylie
conflicting information is inevitable, especially if it is so difficult to get local Rio-based news sources. ABC is saying protesters have marched through Vila Cruzeiro favela, demanding the resignation of Rio de Janeiro state Gov. Cláudio Castro. Hundreds of protesters on Friday marched through one of the favelas targeted in Rio de Janeiro's most lethal police raids, calling for Rio state Gov Cláudio Castro to resign amid continued outrage over the deadly operation. Castro is an ally of former President Jair Bolsonaro and opponent of leftist President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva.
On the other hand, Castro has accused the federal government of abandoning Rio in its fight against organised crime, a claim that Lula's administration has refuted.
Reafirmo o que te disse. Os governadores de vários estados de oposição ao Governo Lula. Já se se reuniram e fazem política pensando nas eleições de 2026. Eleições de Presidente da República, Governador e deputados federais. Essa é a realidade de quem acompanha de perto. Todos apoiadores do ex-presidente. Eu já morei em favela, não a que morreram muitas pessoas. Eu e minha irmã, ficamos no meio de um tiroteio entre policiais e bandidos. Só que a maioria desses governadores, literalmente escondem os índices de violência de seus estados. Não estão aí para a população ou as pessoas que perderam suas vidas. O interesse maior é a Presidência da República de 2026.
Sobre o abandono do Governo federal é mentira desse senhor. Não estou fazendo política. Ele sim. Ele é um dos piores governadores que já passaram pelo estado do Rio de Janeiro. Não é só a cidade do Rio de Janeiro que está abandonada por esse senhor. Tem cidades do estado do Rio de Janeiro que os bandidos tomaram conta. Só para ter uma noção: não se consegue entrar nem de carro ou motocicleta. E fala de quem conhece a realidade e vive aqui.
Luiz
I am quite open to political motivations behind police and army mass murders, in a number of countries. But if most of the Brazilian governors you refer to.. literally hide the violence rates in their states, there is little chance for the citizens to understand what is going on. Or to save their lives.
What a disaster.... a disaster that might well continue :(
Luiz
Rio de Janeiro enjoys some of the most beautiful culture, beaches, food and natural geography in the world. Yet because I understand poverty and crime, I was not surprised when my Brazilian friends migrated to other countries. Staying was dangerous.... leaving their parents and friends was very painful.
While I did read about the attack, putting personal voices to the story has more impact. Those who ordered the 'clean up' may well find themselves behind bars in The Hague, in company with former Philippines President Duterte.
Andrew
That is so true. Just in 2025 there have been massacres of civilians against Alawites in Syria; hundreds killed at El Fasher Sudanese hospital from RSF atrocities; Democratic Republic of the Congo saw brutal attacks on civilians by armed groups, including the Rwandan-backed M23 militia etc.
But the personal connection makes all the difference in the world. I am heartbroken about Rio.
😢😢😢😢
River
the mass murder of endless young men, without arrest or trial, is beyond any definition of civilised behaviour. Can you imagine asking the widows to walk along the streets, to see if they could identify any of the corpses.
I was diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease four years ago. Despite taking medications like Levodopa, my symptoms kept worsening tremors, balance issues, and fatigue made daily life difficult. Last year, I tried a herbal program from NaturePath Herbal Clinic, and within months, I noticed real improvements. My tremors eased, movements became smoother, and my energy and confidence returned.If you or a loved one is struggling with Parkinson’s, I highly recommend their natural approach. Visit www.naturepathherbalclinic.com
or email info@naturepathherbalclinic.com
Greta
thank you for reading the post. Have you been following the hideous news out of Rio?
Post a Comment